SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil)
HALL & ANOR v CITY OF BURNSIDE & ORS (No 10)
[2013] SASC 140
Reasons of Judge Dart a Master of the Supreme Court
5 September 2013
PROCEDURE - COSTS - TAXATION - PARTICULAR ITEMS
Item of work has a dual purpose - what allowance appropriate.
HALL & ANOR v CITY OF BURNSIDE & ORS (No 10)
[2013] SASC 140JUDGE DART:
A point of principle has arisen during the adjudication of a bill of costs.
The second defendant seeks an adjudication of a bill of costs prepared as a consequence of a costs order made by Justice Bleby on 28 March 2008. The proceeding before Justice Bleby was an application for judicial review challenging the validity of a development approval granted by the first defendant, the City of Burnside (“Council”), in favour of the second defendant, City Apartments Pty Ltd (“City Apartments”).
The issue to be determined is what allowance should be made for an item which was necessarily incurred for the litigation, but was also necessary for another purpose. For the reasons that follow, I propose to allow the claim for the item in full.
In the proceeding the plaintiffs agitated, inter alia, issues arising in relation to the building rules consent granted with respect to the construction of a retaining wall.
Separately and apart from the litigation, the plaintiffs complained to the Council about the design of the retaining wall and continued to agitate that issue with the Council. The complaint of the plaintiffs was that the design of the retaining wall and its footings was inadequate. I am advised by counsel that a Development Act 1993[1] notice was served on City Apartments with respect to the original design of the retaining wall. As a result, City Apartments were obliged to continue dealing with the Council on the subject of the retaining wall at the same time as contesting the proceeding.
[1] See s 84 Development Act 1993 (SA).
On 15 December 2006, well after the commencement of the proceeding, the Council made a variation to its building rules consent to permit a retaining wall with a revised design to be constructed. Eventually the proceeding was dismissed by Justice Bleby and the costs order followed the event.
The issue of principle which is said to arise is whether a particular item of work of a solicitor was necessary both for the conduct of proceedings in this Court, and also for dealing with the retaining wall issues raised by the Council, should be allowed in full or should be discounted.
The costs order provided for the costs to be adjudicated on a party and party basis. It also provided for some costs on an indemnity basis, but that related only to some costs incurred near the end of the proceedings. For present purposes, the fact that there was an order for some costs to be paid on an indemnity basis is not relevant.
At the heart of an order for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hall v City of Burnside (No 10) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] SASC 140
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to decide whether an item of work that was necessary for both the litigation and another purpose should be allowed in full or discounted. The costs order provided for the costs to be adjudicated on a party and party basis, meaning that City Apartments was entitled to be reimbursed for the costs reasonably incurred by it in the conduct of the litigation. The particular item in question was the drafting of a statement by Mr Jenkins regarding earthworks, which was necessary for both the litigation and dealing with the Council over the retaining wall design. Both parties agreed that the statement was reasonably necessary and that the amount claimed was appropriate.
The court considered the case of Ricciardi v Philmac Pty Ltd, where the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia held that costs necessary for one set of proceedings could be taxed in that Court if they were incidental to those proceedings. However, the court found Ricciardi to be of limited relevance to the current situation. Instead, the court concluded that the justice of the situation was best served by allowing City Apartments to recover fully for the item in question, as the work was necessary for the litigation and would have had to be undertaken regardless of its utility for another purpose. The court found that the fact that the work could be and was utilised for another purpose did not warrant a partial disallowance of the claim for costs.
The court's decision was that City Apartments should be allowed the full amount claimed for the drafting of the statement by Mr Jenkins. This decision was based on the principle that City Apartments was entitled to be reimbursed for the costs reasonably incurred by it in the conduct of the litigation, and the work in question was necessary for that purpose. The court did not find a sufficient reason to disallow part of the claim for costs, given the dual purpose of the work.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi