Haidari and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

Haidari and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2016] AATA 513 (21 July 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number

2015/2794

Re

Jalal Haidari

APPLICANT

And

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member R W Dunne

Date 21 July 2016
Place Adelaide

The Tribunal:

(a)pursuant to s 43(1)(c) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (“AAT Act”), sets aside the decision under review; and

(b)remits the matter to the decision-maker for reconsideration in accordance with a direction from the Tribunal pursuant to s 43(1)(c)(ii) of the AAT Act that the applicant is a person of good character for the purposes of paragraph 25(2)(b)(iii) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007.

......................[Sgd]..................................................

Senior Member R W Dunne

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP – cancellation of approval for Australian citizenship by conferral – whether the applicant is not of good character – credibility – whether the application for citizenship made by the applicant should be approved – decision under review set aside and remitted.

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth), ss 21, 24 and 25

CASES

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Irving v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1996) 68 FCR 422
Re Zheng and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2011) 121 ALD 372; [2011] AATA 304 
Re Chen and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] AATA 1815 

Re GJRL and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2015) 150 ALD 106; [2015] AATA 76 

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Australian Citizenship Instructions (Cth) issued 1 July 2014.

Citizenship Policy (Cth) issued 1 June 2016

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member R W Dunne

21 July 16

INTRODUCTION

  1. Jalal Haidari (“applicant”) is a citizen of Afghanistan.  He arrived in Australia in 2010 as the holder of a Protection (subclass 866) visa. 

  2. On 1 June 2014, the applicant lodged an application for Australian citizenship by conferral.  The application was approved on 9 January 2015.  However, on 6 February 2015 a notice of intention to cancel his citizenship approval (“Notice”) was sent to the applicant because the case officer thought he may no longer meet the eligibility criteria under the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) (“Act”). 

  3. The case officer subsequently decided to cancel the approval of Australian citizenship by conferral for the applicant under s 25(2)(b)(iii) of the Act, which relates to his good character.

  4. The applicant has applied to this Tribunal for review of the delegate’s decision.

  5. At the hearing, the applicant was represented by Ms J Cox (from the National Pro Bono Project).  Ms C Stokes (from the office of the Australian Government Solicitor) appeared on behalf of the respondent Minister.  I received into evidence the T Documents[1] lodged pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.

    [1] Exhibit R1.

    ISSUE FOR THE TRIBUNAL

  6. The issue for the Tribunal is whether the approval for Australian citizenship given to the applicant may be cancelled if, at the time the Minister proposes to cancel the approval, the applicant is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Haidari and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 513
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for Australian citizenship by conferral. The applicant, Mr Haidari, had his approval for citizenship cancelled by the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection on the grounds that he was not of good character. The Minister’s delegate formed this view based on the applicant’s involvement in sponsoring a spousal visa application where the accompanying death and marriage certificates were found to be not genuine, as they featured the same witness but with different identification details. The applicant sought review of this decision before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the Minister had sufficient grounds to cancel the applicant's approval for Australian citizenship under section 25(2)(b)(iii) of the *Australian Citizenship Act 2007* (Cth), which permits cancellation if the Minister is satisfied that the applicant is not of good character at the time the Minister proposes to cancel the approval. This required the Tribunal to determine the meaning of "good character" in this context and to assess whether the evidence presented established that the applicant lacked this quality at the relevant time.

The Tribunal considered the legislative provisions and relevant case law, including the definition of "good character" from *Irving v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs*, which refers to enduring moral qualities rather than public reputation. The Tribunal noted that while the applicant's involvement with potentially fraudulent documents was a serious concern, the evidence regarding the applicant's personal involvement in the creation or presentation of these documents was not definitively established. The Tribunal also had regard to the applicant's evidence of his positive community involvement and lack of prior criminal history. Ultimately, the Tribunal found that the respondent had not discharged the onus of proving that the applicant was not of good character at the time the Minister proposed to cancel the approval.

Accordingly, the Tribunal set aside the decision under review and remitted the matter to the decision-maker with a direction that the applicant be considered a person of good character for the purposes of paragraph 25(2)(b)(iii) of the *Australian Citizenship Act 2007*.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal:

(a) pursuant to s 43(1)(c) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (“AAT Act”), sets aside the decision under review; and

(b) remits the matter to the decision-maker for reconsideration in accordance with a direction from the Tribunal pursuant to s 43(1)(c)(ii) of the AAT Act that the applicant is a person of good character for the purposes of paragraph 25(2)(b)(iii) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007.

Background

Background to the litigation

The issue for the Tribunal is whether the approval for Australian citizenship given to the applicant may be cancelled if, at the time the Minister proposes to cancel the approval, the applicant is not of good character.LEGISLATIVE AND POLICY BACKGROUND Section 21(2) of the Act sets out the general eligibility criteria for a person to become an Australian citizen. In the decision record dated 5 June 2015 forwarded to the applicant by his case officer, it was stated that his application for conferral of Australian citizenship was approved under s 21(2) of the Act. Section 21(2) relevantly reads:“General eligibility (2)A person is eligible to become an Australian citizen if the Minister is satisfied that the person: …(b)is a permanent resident: (i) at the time the person made the application; and (ii) at the time of the Minister's decision on the application; and (c)satisfies the general residence requirement (see section 22) or the special residence requirement (see section 22A or 22B), or satisfies the defence service requirement (see section 23), at the time the person made the application; and (d)understands the nature of an application under subsection (1); and (e)possesses a basic knowledge of the English language; and (f)has an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship; and (g)is likely to reside, or to continue to reside, in Australia or to maintain a close and continuing association with Australia if the application were to be approved; and (h)is of good character at the time of the Minister's decision on the application.….” Section 24 of the Act provides, in part:“24 Minister's decision (1)If a person makes an application under section 21, the Minister must, by writing, approve or refuse to approve the person becoming an Australian citizen. (1A)The Minister must not approve the person becoming an Australian citizen unless the person is eligible to become an Australian citizen under subsection 21(2), (3), (4), (5), (6), (7) or (8).….” Section 25 of the Act provides, in part:“25 Minister may cancel approval (1) The Minister may, by writing, cancel an approval given to a person under section 24 if: (a)the person has not become an Australian citizen under section 28; and (b)either of the following 2 situations apply. Eligibility criteria not met (2) The first situation applies if: (a)the person is covered by subsection 21(2), (3) or (4); and (b)the Minister is satisfied that, at the time the Minister proposes to cancel the approval, the person is: (i) not a permanent resident; or (ii) not likely to reside, or to continue to reside, in Australia or to maintain a close and continuing association with Australia; or (iii) not of good character.…”AUSTRALIAN CITIZENSHIP INSTRUCTIONS AND CITIZENSHIP POLICY The Australian Citizenship Instructions (“Instructions”) have been issued by the Minister. The Citizenship Policy (“Policy”) was also issued by the Minister on 1 June 2016. The Instructions and the Policy have been adopted to guide those making decisions under the Act. Chapter 10 of the Instructions and Chapter 11 of the Policy set out the relevant legislative requirements and policy guidelines for Australian citizenship, where good character is involved. The Instructions and the Policy reflect Government policy and are not binding on the Tribunal. However, the Tribunal should have regard to the Instructions and/or the Policy unless there is good reason not to do so.[2][2] Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 643 at 645.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Minister’s delegate found that the applicant was not of good character as he had sponsored a spousal visa application that had provided death and marriage certificates which were not genuine as they contained a photo of the same witness, but with different identification details on each certificate. The delegate subsequently cancelled the applicant’s approval of Australian citizenship pursuant to s 25(2)(iii) of the Act.EVIDENCEEvidence of Applicant It was the applicant’s evidence that he was at Christmas Island from March 2010 to August 2010, when he left. He had since worked at a chicken factory until he left there in 2014, but also did building jobs until his doctor said not to work. In Adelaide he lived with house mates. He then rented a property and his friends remained the same. He became involved with new arrivals to Australia and in helping them. There had been no trouble with the law, but he was involved in a traffic offence which only involved an expiation notice. He had not been involved with the police in either Pakistan or Afghanistan. The applicant said that he was married and had five children. One of his children, Ahmad Basir Haidari, was adopted. When he adopted that child he lodged his application through his lawyer and he told her clearly that Ahmad Basir was his adopted child. The applicant also had problems obtaining the correct marriage certificate with the help of Hassan Ali. There were also problems in obtaining the death certificates for the parents of his adopted son. He did not explain why he had not gone to the Afghanistan Embassy in Australia for the certificates. He had asked for assistance from Hassan Ali, but the certificates could take three weeks. Hassan Ali would let the applicant know when the certificates were ready. The problem was that the photographs on the death certificates for the parents did not match. Evidence of Abdul Nabizadeh The evidence of Abdul Nabizadeh was that he had been living in Australia for five years and had known the applicant for four years. He said that the applicant was a good person and he would take part with the applicant in community events. The applicant assisted people in getting around. He did not have a witness statement because no one had asked him for one. Evidence of Qiyam Nosrat It was the evidence of Mr Nosrat, which was taken by telephone, that he had lived in Australia for 16 years and had known the applicant for about five years. He said that he had met the applicant at the Afghan United Association, at events within the centre. He helped with drinks and food and would assist in cleaning the centre. CONSIDERATIONCan the approval for Australian citizenship given to the applicant be cancelled if, at the time the Minister proposes to cancel the approval, the applicant is not of good character? As can be seen from the legislative provisions in paragraph 9 above, under s 25 of the Act the Minister may, by writing, cancel an approval for Australian citizenship given to a person under s 24 if:(a)the person is covered by the provisions in subsection 21(2), (3) or (4); and(b)the Minister is satisfied that, at the time the Minister proposes to cancel the approval, the person is not of good character.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 24 of the Act provides, in part:“24 Minister's decision (1)If a person makes an application under section 21, the Minister must, by writing, approve or refuse to approve the person becoming an Australian citizen. (1A)The Minister must not approve the person becoming an Australian citizen unless the person is eligible to become an Australian citizen under subsection 21(2), (3), (4), (5), (6), (7) or (8).….” Section 25 of the Act provides, in part:“25 Minister may cancel approval (1) The Minister may, by writing, cancel an approval given to a person under section 24 if: (a)the person has not become an Australian citizen under section 28; and (b)either of the following 2 situations apply. Eligibility criteria not met (2) The first situation applies if: (a)the person is covered by subsection 21(2), (3) or (4); and (b)the Minister is satisfied that, at the time the Minister proposes to cancel the approval, the person is: (i) not a permanent resident; or (ii) not likely to reside, or to continue to reside, in Australia or to maintain a close and continuing association with Australia; or (iii) not of good character.…”AUSTRALIAN CITIZENSHIP INSTRUCTIONS AND CITIZENSHIP POLICY The Australian Citizenship Instructions (“Instructions”) have been issued by the Minister. The Citizenship Policy (“Policy”) was also issued by the Minister on 1 June 2016. The Instructions and the Policy have been adopted to guide those making decisions under the Act. Chapter 10 of the Instructions and Chapter 11 of the Policy set out the relevant legislative requirements and policy guidelines for Australian citizenship, where good character is involved. The Instructions and the Policy reflect Government policy and are not binding on the Tribunal. However, the Tribunal should have regard to the Instructions and/or the Policy unless there is good reason not to do so.[2][2] Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 643 at 645. In looking at paragraph 25(2)(b)(iii) of the Act, the expression “not of good character” used there is not defined. Like the term “good character”, the Federal Court and Tribunals have used the ordinary meaning of the words, and made reference to dictionary definitions. Most cases have adopted the following definition from the Full Federal Court judgement in Irving v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs[3], which relevantly reads at [3]:“Unless the terms of the … Act and … regulations require some other meaning be applied, the words ‘good character’ should be taken to be used in their ordinary sense, namely, a reference to the enduring moral qualities of a person, and not the good standing, fame or repute of that person in the community. The former is an objective assessment apt to be proved as a fact whilst the latter is a review of subjective public opinion …”[3] (1996) 68 FCR 422. As explained in 10.3.4 of the Instructions, an applicant of good character would:·Be truthful and not practise deception or fraud in their dealings with the Australian Government, or other governments and organisations, for example:oproviding false personal information (such as fraudulent work experience or qualification documents) or other material deception during visa and citizenship applicationsoinvolvement in bogus marriage…

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It was the evidence of Mr Nosrat, which was taken by telephone, that he had lived in Australia for 16 years and had known the applicant for about five years. He said that he had met the applicant at the Afghan United Association, at events within the centre. He helped with drinks and food and would assist in cleaning the centre. CONSIDERATIONCan the approval for Australian citizenship given to the applicant be cancelled if, at the time the Minister proposes to cancel the approval, the applicant is not of good character? As can be seen from the legislative provisions in paragraph 9 above, under s 25 of the Act the Minister may, by writing, cancel an approval for Australian citizenship given to a person under s 24 if:(a)the person is covered by the provisions in subsection 21(2), (3) or (4); and(b)the Minister is satisfied that, at the time the Minister proposes to cancel the approval, the person is not of good character. In giving her closing, it was Ms Cox’s submission that there needs to be sufficient evidence before the Tribunal that, at the time the Minister proposes to cancel the approval, the applicant is not of good character. Unlike the provisions in s 21(2)(h) of the Act, which require that the applicant is a person of good character at the time of the Minister’s action, s 25(2)(b)(iii) requires that the person is not of good character. The wording of the test in s 25 is subtly different to the wording of the test in s 21(2)(h). Mr Hassan Ali, the friend of the applicant, obtained the marriage certificate. He obtained all three relevant certificates, but he was in fact able to be a witness and attorney for the bridegroom on the marriage certificate as he was present at the applicant’s wedding. Ms Cox argued that it is for the respondent to provide sufficient evidence that the applicant is not of good character. She submitted that this has not been done. She suggested that the assessment of a person’s character involves the requirement for the decision-maker to look holistically at the applicant’s behaviour. The applicant adopted a child who did not have family members to look after him, as his parents had both died. He had never been in trouble with the police, the only offending in Australia was for a minor traffic offence. Moreover, he had never been in trouble with the police in Pakistan or Afghanistan. Ms Stokes for the respondent submitted that the affidavit evidence of Mr Hudson, the Chief Migration Officer at the Australian High Commission, was not subject to cross-examination. She said she assumed the applicant accepted that evidence. And that strongly suggested that the documents (including the certificates) were fake and bogus. However, when the Consulate General of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan in Quetta certified the applicant’s wedding certificate as it did, what did it mean when it described the certificate as fake and bogus? Moreover, in the email from Richard Kerr contained in Annexure A to Mr Hudson’s affidavit, Mr Kerr said:“BackgroundMr HAIDARI has been refused citizenship as the delegate formed the view that he had provided counterfeit documents to support the application for a spouse visa by his claimed wife and children.The counterfeit docs are a marriage certificate and a death certificate (which details the death of the biological parents of his adopted son, which is disclosed in the spouse visa application). The problematic issue is that one of the witnesses to these docs has appeared on other Afghani docs under other identities.Mr H is appealing the refusal at the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) because he maintains that someone else, possibly his son, lodged the application for these documents at the Afghani Consulate in Quetta (Pakistan) and that the Consulate ‘mixed them up’.Mr H has now submitted ‘corrected’ parts of the marriage doc and has provided a notarised certificate from the witness to the marriage certificate setting out how well he has known Mr H and his wife.We have read various IMtel reports from Dubai post casting doubt on the veracity of Afghani docs in general and those claimed to be issued by the Afghani Consulate in Quetta, Pakistan.We now have concerns that the entire marriage certificate is false (and the death certificate of the parents of his adopted son likewise false) and that those docs were not issued by the Afghani consulate in Quetta, but by some other party.We now wish to rely on these docs being false to defend the decision to refuse HAIDARI’s application for citizenship at the AAT. Hence, we seek their authentication. We understand from Dubai post that you/your team can do this thru’ the Afghani Embassy in Islamabad.”