Haex and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

Haex and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 174 (15 February 2023)

Division:                  NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2022/3672

Re:Peter Haex

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Member I Thompson

Date:15 February 2023

Place:Adelaide

For the reasons set out below, the Tribunal decides that:

  1. The Tribunal disallows Associate Professor Metzer’s objection to the issue of the summons to produce referrals, reports, clinical notes, correspondence or any other documents regarding any attendance on, or treatment of the applicant, Mr Peter Haex;

  2. The Tribunal orders pursuant to s 35(4) of the AAT Act that:

    (a)the provision of raw clinical data from psychometric assessment of the applicant be produced in a sealed envelope or a password protected electronic file; and

    (b)subject to any subsequent order of the Tribunal, the disclosure of the raw clinical data is limited to the Presiding Member of the Tribunal (and any member of staff nominated by the Presiding Member)

    .........[sgnd].............................

    Member I Thompson

    Catchwords

    PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – National Disability Insurance Scheme – objection to compliance with summons – documents including psychological test material – whether documents contain information of apparent relevance to the issues before the Tribunal – summons to be satisfied

    Legislation

    Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

    Cases

    Comcare v Maganga [2008] FCA 285

    Huchatz and Australian Capital Territory [2020] AATA 4237

    Panagiotou and TNT Australia Pty Ltd [2011] AATA 565

    REASONS FOR DECISION

    Member I Thompson

    15 February 2023

  3. The substantive application concerns Mr Haex’s request to become a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (“NDIS”). He lodged an application to the Tribunal for a review of an internal review decision of the National Disability Insurance Agency (“the Agency”) made on 19 April 2022, which affirmed the original decision that he does not meet the criteria in in the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (“the NDIS Act”) for access to the scheme. His application to the Tribunal claims that he does meet the access criteria with regard to his disability from spinal and post-traumatic stress disorder.

  4. On 18 October 2022, the Agency requested that a summons be issued to Associate Professor Jacques Metzer at PsychMed for referrals, reports, clinical notes, correspondence or any other documentation regarding attendance and treatment of Mr Haex. The reason for the request was that the documents have a bearing, specifically on the assessment of whether Mr Haex’s conditions have the requisite permanency to satisfy the access criteria in ss 24 and 25 of the NDIS Act.

  5. On 19 October 2022, the Tribunal issued a summons to Associate Professor Metzer to produce the documents, returnable on 4 November 2022. By letter dated 27 October 2022, Associate Professor Metzer objected to the production of the documents and requested that the summons be withdrawn. Consequently, an interlocutory hearing was listed on 20 December 2022, and in accordance with directions the Tribunal issued at the interlocutory hearing, the Agency provided written submissions. In response, on 31 January…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Haex and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 174
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an objection by Associate Professor Metzer to a summons issued by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) Tribunal, requiring the production of psychological records belonging to Mr Peter Haex. The dispute centred on whether these documents, including raw clinical data from psychometric assessments, were relevant to the issues before the Tribunal in its review of Mr Haex's NDIS eligibility. The Tribunal was required to determine the apparent relevance of the requested documents to the issues to be decided in the substantive application.

The Tribunal applied the principles articulated in *Panagiotou*, which distinguish between the relevance required for issuing a summons and the relevance required for actual review of a decision. While the Tribunal must have regard only to material it deems relevant when reviewing a decision, it may issue a summons if the documents can reasonably be expected to "throw some light" on the issues to be decided. The Tribunal considered that the requested records and notes, relating to Mr Haex's psychosocial impairment, were of apparent relevance to the criteria of permanence and reduction in functional capacity under the NDIS Act and Rules.

The Tribunal reasoned that the requested records had a legitimate forensic purpose and were not irrelevant to the substantive review. While acknowledging concerns raised by Associate Professor Metzer regarding the burden and potential delays associated with collating and analysing large quantities of information, the Tribunal found these concerns were outweighed by the factors favouring production. The Tribunal also addressed the issue of "raw clinical data," agreeing with the NDIA's suggestion for its provision in a sealed envelope or password-protected file, with disclosure limited to the Presiding Member. Accordingly, the Tribunal disallowed the objection to the summons and ordered the production of the specified documents, subject to conditions regarding the handling of the raw clinical data.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Subsequent to production of the summons material further consideration will be necessary in relation to inspection while noting at this stage the expressed concern that inspection should be restricted to a clinical psychologist, and inspection should not be available to a registered psychologist, a psychiatrist or any other medical practitioner or allied health practitioner. It would be envisaged, and it is seemingly not controversial that the file containing the clinical data be returned to Associate Professor Metzer when the proceedings are finalised. These are matters which may require further consideration in the context of any requests for leave to inspect documents under s40 B of the AAT ActConclusion The Tribunal disallows Associate Professor Metzer’s objection to the issue of the summons to produce referrals, reports, clinical notes, correspondence or any other documents regarding any attendance on, or treatment of the applicant, Mr Peter Haex, The Tribunal orders pursuant to s 35(4) of the AAT Act that:(a)the provision of raw clinical data from psychometric assessment of the applicant be produced in a sealed envelope or a password protected electronic file; and (b)subject to any subsequent order of the Tribunal, the disclosure of the raw clinical data is limited to the Presiding Member of the Tribunal (and any member of staff nominated by the Presiding Member).I certify that the preceding twenty-one (21) paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of Member Thompson.................[sgnd]..................................Associate

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Panagiotou,[5] Deputy President Forgie provided further clarification about the approach to be taken on the grounds of relevance of personal records in accordance with the particular stage reached in the proceedings. She relevantly stated:What the Tribunal regards as relevant when it is actually reviewing a decision may be different from what it regards as relevant when it issues a summons. When reviewing a decision, it must have regard only to evidence or material that it actually regards as relevant. When it is issuing a summons for documents or material, it requires only that they appear to have relevance to the issues to be decided. That is, it may issue a summons requiring their production if they can reasonably be expected to throw some light on the issues that will have to be decided in reviewing the decision.[6][5] [2011] AATA 565; 127 ALD 340.[6] Ibid at [25]. Consideration One component of Mr Haex’s access request to the NDIS relates to psychosocial impairment. The Tribunal will be required to consider the evidence with regard to the criteria of permanence in the NDIS Act and the NDIS (Becoming a Participant) Rules. The criteria in the NDIS Rules about the permanence of impairments and the criteria about reduction in an applicant’s functional capacity require a detailed and practical assessment of the evidence about the impairments and the ways in which those impairments affect an applicant. Mr Haex has consulted with Associate Professor Metzer for at least 4 years and also with practitioners in the same psychology practice. The Tribunal considers that the requested records and notes are of apparent relevance. There is a real possibility that they will shed light on the issues to be determined in this review and assist the Tribunal in its consideration of the evidence and the determination of the correct or preferable decision. Associate Professor Metzer’s submissions raise concerns about the burdensome prospect of collating and analysing large quantities of possibly irrelevant information and the delays that may be associated with those tasks. In considering the submissions made by both parties in the context of the evidence currently available and the issues to be decided in the substantive application, the concerns which he raises are outweighed by the factors in favour of production of the material. That material is not irrelevant, and it is not unrelated to the issue to be decided on the substantive review. Accordingly, the Tribunal considers that issuing the summons has a legitimate forensic purpose. The Tribunal does not accept that the request for the summons was not made in good faith or that it amounts to a phishing expedition. Additionally, the Tribunal must consider the submissions concerning the “raw clinical data” in the psychology records. The Agency suggested provision of that material to the Tribunal be in a sealed envelope or a password protected electronic file. Associate Professor Metzer confirmed that this clinical data is the data produced and analysed through psychometric assessments, of which five such assessments are mentioned in a report he wrote in May 2017. Professional and policy considerations are uniquely important and specific to the methodology of these psychology assessments and the personal data which they generate. Associate Professor Metzer wrote in his letter to the Tribunal dated 27 October 2022, that his agency’s policy “is not to submit to requests for release of raw clinical data, since their interpretation can be done only by professional clinical psychologists, who must undergo specific and accredited education and training, lasting at least 6 years at university level before undergoing further AHPRA supervised early professional work”.