Hailu and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

Hailu and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2019] AATA 982 (30 April 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2018/6788

Re:Mulugeta Hailu

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Ms Anna Burke AO, Member

Date:30 April 2019

Date of written reasons:        23 May 2019

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

[sgd]........................................................................

Ms Anna Burke AO, Member

Catchwords

CHILD SUPPORT – Departure Prohibition Order (“DPO”) – no grounds requiring revocation of DPO – no grounds for exercising discretion to revoke DPO – decision under review affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988

Cases

O'Neill and Child Support Registrar [2010] AATA 545

Secondary Materials

Australian Government, Child Support Guide, Version 4.38 (4 February 2019)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms Anna Burke AO, Member

23 May 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 22 October 2018 the Child Support Registrar (Registrar) made a decision to refuse to revoke the Departure Prohibition Order (DPO) against Mr Hailu under s 72I of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Collection Act). Mr Hailu is seeking a review of this decision.

  2. The application was heard on 30 April 2019. Mr Hailu was self-represented. Mr Adam Cunynghame of Sparke Helmore Lawyers appeared for the respondent. The Tribunal was assisted by the services of an Amharic interpreter.

  3. The Tribunal provided an oral decision at the conclusion of the hearing, affirming the decision under review. Mr Hailu subsequently requested written reasons for the decision in accordance with s 43(2A) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. These are those reasons.

    BACKGROUND

  4. Mr Hailu is a 56-year-old Australian citizen, originally from Ethiopia, who is self-employed as a taxi driver. Mr Hailu is divorced and has three children, for whom he has a child support liability which will end in 2024 when his youngest child turns 18. Mr Hailu’s         ex-partner had requested the Registrar calculate and collect child support in respect of their three children on her behalf.

  5. On 3 September 2018 a delegate of the Registrar issued Mr Hailu a DPO under s 72D of the Collection Act. In the submission to make the DPO the delegate noted that:

    ·Mr Hailu’s monthly liability is $35;

    ·since September 2011 collection arrangements from Mr Hailu have strictly been by way of enforcement; and payments have only been received via withholding of Centrelink payments that Mr Hailu has intermittently received;

    ·Mr Hailu has been in arrears since 7 November 2013;

    ·the Child Support Agency’s (the Agency) last contact with Mr Hailu was 23 October 2017, when he advised that he did not agree with the arrears and did not offer to make any payments;

    ·in February 2018 Mr Hailu’s ex-partner confirmed she would like the Agency to continue to seek outstanding arrears. At that stage Mr Hailu had an outstanding child support liability of $10,141.83;

    ·the last child support collection was on 6 June 2018 via a Centrelink deduction of $49.11;

    ·on 23 February 2018 Mr Hailu listed his occupation on an incoming…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hailu and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 982
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Hailu to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) regarding a Departure Prohibition Order (DPO) issued to him under the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1984 (Collection Act). Mr Hailu, a self-employed taxi driver, had a child support liability for his three children, which was due to end in 2024. The DPO was issued due to persistent failure to meet his child support obligations, significant arrears, and a history of payments only being received through enforcement mechanisms, such as Centrelink deductions. Mr Hailu had also travelled overseas multiple times and transferred substantial sums of money abroad.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Mr Hailu's DPO should be revoked. This required the Tribunal to consider the grounds for revocation under section 72I of the Collection Act, which include the person no longer having a child support liability, having made satisfactory arrangements to discharge the liability, or the liability being irrecoverable. The Tribunal also had to consider whether to exercise its discretion under section 72I(3) to revoke the DPO if it considered it desirable to do so.

The Tribunal reasoned that Mr Hailu did not meet the statutory grounds for revocation. Firstly, he had a significant outstanding child support debt, and the Tribunal lacked jurisdiction to review the assessment of this liability, which Mr Hailu disputed. Secondly, the Tribunal found that Mr Hailu had not made satisfactory arrangements to discharge his substantial arrears, noting that his proposed monthly payments would take many years to clear the debt and that his payment history indicated a persistent failure to meet his obligations. Consequently, the Tribunal determined that it was not desirable to exercise its discretion to revoke the DPO.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, meaning the DPO remained in force.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal provided an oral decision at the conclusion of the hearing, affirming the decision under review. Mr Hailu subsequently requested written reasons for the decision in accordance with s 43(2A) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. These are those reasons.BACKGROUND Mr Hailu is a 56-year-old Australian citizen, originally from Ethiopia, who is self-employed as a taxi driver. Mr Hailu is divorced and has three children, for whom he has a child support liability which will end in 2024 when his youngest child turns 18. Mr Hailu’s ex-partner had requested the Registrar calculate and collect child support in respect of their three children on her behalf. On 3 September 2018 a delegate of the Registrar issued Mr Hailu a DPO under s 72D of the Collection Act. In the submission to make the DPO the delegate noted that: ·Mr Hailu’s monthly liability is $35;·since September 2011 collection arrangements from Mr Hailu have strictly been by way of enforcement; and payments have only been received via withholding of Centrelink payments that Mr Hailu has intermittently received; ·Mr Hailu has been in arrears since 7 November 2013;·the Child Support Agency’s (the Agency) last contact with Mr Hailu was 23 October 2017, when he advised that he did not agree with the arrears and did not offer to make any payments;·in February 2018 Mr Hailu’s ex-partner confirmed she would like the Agency to continue to seek outstanding arrears. At that stage Mr Hailu had an outstanding child support liability of $10,141.83;·the last child support collection was on 6 June 2018 via a Centrelink deduction of $49.11;·on 23 February 2018 Mr Hailu listed his occupation on an incoming passenger card as self-employed; and·Mr Hailu has travelled overseas three times between January 2016 and February 2018 for periods of up to six months. On 20 October 2018 the delegate of the Registrar determined that the DPO should not be revoked and, in addition to the information noted above, noted that Mr Hailu had transferred $11,334 overseas between April 2015 and August 2018.THE ISSUES IN CONTENTION The issue in contention is whether Mr Hailu’s DPO should be revoked in accordance with the Collection Act.RELEVANT LEGISLATION Section 72D of the Collection Act gives the Registrar the power to make a DPO. The Child Support Guide explains: A DPO prevents a person who has persistently failed to meet their child support liability commitments, or carer liability commitments, from leaving Australia without either discharging all debts or making satisfactory arrangements to do so. A DPO places significant restrictions on the freedom of movement of citizens and residents of Australia and visitors to Australia, and will not be made without consideration of all relevant circumstances Where a DPO is in force, the Registrar can vary or revoke the DPO, or can issue a departure authorisation certificate (DAC). Section 3 of the Collection Act states that the principal objects of the Act are to ensure: (a) that children receive from their parents the financial support that the parents are liable to provide; and (b) that periodic amounts payable by parents towards the maintenance of their children are paid on a regular and timely basis; and (c) that Australia is in a position to give effect to its obligations under international agreements or arrangements relating to maintenance obligations arising from family relationship, parentage or marriage. (2) It is the intention of the Parliament that this Act shall be construed and administered, to the greatest extent consistent with the attainment of its objects, to limit interferences with the privacy of persons.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal, having considered all the evidence placed before it, found that Mr Hailu did not meet the requirements of s 72l of the Collection Act for the DPO to be revoked; nor was his situation such that it was desirable for the Tribunal to exercise its discretion to revoke the DPO. DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 72I(3) of the Collection Act provides that the Registrar may also revoke a DPO at their own discretion: 3) The Registrar may also, at the Registrar's discretion, revoke or vary a departure prohibition order in respect of a person if the Registrar considers it desirable to do so.CONSIDERATION The respondent tendered in evidence a certificate issued under s 116(2) of the Collection Act certifying that at 29 April 2019 Mr Hailu had a child support debt of $10,190.01 and penalties of $3,373.18. Person no longer has a child support liability Mr Hailu disputes the calculation of the liability, arguing that he has submitted tax returns which have not been taken into account in the calculation of his child support liability. As the Tribunal explained to Mr Hailu at numerous stages, the Tribunal did not have jurisdiction to reconsider the liability. However, it was open to Mr Hailu to challenge the amount in dispute by seeking a change of assessment or by applying to the Federal Court of Australia. Mr Hailu advised the Tribunal that he had not sought a review of his liability. The Tribunal's jurisdiction under s 72T of the Collection Act is relevantly limited to a review of the Registrar's decision under s 72I; that is, the refusal to revoke Mr Hailu's DPO. The Tribunal’s jurisdiction does not extend to a review of the initial decision to impose the DPO. Nor does s 72T of the Collection Act empower the Tribunal to review the basis for the assessment of Mr Hailu's liability. Therefore, the Tribunal accepts the assessment under s 116(2) of the Collection Act as a valid assessment. As such, Mr Hailu has a child support liability and cannot fulfil s 72l(1)(a) of the Collection Act for his DPO to be revoked.The person has made arrangements to satisfy the Registrar the liability has been made or will be wholly discharged Mr Hailu argued that he had sought to make arrangements with the Registrar to discharge the liability and had made voluntary payments of $105 on 16 October 2018 and $106.80 on 15 January 2019. Mr Hailu told the Tribunal: “What I want today is to be able to travel. If this is resolved we can negotiate how much I need to pay each month. I will make a promise to pay. I just want to be a free man and I will pay how much I can afford.” The respondent argued that given the size of the debt, it will take Mr Hailu 13 years to discharge the debt at the amount of $100-$150 a month. The respondent pointed to Mr Hailu’s lengthy history of failing to pay child support and that payments have only been received via garnisheeing Mr Hailu’s Centrelink benefits as evidence that Mr Hailu had not entered into a repayment arrangement which was satisfactory to the Registrar. The Tribunal found that Mr Hailu had not entered into a satisfactory arrangement to discharge his child support liability; and therefore he did not fulfil the requirements of s 72l(1)(b) of the Collection Act for his DPO to be revoked.The registrar is satisfied that the liability is completely irrecoverable