IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF QUEENSLAND
No. 1641 of 1998
BrisbaneBefore Williams J
[Hallam v Burns & Anor]
BETWEEN:
MURRAY JAMES HALLAM AND
GAIL MARGARET HALLAM
Plaintiffs
AND:
ROSS JAMES BURNS
First Defendant
AND:
DIANE MARIA BURNS
(AKA DIANE MARIA CAVALLARO)
Second Defendant
AND:
GLENN DALBY
Third Defendant
AND:
SUSAN MARGARET DALBY
Fourth Defendant
JUDGMENT - WILLIAMS J
Judgment delivered 11 December 1998
CATCHWORDS: Equity - Contribution between co-sureties - whether discharge of debt by principal debtor or guarantor - effect of assignment of original deed of loan to surety considered.
Counsel: D K Smith for plaintiffs
C Wilson for defendants
Solicitors:J N O’Donoghue for plaintiffs
Macgillivarys for defendants
Hearing Date: 12-14 October 1998
JUDGMENT - WILLIAMS J
Judgment delivered 11 December 1998
In the action the plaintiffs seek the following relief:
“1A declaration that the Plaintiffs are entitled to be subrogated to the rights of Heller Factors Pty Ltd in respect of securities given by the First and Second Defendants to Heller Factors Pty Ltd to secure obligations owed by Osprey Industries Pty Ltd.
2.Contribution from the Defendants in the sum of $107,618 as co-sureties for the debt of Osprey Industries Pty Ltd to Heller Factors Pty Ltd or in respect of such sums inclusive of interest as the Court determines.
3.In the alternative, for an order requiring the Defendants to exonerate the Plaintiffs’ in respect of the sum of $107,618.
4.In the further alternative, for exoneration and for interest on such sum at the rate of interest agreed between Heller Factors Pty Ltd, the Plaintiffs and the Defendants.
5.Alternatively, for interest at such rate and for such time as the Court shall think just.
6.Legal costs incurred by the Plaintiffs:
(a)Prior to the commencement of these proceedings in relation of the claim by Heller Factors Pty Ltd against the Plaintiffs as Guarantors;
(b)Of this action.”
At the end of the trial it seemed to me that the plaintiffs’ principal cause of action against the defendants was for contribution arising from the circumstances that all of the parties to the action were guarantors of the indebtedness of Osprey Industries Pty Ltd (“Osprey”) to Heller Factors Pty Ltd (“Heller”) and that the plaintiffs had (on their case) paid more than their due share of liability as co-sureties. The trial was complicated by a number of factors for which, in my ultimate view, the plaintiffs were primarily responsible and the resolution of factual disputes and proof of simple transactions was made vastly more difficult because of the failure of the plaintiffs to prosecute their claim for contribution promptly.
At the time of trial there was open antagonism between the plaintiffs on the one hand and the defendants on the other and that gave rise to many issues which were heatedly debated during the trial. Many of those, in my view, are irrelevant to the resolution of the ultimate issue. I have endeavoured in these reasons to deal only with matters which in my view are necessary to the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hallam v Burns and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] QSC 277
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the plaintiffs had not established that the balance of the amounts paid to Heller came from their personal funds or were paid in such circumstances as to be treated in equity as a payment by them personally. The court concluded that the true nature of the transaction was that Mirotone made available money by way of loan to Osprey to enable the latter to discharge its indebtedness to Heller. Therefore, the plaintiffs were not entitled to claim contribution for the full amount they had paid. The court allowed interest on $15,600 for a period of 3 years at 8% per annum.
The plaintiffs were entitled to contribution from the defendants with respect to the $15,600 and interest as stated. Upon satisfaction of that judgment, Mr. and Mrs. Burns would be entitled to redemption of the mortgages they gave to Heller and which have been assigned to the plaintiffs. The court will hear further submissions on the appropriate form of order, including orders as to costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland. It was a first-instance hearing where the plaintiffs sought various reliefs, including a declaration of their entitlement to be subrogated to the rights of Heller Factors Pty Ltd, contribution from the defendants, and exoneration from the defendants. The case involved a complex factual background, with disputes over the payments made by the plaintiffs to Heller, the true nature of those payments, and the circumstances surrounding the establishment and operation of various companies involved in the dispute. The trial was complicated by the failure of the plaintiffs to prosecute their claim for contribution promptly and the open antagonism between the parties.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to be subrogated to the rights of Heller Factors Pty Ltd in respect of securities given by the defendants.
2. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to contribution from the defendants for the excess amount paid as co-sureties.
3. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to interest on the amount of contribution from the defendants.
Held
1. The plaintiffs are not entitled to be subrogated to the rights of Heller Factors Pty Ltd in respect of securities given by the defendants.
2. The plaintiffs are entitled to contribution from the defendants for the excess amount paid as co-sureties, amounting to $15,600.
3. The plaintiffs are entitled to interest on the amount of contribution from the defendants at a rate of 8% per annum for a period of 3 years.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In addressing the issues raised in the case, the court examined the nature of the plaintiffs' payments to Heller Factors Pty Ltd and the circumstances under which those payments were made. The court found that the plaintiffs did not establish that they personally, as guarantors, made the final three payments to Heller on 14 November 1990, 10 December 1990, and 22 February 1991 in a manner that entitled them to be subrogated to the rights of Heller Factors Pty Ltd. The court concluded that the true nature of those transactions was that Mirotone made available money by way of loan to Osprey to enable the latter to discharge its indebtedness to Heller. As a result, the plaintiffs are not entitled to subrogation.
However, the court found that the plaintiffs were entitled to contribution from the defendants for the $15,600 they personally paid in reduction of the indebtedness of Osprey to Heller, after deducting the $1,800 that was the only part of the original loan used to satisfy a personal indebtedness of the plaintiffs. The court awarded interest on the amount of contribution from the defendants at a rate of 8% per annum for a period of 3 years, taking into account the unreasonable and illegal demands made by the plaintiffs against the defendants. The court held that the defendants are liable to pay the plaintiffs the amount of $15,600 plus interest as calculated, and upon satisfaction of that judgment, Mr. and Mrs. Burns would be entitled to redemption of the mortgages they gave to Heller and which have been assigned to the plaintiffs.
The court based its decision on the principle that a guarantor who pays more than their fair share of the principal debt is entitled to obtain contribution from fellow guarantors, in accordance with the equitable principle of contribution. The court distinguished the case from prior authority on the assignment of rights and the discharge of debts, as the principal debt had been discharged before the assignment in this case. The court also considered the defendants' good cause for believing that the plaintiffs were conducting the affairs of the companies in such a way as to benefit themselves and to disadvantage the defendants, which was relevant to the equitable principle of contribution.