FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Hall v Mercury Information Technology (South Australia) Pty Limited
[2002] FCA 272
GREGORY WINFIELD HALL in his capacity as Receiver & Manager of LAPTOP LAND (NSW) PTY LIMITED (RECEIVER & MANAGER APPOINTED) ACN 052 529 656 v MERCURY INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY (SOUTH AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED (Administrator Appointed) ACN 008 100 196 & ORS
N 3008 of 2002STONE J
18 MARCH 2002
SYDNEY
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
N 3008 OF 2002
BETWEEN:
GREGORY WINFIELD HALL in his capacity as Receiver & Manager of LAPTOP LAND (NSW) PTY LIMITED (RECEIVER & MANAGER APPOINTED) ACN 052 529 656
APPLICANTAND:
MERCURY INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY (SOUTH AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED (Administrator Appointed)
ACN 008 100 196
FIRST RESPONDENTMERCURY INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PTY LIMITED (Administrator Appointed) ACN 079 712 208
SECOND RESPONDENTLAPTOP LAND (QLD) PTY LIMITED ACN 089 859 861
THIRD RESPONDENTMERCURY INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY (VIC) PTY LIMITED ACN 095 700 897
FOURTH RESPONDENTMERCURY SERVICE GROUP PTY LIMITED
ACN 089 248 706
FIFTH RESPONDENTPERSONAL COMPUTER AUCTION PTY LIMITED
ACN 091 786 266
SIXTH RESPONDENTLAPTOP LAND (VIC) PTY LIMITED ACN 090 489 740
SEVENTH RESPONDENTLAPTOPS DIRECT.COM PTY LIMITED ACN 083 130 349
EIGHTH RESPONDENTMERCURY GROUP PTY LIMITED ACN 082 594 081
NINTH RESPONDENTLAPTOP LAND (SYDNEY) PTY LIMITED ACN 089 248 715
TENTH RESPONDENTMERCURY GROUP ADMINISTRATION PTY LIMITED ACN 089 248 699
ELEVENTH RESPONDENTMERCURY FINANCIAL SERVICES PTY LIMITED
ACN 097 037 039
TWELTH RESPONDENTGIGIDIN PTY LIMITED ACN 064 669 361
THIRTEENTH RESPONDENTRENT-A-LITE PTY LIMITED ACN 000 542 058
FOURTEENTH RESPONDENTIAN RUSSELL LOCK in his capacity as Administrator of MERCURY INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY (SOUTH AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED (Administrator Appointed)
ACN 008 100 196
FIFTEENTH RESPONDENTRONALD J DEAN-WILLCOCKS in his capacity as Administrator of MERCURY INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PTY LIMITED (Administrator Appointed) ACN 079 712 208
SIXTEENTH RESPONDENTJUDGE:
STONE J
DATE OF ORDER:
18 MARCH 2002
WHERE MADE:
SYDNEY
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1. The applicant has leave to proceed with this proceeding against the first and second respondent.
Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
N 3008 OF 2002
BETWEEN:
GREGORY WINFIELD HALL in his capacity as Receiver & Manager of LAPTOP LAND (NSW) PTY LIMITED (RECEIVER & MANAGER APPOINTED)
APPLICANTAND:
MERCURY INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY (SOUTH AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED (Administrator Appointed)
ACN 008 100 196
FIRST RESPONDENTMERCURY INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PTY LIMITED (Administrator Appointed) ACN 079 712 208
SECOND RESPONDENTLAPTOP LAND (QLD) PTY LIMITED ACN 089 859 861
THIRD RESPONDENTMERCURY INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY (VIC) PTY LIMITED ACN 095 700 897
FOURTH RESPONDENTMERCURY SERVICE GROUP PTY LIMITED
ACN 089 248 706
FIFTH RESPONDENTPERSONAL COMPUTER AUCTION PTY LIMITED ACN 091 786 266
SIXTH RESPONDENTLAPTOP LAND (VIC) PTY LIMITED ACN 090 489 740
SEVENTH RESPONDENTLAPTOPS DIRECT.COM PTY LIMITED ACN 083 130 349
EIGHTH RESPONDENTMERCURY GROUP PTY LIMITED ACN 082 594 081
NINTH RESPONDENT
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hall v Mercury Information Technology (South Australia) Pty... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] FCA 272
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues included whether the court should consider the intermingling of affairs between the respondent companies as a factor in granting leave. Additionally, the court had to assess the insolvency of MIT, which was conceded by the company through its solicitor, Mr Fordyce. The court also needed to decide whether the prima facie case of insolvency was sufficient for granting leave or if further discretionary considerations were required.
The court considered the evidence and submissions provided by Mr Hall and Ms Carolyn Rowe, who assisted him as a receiver and manager of Laptop. They highlighted the extensive services provided by Laptop to the Mercury IT Group, including acting as the registered office, keeping books and records, managing stock distribution, and handling finances, without charging any fees. This led to the anticipation that Laptop may become a creditor of most of the companies in the group once proper accounts were prepared. The court also noted the difficulties in gathering information about Laptop's stock, leases, and intercompany loans due to internal transfers and journal entries.
In its decision, the court granted Mr Hall leave to proceed with the proceeding against MIT(SA) and MIT. The court accepted that Laptop was a creditor of MIT(SA) and had standing to bring the application. It also considered the discretionary factors and found that the intermingling of affairs and the need for a single administration justified the grant of leave. The court acknowledged that while the insolvency of MIT was established, it was also necessary to consider other discretionary factors as per the relevant sections of the Corporations Act.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The applicant has leave to proceed with this proceeding against the first and second respondent.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: RONALD J
As the debt of $19,816 identified by Mr Hall was not otherwise challenged I accept for the purposes of s 459P that Laptop is a creditor of MIT(SA) and as such has standing under that section to bring this application against that company. Discretionary considerations It remains to consider the factors relevant to the exercise my discretion to grant leave to the applicant to continue with this proceeding under s 440D in relation to MIT(SA) and MIT and under s 459P(2) in relation to MIT. In relation to the grant of leave under s 459P(2) there is an additional constraint imposed by s 459P(3), which provides that:“The Court may give leave if satisfied that there is a prima facie case that the company is insolvent, but not otherwise.” In this case the insolvency requirement has been satisfied by MIT, through its solicitor, Mr Fordyce, conceding that it is insolvent. However, while a prima facie case of insolvency is a necessary condition for the grant of leave, it may not be sufficient; Melbase Corporation Pty Ltd v Segenhoe Ltd (1995) 17 ACSR 187 per Lindgren J at 190. Applicant’s evidence and submissions in relation to the granting of leave The applicant’s submissions that the Court should exercise its discretion to grant leave under both s 440D and s 459P(3) are based mainly on the allegation that the affairs of the respondent companies are so intermingled that cost and efficiency considerations dictate that there be a single administration by an independent person who, as provisional liquidator, would regularise the accounts of all the respondent companies. Once that has been done informed decisions could be made about the future of each company. In his affidavit of 7 March 2002, Mr Hall refers to some of the difficulties he has experienced in obtaining information about the affairs of Laptop. He states that Laptop had a central role within the Mercury IT Group in that:· most of the companies in the Group used its premises at 60 Miller Street North Sydney as their registered office and as their principal place of business;· Laptop kept the books and records for all of the companies within the Group except for MIT(SA) and one other company;· most, if not all, of the Group’s stock was acquired by Laptop and distributed to other trading companies within the Group. There were two exceptions to this practice one of which was MIT(SA);· it acted as treasurer for the Group collecting and distributing money within the Group as required;· it paid wages and related costs of employees within the Group with the exception of the employees of four companies including MIT(SA) and MIT.Despite these extensive services, no charges were made by Laptop. For this reason Mr Hall anticipates that Laptop may be a creditor of most of the companies in the Group once proper accounts were prepared. Further affidavit evidence was given by Ms Carolyn Rowe, a senior manager with PricewaterhouseCoopers who has been assisting Mr Hall in his work as receiver and manager of Laptop. In her affidavit of 7 March 2002, Ms Rowe identifies some of the difficulties that she has experienced in attempting to gather information about Laptop’s stock, leases and intercompany loans. She referred to the difficulty of identifying stock belonging to Laptop. She was told, for instance, that stock in boxes marked with the name of Laptop had been transferred to other companies within the Group by “internal transfer”. She was told that stock for MIT was ordered by Laptop and transferred by journal entry to MIT after delivery by the suppliers. On sale by MIT the money was banked in MIT’s account but that the bank account was “swept up” and transferred to Laptop. The same pattern occurred with purchases for MIT(SA). The process was similar with other Group companies except that most did not have bank accounts and in such cases the funds were paid directly into the Laptop account.