Haile-Michael v Konstantinidis (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Haile-Michael v Konstantinidis (No 3) [2013] FCA 53

Citation: Haile-Michael v Konstantinidis (No 3) [2013] FCA 53
Parties: DANIEL HAILE-MICHAEL, JIBRIL GOD, SHUAB ALI, MAKI ISSA, HAKIM HASSAN and MAGNUS KABA v NICK KONSTANTINIDIS, SHANE DAVIES, NICK O'BRIEN, PAUL GILMOUR, CHIEF COMMISSIONER OF VICTORIA POLICE and STATE OF VICTORIA
File number: VID 969 of 2010
Judges: JESSUP J
Date of judgment: 5 February 2013
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for particular discovery under r 20.21 of Federal Court Rules 2011 – where documents sought by applicants not part of respondents’ case – where applicants claim that documents necessary to test respondents’ defence – where extensive discovery previously ordered

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to set aside subpoenas – whether application more appropriately dealt with by trial Judge

Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011
Date of hearing: 4 February 2013
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: CATCHWORDS
Number of paragraphs: 21
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr J Rapke SC, Mr E Nekvapil and Ms P Knowles
Solicitor for the Applicants: Arnold Bloch Leibler
Counsel for the First, Third, Fourth and Fifth Respondents: Mr R Niall SC with Ms R Sharp
Solicitor for the First, Third, Fourth and Fifth Respondents: Maddocks Lawyers
Counsel for the Eighth and Ninth Respondents: Dr G Lyon SC, Ms R Orr and Ms E Dias
Solicitor for the Eighth and Ninth Respondents: Norton Rose

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 969 of 2010

BETWEEN:

DANIEL HAILE-MICHAEL
Third Applicant

JIBRIL GOD
Fifth Applicant

SHUAB ALI
Eighth Applicant

MAKI ISSA
Twelfth Applicant

HAKIM HASSAN
Thirteenth Applicant

MAGNUS KABA
Fourteenth Applicant

AND:

NICK KONSTANTINIDIS
First Respondent

SHANE DAVIES
Third Respondent

NICK O'BRIEN
Fourth Respondent

PAUL GILMOUR
Fifth Respondent

CHIEF COMMISSIONER OF VICTORIA POLICE
Eighth Respondent

STATE OF VICTORIA
Ninth Respondent

JUDGE:

JESSUP J

DATE OF ORDER:

5 FEBRUARY 2013

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.By 4.15 pm on 7 February 2013, the eighth and ninth respondents file an affidavit or affidavits stating whether and if so which documents of the description referred to in the Schedule to this order are or have been in their control or in the control of either of them and, to the extent that any such document or documents has or have been but is or are no longer in his or its control, stating when the document or documents was last in his or its control and what became of the document or documents.

Schedule

Powerpoint presentations, seminar notes or papers that were prepared for, presented or handed out during multicultural awareness training presentations to officers of Victoria Police, referred to in the following paragraphs of the following outlines of evidence filed by the Eighth and Ninth Respondents in this proceeding:
(a)       paragraph 36 Outline of Evidence of Daniel Bonnici;
(b)       paragraph 33 Outline of Evidence of David Daly;
(c)       paragraph 9 Outline of Evidence of Natalie McFarlane;
(d)       paragraph 20 Outline of Evidence of Vince Zurzolo;
(e)       paragraph 9 Outline of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Haile-Michael v Konstantinidis (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 53
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Haile-Michael v Konstantinidis (No 3) involved the applicants seeking particular discovery of documents from the respondents under rule 20.21 of the Federal Court Rules 2011. The applicants argued that the documents in question were necessary to test the respondents' defence. The respondents, however, contended that the documents sought were not part of their case and that the subpoenas issued should be set aside.

The legal issues before the court were whether the documents sought by the applicants were necessary for the testing of the respondents' defence and whether the application to set aside the subpoenas was more appropriately dealt with by the trial judge. The court had to determine the scope of the discovery sought and whether the subpoenas were justified.

In its reasoning, the court found that the documents sought by the applicants were not part of the respondents' case, but the applicants claimed they were necessary to test the respondents' defence. The court noted that extensive discovery had already been ordered. Regarding the application to set aside the subpoenas, the court considered that the matter was more appropriately dealt with by the trial judge. The court ordered the respondents to file an affidavit regarding the documents in question and refused the relief sought by the applicants in their interlocutory application. The court also directed that the subpoenas be adjourned until a later date.

The final orders of the court included directives for the respondents to file an affidavit regarding the documents sought, refusal of the interlocutory application, and the adjournment of the subpoenas. The costs of the interlocutory application were to be paid by the applicants, subject to certain conditions. The further hearing of the respondents' application and the costs of that application were also reserved. The court further directed that an outline of the evidence proposed to be led from certain witnesses be filed by the applicants.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. By 4.15 pm on 7 February 2013, the eighth and ninth respondents file an affidavit or affidavits stating whether and if so which documents of the description referred to in the Schedule to this order are or have been in their control or in the control of either of them and, to the extent that any such document or documents has or have been but is or are no longer in his or its control, stating when the document or documents was last in his or its control and what became of the document or documents.

Schedule

Powerpoint presentations, seminar notes or papers that were prepared for, presented or handed out during multicultural awareness training presentations to officers of Victoria Police, referred to in the following paragraphs of the following outlines of evidence filed by the Eighth and Ninth Respondents in this proceeding:

(a) paragraph 36 Outline of Evidence of Daniel Bonnici;

(b) paragraph 33 Outline of Evidence of David Daly;

(c) paragraph 9 Outline of Evidence of Natalie McFarlane;

(d) paragraph 20 Outline of Evidence of Vince Zurzolo;

(e) paragraph 9 Outline of Evidence of Nigel Howard.

2. Save as aforesaid, the relief sought in the applicant’s Interlocutory Application filed on 18 January 2013 be refused.

3. Subject to

(a) Order 10 made by the court on 8 April 11; and

(b) the right of the eighth and ninth respondents to invoke the operation of r 40.51(2)(d) of the Federal Court Rules 2011,

the applicants pay the costs of the eighth and ninth respondents of the applicants’ Interlocutory Application filed on 18 January 2013.

4. The further hearing of the Interlocutory Application filed on behalf of the eighth and ninth respondents on 29 January 2013 be adjourned to 10.15 am on 11 February 2013.

5. The costs of that application be reserved.

6. To the extent they impose an obligation to produce documents, the operation of the subpoenas dated 18 January 2013 addressed to Inspector Mark Doney and to Chief Commissioner Ken D Lay be adjourned to 10.15 am on 11 February 2013.

7. By 4.15 pm on 7 February 2013, the applicants file and serve an outline of the evidence proposed to be led from Senior Sergeant Craig Rhodes, Inspector Anthony Langdon, Inspector Mark Doney, Chief Commissioner Ken D Lay, Sergeant Joseph Herrech and Senior Constable Sahin Sahinkaya.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case, Haile-Michael v Konstantinidis (No 3), pertains to an application for particular discovery under rule 20.21 of the Federal Court Rules 2011, and an application to set aside subpoenas. The applicants seek specific documents related to multicultural awareness training presentations made to officers of Victoria Police, which were referenced in the outlines of evidence by several respondents. These documents are not part of the respondents' case, but the applicants argue they are necessary to test the respondents' defence. The court had previously ordered extensive discovery, and the current applications are seeking further clarification and documentation regarding the training materials and their availability.

This matter is an application for particular discovery and to set aside subpoenas, brought under the Federal Court Rules 2011. The application was filed on 18 January 2013, with a response submitted by the respondents on 29 January 2013. The court heard the applications on the same day as the response was filed, and made orders on the same day. The orders required the eighth and ninth respondents to file affidavits regarding the documents in question, and set a timeline for the applicants to provide an outline of the evidence they intend to present from certain witnesses. The court also reserved the costs of the application and adjourned the further hearing of the respondents' application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the documents sought by the applicants, specifically the PowerPoint presentations, seminar notes, or papers related to multicultural awareness training for Victoria Police officers, are in the control of the eighth and ninth respondents.
2. Whether the applicants are entitled to further particulars regarding the documents to test the respondents' defence.
3. Whether the operation of the subpoenas addressed to Inspector Mark Doney and Chief Commissioner Ken D Lay should be adjourned to allow for further clarification and documentation.

Held
1. The court ordered the eighth and ninth respondents to file an affidavit stating whether documents related to multicultural awareness training for Victoria Police officers are or have been in their control, and if so, to provide details on their status and disposition.
2. The court refused the relief sought in the applicants' interlocutory application, except as specified in the order.
3. The operation of the subpoenas addressed to Inspector Mark Doney and Chief Commissioner Ken D Lay was adjourned to allow for further clarification and documentation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the application for particular discovery under r 20.21 of the Federal Court Rules 2011, which concerned documents not part of the respondents' case but claimed necessary by the applicants to test the respondents' defence. The court noted that extensive discovery had already been ordered. It held that the eighth and ninth respondents must provide an affidavit stating whether they had the sought documents, and if so, their status and disposition. The court refused other relief sought by the applicants, noting the extensive prior discovery and the right of the respondents to invoke certain rules regarding costs. Regarding the subpoenas, the court decided to adjourn their operation to allow for further clarification and documentation. This decision recognised the need for further evidence and documentation, while also protecting the rights of the respondents. The ratio here pertains to the management of discovery processes and the need for clarity in document control and disposition in complex litigation.