Hammoud Brothers P/L v NRMA Insurance Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read
CITATION: Hammoud Brothers P/L v NRMA Insurance Ltd [2004] NSWCA 1
HEARING DATE(S): 05/12/03
JUDGMENT DATE:
5 February 2004
JUDGMENT OF: Meagher JA at 1; Santow JA at 16
DECISION: Leave to appeal allowed; costs to be costs in the appeal.
CATCHWORDS: INSURANCE CLAUSES: Theft - fraud - onus of proof.
CASES CITED: Simon v NRMA Insurance Ltd (NSWCA, 22.10/1991, unrep.)
Anghelatos v Northern Assurance (The "Olympia") (1924) 19 LI. L. Rep. 255
Compania Naviera Vascongada v British & Foreign Marine Insurance Co ltd (The "Gloria") (1936) 54 LI. L. Rep. 35

PARTIES :

Hammoud Brothers Pty Ltd
v
NRMA Insurance Ltd
FILE NUMBER(S): CA 41219/02
COUNSEL: A: G O'L Reynolds SC & J Foord
R: R W Seton SC & Miss K Sant
SOLICITORS: A: RF Bergagnin & Co
R: Abbott Tout Solicitors
LOWER COURTJURISDICTION: District Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): 9115/02
LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :
Freeman DCJ


                          CA 41219/02

                          MEAGHER JA
                          SANTOW JA

                          Friday, 6 February 2004
HAMMOUD BROTHERS PTY LTD v NRMA INSURANCE LTD
Judgment

1 MEAGHER JA: There is before the Court an application for leave to appeal from a decision of Freeman DCJ dated 29 November 2002.

2 In order to assess the strength of the rival contentions, it is necessary to set out the salient facts.

3 The applicant company, Hammoud Brothers Pty Ltd (‘Hammoud Bros’), sued the opponent, NRMA Insurance Ltd (‘NRMA’), in the District Court under a policy of insurance. The claim was for the sum of $54,600, being the agreed value (less excess) of a motor vehicle registered to Hammoud Bros, and allegedly stolen on 12 or 13 August 2000.

4 The relevant clause of the insurance policy provided that if the insured vehicle was stolen, and not found, NRMA would pay out the insured value of the vehicle.

5 Conversely, the exclusion clause was expressed as follows: “this policy does not cover…loss or damage intentionally caused by you or a person acting with your express or implied consent”.

6 Against this background, the issues agitated before Freeman DCJ were essentially these: (a) whether Hammoud Bros had established, on the balance of probabilities, that the vehicle was stolen; viz., removed from their possession and control without their consent or connivance; and (b), on NRMA’s contention, whether the claim made in respect of the putative theft of the vehicle was a fraudulent one.

7 Mr R W Seton, learned senior counsel for NRMA, contended instead, and quite correctly, in my view, that the two issues outlined above were distinct considerations. Simon v NRMA Insurance Ltd (NSWCA, 22.10.1991, unrep.). On that view, it was for Hammoud Bros to establish theft, and for NRMA to negative that assertion by their allegation of fraud, if it were capable of proof. The ability successfully to establish one necessarily rules the other out.

8 Though, as Mr Seton pointed out in his written submissions, a non-finding of fraud is not commensurate with a finding of theft, in favour of Hammoud Bros.

9 Had matters been…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hammoud Brothers P/L v NRMA Insurance Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWCA 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hammoud Brothers Pty Ltd (the appellant) appealed to the New South Wales Court of Appeal against a decision of the primary judge concerning an insurance claim made against NRMA Insurance Ltd (the respondent). The dispute arose from a claim for loss due to theft, which the insurer had declined on the basis that the loss was not covered by the policy due to alleged fraud by the insured.

The central legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the primary judge had erred in finding that the appellant had failed to discharge the onus of proof that the loss was caused by theft within the meaning of the insurance policy. Specifically, the court considered whether the evidence presented established that the loss was a result of an unlawful taking of property, as opposed to other causes, and whether the insurer had successfully established fraud on the part of the appellant.

Meagher and Santow JJA allowed the appeal, finding that the primary judge had misapplied the onus of proof in relation to the fraud defence. The Court held that while the onus of proving the loss rests with the insured, the onus of proving fraud, which is an affirmative defence, rests with the insurer. The Court concluded that the insurer had not discharged its onus of proving fraud, and therefore the insured was entitled to succeed on its claim for loss by theft. The appeal was allowed, with costs to be costs in the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Leave to appeal allowed; costs to be costs in the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established