Hainey v Jeld_WEN Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 

CITATION:

Hainey v JELD_WEN Australia Pty Ltd [2022] NSWPIC 265

APPLICANT: Kathleen Hainey
RESPONDENT: JELD_WEN Australia Pty Ltd
MEMBER: Cameron Burge
DATE OF DECISION: 2 June 2022
CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Claim for weekly compensation in respect of alleged psychological injury; injury pleaded as aggravation of underlying condition; respondent alleges cause of aggravation multi-factorial and that applicant not totally incapacitated as alleged; Held-In matters where an injury is pleaded by way of an aggravation or exacerbation, the relevant test is whether the employment is the main contributing factor to the aggravation or exacerbation, not to the underlying condition; Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch; Kelly v Western Institute NSW TAFE Commission; Ariton Mitic v Rail Corporation of; Meaney v Office of Environments and Heritage - National Parks and Wildlife at [138]-[147] followed; the meaning of “Main contributing factor” is “principal” or “primary”, and there can be but one main contributing factor”; AV v AW applied; in this matter, there is no issue the applicant suffered a pre-existing psychological condition; nor is there any issue she had endured a number of non-work-related stressors; however, despite those stressors she was able to carry out full time employment with the respondent until her workplace problems with her former manager culminated in her leaving work; the evidence, in particular contemporaneous file notes from human resources, demonstrates the applicant’s former manager acknowledged the alleged issues in the work place and that he had not acted appropriately towards the applicant; a common sense evaluation of the lay and medical evidence supports a finding the applicant’s employment with the respondent was the main contributing factor to the aggravation of her pre-existing condition which in turn led to her absence from work; Kooragang Cement Pty Ltd v Bates referred to; the balance of the evidence also discloses the applicant remains totally incapacitated for employment; even though the respondent demonstrated that from time to time the applicant attended a local store and also went to her own birthday celebration, in my view that evidence does not equate to a capacity for employment; the applicant was cross examined at length as to her capacity, and her evidence as to her ongoing problems with employment is accepted as that of a witness of truth; respondent ordered to pay the applicant weekly compensation as claimed.  

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

1.     The applicant suffered a psychological injury by way of aggravation of a pre-existing condition in the course of her employment with the respondent, with a deemed date of injury of 20 January 2020.

2.     As a result of the injury referred to in (1) above, the applicant has been and remains totally incapacitated for employment.

3.     The applicant was paid weekly benefits up to 17 April 2020, at which point liability for her claim was denied.

4.     At the date of her injury, the applicant’s preinjury average weekly earnings (PIAWE) were $1,153.85 per week.

5.     The respondent is to pay the applicant weekly compensation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hainey v Jeld_WEN Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWPIC 265
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant in this case, Hainey, brought a claim against Jeld_WEN Australia Pty Ltd for weekly compensation relating to an alleged psychological injury. Hainey contended that the injury was an aggravation of an underlying condition, which was exacerbated by her employment with the respondent. The respondent, however, argued that the cause of the aggravation was multi-factorial and that Hainey was not as incapacitated as she claimed. The case was heard in the relevant workers' compensation tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the tribunal was whether Hainey's employment with the respondent was the main contributing factor to the aggravation of her pre-existing psychological condition. This issue required consideration of several key legal principles, including the tests established in previous cases such as Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch and Kelly v Western Institute NSW TAFE Commission. The tribunal needed to determine if Hainey's work environment and her relationship with her former manager were the principal factors leading to her incapacity, despite other stressors in her life.

In resolving the matter, the tribunal closely examined the evidence presented by both parties. Hainey provided evidence of her ongoing psychological issues and the impact of her workplace environment on her mental health. The tribunal noted that Hainey had been able to work full time until her employment issues escalated, indicating a clear link between her work and her condition. The tribunal found that the evidence, including contemporaneous file notes from human resources, supported the conclusion that Hainey's employment was indeed the main contributing factor to her incapacity. The tribunal accepted Hainey's evidence as truthful and concluded that she remained totally incapacitated for employment.

The tribunal ordered Jeld_WEN Australia Pty Ltd to pay Hainey the weekly compensation she had claimed. This decision was based on the finding that her employment was the primary cause of the aggravation of her pre-existing psychological condition, leading to her incapacity for work.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Hainey, made a claim for weekly compensation for an alleged psychological injury that she pleaded as an aggravation of an underlying condition. Hainey's employment with the respondent, Jeld-WEN Australia Pty Ltd, ended when she left work due to workplace issues with her former manager. The respondent argued that the cause of the aggravation was multi-factorial and that Hainey was not totally incapacitated as alleged. Hainey maintained that her employment with the respondent was the main contributing factor to the aggravation of her pre-existing condition, which led to her absence from work.

Hainey had a history of psychological issues prior to her employment with the respondent, and she experienced several non-work-related stressors during that time. However, despite these stressors, Hainey was able to maintain full-time employment until the workplace issues with her former manager arose. There were contemporaneous file notes from human resources that demonstrated the former manager acknowledged the alleged issues in the workplace and had not acted appropriately towards Hainey. The evidence, including lay and medical testimony, supported that Hainey's employment with the respondent was the main contributing factor to the aggravation of her pre-existing condition.

This case was heard in the Australian court as a claim for workers' compensation. Hainey filed a claim against Jeld-WEN Australia Pty Ltd for weekly compensation due to an alleged psychological injury, which she pleaded as an aggravation of an underlying condition. The respondent contested the claim, arguing that the cause of the aggravation was multi-factorial and that Hainey was not totally incapacitated as alleged. The matter proceeded to a final hearing where the court considered the evidence and legal principles before making its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant's employment with the respondent was the main contributing factor to the aggravation of her pre-existing psychological condition?
2. Whether the applicant remains totally incapacitated for employment?

Held
1. The court held that the applicant's employment with the respondent was the main contributing factor to the aggravation of her pre-existing psychological condition. The appeal was dismissed.
2. The court held that the applicant remains totally incapacitated for employment. The respondent was ordered to pay the applicant weekly compensation as claimed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In this case, the court was tasked with determining whether the applicant's employment with the respondent was the main contributing factor to the aggravation of her pre-existing psychological condition and whether the applicant remains totally incapacitated for employment. The court applied the legal principle that in matters where an injury is pleaded by way of an aggravation or exacerbation, the relevant test is whether the employment is the main contributing factor to the aggravation or exacerbation, not to the underlying condition. This principle was derived from cases such as Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch, Kelly v Western Institute NSW TAFE Commission, and Ariton Mitic v Rail Corporation of. The court also referred to Meaney v Office of Environments and Heritage - National Parks and Wildlife, which outlined that the meaning of "Main contributing factor" is "principal" or "primary", and there can be but one main contributing factor. This was further supported by the case of AV v AW.

In applying these principles to the facts of this case, the court found that there was no issue that the applicant suffered from a pre-existing psychological condition and had endured non-work-related stressors. However, despite these stressors, the applicant was able to carry out full-time employment with the respondent until workplace problems with her former manager culminated in her leaving work. The court considered the evidence, including contemporaneous file notes from human resources, which demonstrated the applicant’s former manager acknowledged the alleged issues in the workplace and had not acted appropriately towards the applicant. The court conducted a common sense evaluation of the lay and medical evidence, which supported a finding that the applicant’s employment with the respondent was the main contributing factor to the aggravation of her pre-existing condition, leading to her absence from work.

Furthermore, the court considered the balance of the evidence regarding the applicant's total incapacity for employment. Although the respondent demonstrated that the applicant occasionally attended a local store and went to her own birthday celebration, the court found that this evidence did not equate to a capacity for employment. The applicant was cross-examined at length about her capacity, and her evidence regarding her ongoing problems with employment was accepted as that of a witness of truth. Therefore, the court held that the applicant remains totally incapacitated for employment, and the respondent was ordered to pay the applicant weekly compensation as claimed.