SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil)
HALL & ORS v CITY OF BURNSIDE & ORS
[2023] SASC 173
Decision of Judge Dart a Master of the Supreme Court
PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - COSTS - TAXATION AND OTHER FORMS OF ASSESSMENT - APPEAL, REVIEW OR REFERENCE
Taxation of costs - large number of items taxed - lump sum assessment adopted for balance of the bill - nature of lump sum assessment - ex tempore judgment delivered - applicants seek review of the outcome - nature of a review - review grounds not made out.
Held:
1. Review dismissed.
2. Applicants to pay the second respondent's costs of the review.
Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) r 195.9 and r 195.12; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 271(6), referred to.
Bayley & Associates Pty Ltd v DBR Australia Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 346; Catto & Ors v Hampton Australia Ltd (In Liq) & Ors [2008] SASC 231, considered.
HALL & ORS v CITY OF BURNSIDE & ORS
[2023] SASC 173
The first and second applicants in this proceeding seek a review of a decision made to progress a taxation of costs. The application for review is dismissed.
Background
This proceeding commenced in 2006. It started with an application for an interlocutory injunction to restrain the respondents from proceeding with the construction of a residential property on land adjacent to the land of the applicants.
The second respondent was the developer of the residential property. It obtained the relevant approvals from the first respondent to proceed. The basis for the injunction was a complaint about the approved retaining wall. It was alleged it was not sufficiently engineered to perform the task that was required of it.
The land is sloping, and it was necessary for a retaining wall to be built once the relevant block was excavated for the purpose of footings. The matter resolved when a new planning approval was granted for an improved design of the retaining wall.
In 2007 Bleby J made costs orders requiring the first and second applicants to pay the costs of the second respondent. Some of the costs were awarded on an indemnity basis.
The taxation for the claim for costs has been a long and tedious process. The claim for costs extends to more than 3,000 items. Along the way a number of judgments have been delivered in relation to various issues of principle. Usually matters such as this eventually become capable of settlement. Not so this matter.
A part of the difficulty in undertaking the taxation has been that the lawyers and engineers involved in the litigation were also involved in the dealings with the first respondent in relation to gaining approval for the variation of the retaining wall design.
It has been necessary to remove from the claim for costs the costs of the lawyers and engineers which related to dealings with the City of Burnside for the variation. Those issues did not form part…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hall v City of Burnside and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] SASC 173
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court emphasised that the lump sum taxation process was appropriate in this case due to the complexity and length of the litigation. It noted that the applicants' claims for greater deductions were speculative and not based on concrete evidence. The court found that the applicants had not demonstrated that the lump sum assessment was unfair or unreasonable. Therefore, the review application was dismissed, and the taxation outcome was confirmed. The applicants' claims for greater deductions were rejected as speculative and not supported by the evidence. The court upheld the lump sum assessment as fair and reasonable under the circumstances.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The first and second applicants seek a review of the taxation outcome. The grounds of review are as follows:[9]1.In making the orders the court has not given sufficient weight to the matters referred to in the Applicants’ submissions FDN 159 and, in particular, in paragraphs 1-7, 12‑33, 35, 36-37, and 38-44 thereof.2.The application of a 55% reduction for solicitor’s fees to arrive at a lump sum is insufficient to arrive at a fair and reasonable result having regard to the matters referred to in the said paragraphs 12-33 and 35.3.The application of a 32% reduction for counsel fees to arrive at a lump sum is insufficient to arrive at a fair and reasonable result having regard to the matters referred to in the said paragraphs 35 and 38-44.4.Alternatively, it would have been reasonable to tax counsel fees in the normal way having regard to the matters referred to in the said paragraphs 35 and 38-44.5.The allowance of $2,000 for miscellaneous disbursements was made when the nature and status of those amounts remained in question and uncertain as insufficient information had been provided, and does not sufficiently allow for the matters referred to in the said paragraphs 36 and 37.[9] Application to Registrar, FDN 172 , filed 27 October 2022.Consideration The first ground of review is a catch all. It covers the matters which are set out more specifically in the other four grounds of review. In suggesting that I did not give sufficient weight to the applicants’ written submissions, I expect what is meant is that I erred in failing to accept those submissions. There is no real need to deal with ground of review one because the other four grounds deal in a more specific way with the complaints of the applicants. Grounds of review two and three are the substantive complaints. The applicants contend that if the taxation proceeded, the second respondent’s position would have worsened. A taxation where 55% of solicitor’s fees are taxed off is a rare outcome. It arose because of the mixing of litigation costs and the costs of negotiating with the Council about planning matters. The same issue caused the 32% reduction for counsel fees. The critical question on review is whether there is merit in the applicants’ submission that if the taxation had proceeded the reductions would have been greater for the remaining items. This is a very unusual taxation. The Court does not normally have the advantage, on a lump sum assessment, of having taxed 1,400 items. That is a very large sample size. I am not convinced that the applicants are correct that, if the taxation had continued, the deduction of solicitor and counsel fees would have been greater than for the items taxed. I regard the applicants’ position as optimistic speculation. There is an equal prospect, in my view, that if the taxation had continued that the position of the second respondent would have improved. That is, the percentage of solicitor’s and counsel fees to be taxed off would have diminished. There was a real prospect of that occurring. If that is correct, then the outcome achieved on the lump sum taxation was generous to the applicants.