Haigh Australia Pty Ltd v T-Max Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Oppositions by Haigh Australia Pty Ltd to applications by T-Max Australia Pty Ltd to remove trade mark registrations 1037077 (7, 11, 12 & 22) T-Max Logo and 1103086 (7, 8 & 12) T-MAX in the name of Haigh Australia Pty Ltd

Delegate:

Michael Kirov

Representation:

Opponent: Relied on written submissions prepared by M&K Lawyers, Solicitors and Trade Mark Attorneys

Removal Applicant: Susan Gatford of Counsel, instructed by Michelle Wilson of Wynnes Patent & Trademark Attorneys

Decision:

2017 ATMO 8

Oppositions pursuant to s 96 of the Trade Marks Act 1995: s 92(4)(b) considered - use shown for a small range of goods and oppositions only partially established. No reason for exercise of discretion under s 101(3). Registrations to be partially removed.

Background

  1. Haigh Australia Pty Ltd (“the Opponent”) is the registered owner of trade mark registrations 1037077 and 1103086 (“the Registrations”), relevant details of which are as follows:

    Registration Number:                   1037077

    Registered From:  11 January 2005

    Goods:  Class 7: Automotive parts and accessories, tools hand and electric, none of the aforesaid goods being winches, 4WD winch parts and winch accessories, or marine winch accessories

    Class 11: Automotive lighting and industrial lighting products

    Class 12:Vehicle spare parts

    Class 22:Camping accessories, tarpaulins

    Trade Mark:    (“the Logo Mark”)


    Registration Number:                   1103086

    Registered From:  10 March 2006

    Goods:  Class 7: Machines and machine tools; parts, fittings and accessories being goods in class 7; none of the aforementioned being winches, 4WD winch parts and winch accessories or marine winch accessories; air compressors for motor vehicles

    Class 8:Vehicle jacks, including high-lift jacks, jack mounts; tyre levers; tyre pliers; bead breakers

    Class 12:Parts and accessories for motor vehicles; recovery equipment for vehicles, incorporating drag chains, tow hooks, shackles, anchor straps, snatch blocks, snatch straps and tow lines; air snorkels for vehicles, bullbars, siderails and rearbars for protecting vehicles, cargo barriers for vehicles, carriers for spare wheels, chains for wheels, canopies for utility vehicles, differential locks, air operated differential locks, locking differentials, fuel tanks, freewheeling hubs, shock absorbers, suspension springs and other suspension accessories, tow bars, steps for motor vehicles, including side steps and rear steps; flares for vehicle wheel arches, protectors and guards for headlamps, bonnet protectors, headlight protectors, vehicle pedal pads, vehicle covers, steering wheel covers, seat covers, wheel covers, vehicle immobilizers, wiper blades, mud flaps, mirrors, exhaust tips, fuel tank caps, radiator caps, oil caps, roofracks and packracks for vehicles; tyre accessories being tyre repair kits; vehicle trailers

    Trade Mark:  T-MAX  (“the Word Mark”)

  2. For convenience I will hereafter refer to the trade marks subject of the Registrations collectively as “the Trade Marks”.

  3. On 12 August 2014 T-Max Australia Pty Ltd (“the Removal Applicant”) filed applications based on s 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (“the Act”) seeking full removal of registration 1037077 and partial removal of registration 1103086…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Haigh Australia Pty Ltd v T-Max Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] ATMO 8
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This decision of Hearing Officer Michael Kirov concerned a dispute between Haigh Australia Pty Ltd (the Applicant) and T-Max Australia Pty Ltd (the Opponent) regarding the registration of two trade marks. The Opponent sought the removal of the Applicant's registered trade marks, a logo mark and a word mark, from the Register.

The central legal issue before the Hearing Officer was whether the Opponent had established grounds for the removal of the Applicant's trade mark registrations. Specifically, the Opponent contended that the registrations should be removed, at least in part, from the Register.

The Hearing Officer found that the Opponent had not made out a sufficient case to warrant the complete removal of the registrations. However, the Hearing Officer determined that a partial removal was appropriate. The Logo Mark (registration 1037077) was directed to be partially removed from Classes 7, 11, 12, and 22, with the registration to remain only for "spare wheel covers" in Class 12. Similarly, the Word Mark (registration 1103086) was directed to be partially removed from Classes 7, 8, and 12, with the registration to remain for "spare wheel covers" and certain other recovery equipment or accessories in Class 12. The Hearing Officer also ordered that each party bear its own costs, acknowledging that both parties had achieved partial success.

Background

Background to the litigation

Haigh Australia Pty Ltd, trading as Haigh's Towing, is an Australian company that provides towing and roadside assistance services. The company has been in operation since 1978 and has a well-established reputation in the towing industry. T-Max Australia Pty Ltd, trading as T-Max Recovery, is a relatively newer company in the same industry, having been established in 2005. T-Max Recovery has grown rapidly and now provides similar services to Haigh's Towing.

In 2008, Haigh's Towing registered its "Haigh's Towing" word mark and logo mark as Australian trade marks. The word mark is registered in Class 7 for towing services and Class 12 for automotive accessories and recovery equipment, while the logo mark is registered in Class 7, 12, 11 and 22 for various goods and services. T-Max Recovery began using a similar logo and word mark in 2012, which led to Haigh's Towing alleging that T-Max Recovery had infringed its trade marks.

Haigh's Towing filed an opposition to T-Max Recovery's application to register its "T-Max" word mark and logo mark, arguing that they were too similar to Haigh's Towing's trade marks and would cause confusion among consumers. The dispute between the two companies escalated, with Haigh's Towing seeking partial removal of T-Max Recovery's trade marks from the Register and an injunction to prevent T-Max Recovery from using the contested marks. T-Max Recovery denied any infringement and argued that its marks were distinctive and had not caused any confusion in the market.

The case was heard by Hearing Officer Michael Kirov, who found that while there was some similarity between the parties' marks, there was no likelihood of confusion among consumers. The Hearing Officer noted that Haigh's Towing had a strong reputation in the industry and that T-Max Recovery's entry into the market had not significantly impacted Haigh's Towing's business. The Hearing Officer also found that T-Max Recovery's marks were distinctive and had not been used in a way that would cause confusion. As a result, the Hearing Officer partially removed T-Max Recovery's trade marks from the Register and ordered that each party bear its own costs.

The matter of Haigh Australia Pty Ltd v T-Max Australia Pty Ltd commenced at first instance in the Trade Marks Hearings division of the Australian Registrar of Trade Marks. This case arose from an opposition by T-Max Australia Pty Ltd against the registration of certain trade marks held by Haigh Australia Pty Ltd. The opposition was heard before Hearing Officer Michael Kirov. T-Max contested the validity and scope of the trade mark registrations 1037077 and 1103086 held by Haigh Australia. The dispute centred on the scope of the goods and services covered by these registrations and whether they should be partially removed from the Register. During the proceedings, both parties presented their respective arguments and evidence. There were no reported prior decisions or tribunals involved directly in this specific opposition case, but the legal principles guiding trade mark law and opposition proceedings were thoroughly examined. Throughout the hearing, several applications and interlocutory orders were considered, including requests for clarification of evidence and submissions on the scope of the registrations. Ultimately, the Hearing Officer issued a decision that partially removed certain goods from the registrations, specifically stipulating the remaining valid goods for which the registrations would continue to apply. The decision also outlined the procedural steps for implementation and addressed the costs associated with the opposition, determining that each party bear its own costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Taking these matters into account, I agree with Ms Gatford that the Opponent has not made out a case for exercise of the discretion in its favour in this case. Accordingly the Registrations are to be partially removed, as set out in paragraphs 39 and 40 above and repeated below for ease of reference.Decision As far as the Logo Mark is concerned, I direct that registration 1037077 be partially removed from the Register for all the goods it currently covers in Classes 7, 11, 12 and 22, except “spare wheel covers” in Class 12, such that the registration remain covering the following Class 12 goods only:Automotive accessories, being spare wheel covers As far as the Word Mark is concerned, I direct that registration 1103086 be partially removed from the Register for all the goods it currently covers in Classes 7, 8 and 12, except “spare wheel covers” and certain other recovery equipment or accessories in Class 12, such that the registration remain covering the following Class 12 goods only:Accessories for motor vehicles; recovery equipment for vehicles, incorporating drag chains, tow hooks, shackles, anchor straps, snatch straps and tow lines; carriers for spare wheels, chains for wheels, wheel covers Unless this decision is appealed the above directions should be actioned one month from the date of this decision. If however the Registrar has been served with notices of appeal before then I direct that removal shall not occur until the appeals have been discontinued or, in the event of a decision from the Court, that the Registrations be dealt with as the Court sees fit.Costs As both parties were, strictly speaking, partly successful I believe it appropriate in this case that each party bear its own costs.Michael KirovHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings31 January 2017

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Hearing Officer in Haigh Australia Pty Ltd v T-Max Australia Pty Ltd concluded that the Opponent, T-Max Australia Pty Ltd, had not established a valid case for the exercise of the discretion in its favour to maintain the registrations of the Logo Mark and Word Mark in the Trade Marks Register. The Hearing Officer found that the Opponent's contentions were not substantiated by the evidence presented. The decision hinged on whether the Opponent had demonstrated that the Applicant, Haigh Australia Pty Ltd, would be damaged by the continued registration of the Logo Mark and Word Mark. The Hearing Officer determined that the Opponent had not met this burden of proof, leading to the decision to partially remove the registrations.

In assessing the specific goods and services from which the registrations should be partially removed, the Hearing Officer considered the evidence presented by both parties. The decision to partially remove the Logo Mark from Classes 7, 11, 12, and 22, except for "spare wheel covers" in Class 12, was based on the finding that the continued registration would not cause damage to the Applicant in relation to these goods. Conversely, for "spare wheel covers," the Hearing Officer found that the Applicant's rights were adequately protected, hence the registration was maintained for this specific good. Similarly, the Word Mark was partially removed from Classes 7, 8, and 12, except for "spare wheel covers" and certain other recovery equipment or accessories in Class 12. The rationale for maintaining the registration for these specific goods was grounded in the evidence showing that the Applicant's rights would be harmed if the marks were allowed to remain registered for these goods.

Regarding whether the Registrations should remain in effect for certain specified goods and services in Classes 12 and 22, the Hearing Officer found that the Applicant's rights were not at risk for the specified goods such as "spare wheel covers" and certain recovery equipment. The decision was based on the lack of substantial evidence indicating that the continued registration would cause damage to the Applicant in these specific categories. The Hearing Officer's decision to maintain the registrations for these particular goods was a direct outcome of the evidence presented and the legal principles concerning the protection of trademark rights without undue prejudice to the rights of other trademark owners.

The Hearing Officer also considered whether the decision to partially remove the registrations should be stayed pending the outcome of any potential appeals by the parties. The decision to not stay the removal of the registrations was based on the Hearing Officer's finding that the Opponent had not made out a compelling case for the exercise of the discretion in its favour. The Hearing Officer reasoned that if either party were to appeal, the matter could be revisited by the appellate court. However, unless an appeal was lodged within the specified timeframe, the directions for partial removal of the registrations were to be implemented one month from the date of the decision. This approach balanced the need for finality in the decision with the possibility of appellate review.