Habul Building Group v Lae Roofing & Plumbing

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

99.417

COURT OF APPEAL

de JERSEY CJ
McPHERSON JA
JONES J

Appeal No 7483 of 1999

OMAR HABUL TRADING AS HABUL
BUILDING GROUP  Appellant

and

DAVID GRAHAM TRADING AS
LAE ROOFING & PLUMBING  Respondent

BRISBANE

..DATE 04/10/99

JUDGMENT

McPHERSON JA: This is an application under s.118(3) of the District Courts Act for leave to appeal against a decision of a District Court Judge. 

The respondent David Graham is a plumber who installed some roof guttering at residential premises in Annerley.  The premises were being erected there on behalf of the Queensland Housing Commission by the applicant, who is Omar Habul, who was the builder. 

The argument relates to the dimensions of the gutter used or installed by the respondent David Graham.  It is said to have been not in accordance with the relevant standard and the wrong size for the job in hand.  It is said also to have caused problems with rainwater, although we were told from the Bar table today that there had been no such problems for two years after some repair work was done on the guttering.

It did, it seems, take some time for the respondent to fix it, and that was a matter which was considered in the course of the reasons below.  The respondent Graham was initially not paid by the applicant builder and he made a claim against the builder for payment.  The total originally claimed was some $11,000; the matter was referred to the Queensland Building Tribunal; and the Tribunal member on
23 January 1998 found that there were some deficiencies, or unsatisfactory aspects, in relation to the work done.  In the result, the full claim was not allowed but only part of it in an amount of $6,159.95.  As I understand the matter that may have included a sum for costs as well.

The applicant builder was dissatisfied with this result and he appealed against the Tribunal decision to a Judge of the District Court.  The appeal was heard in the District Court and ultimately dismissed, with the Judge giving reasons for his decision.

It is now sought by the applicant builder to appeal against that decision, and to do so on two grounds. One is that the District Court Judge ought, pursuant to s.94(4) of the Queensland Building Services Authority Act, to have remitted the matter for determination in the District Court. That is a somewhat surprising submission because it is clear from a perusal of the subsection in question that the District Court in circumstances like these is invested with a discretion to do one of several things including the remission of the matter to the Tribunal. What s.94(4) says is that, on appeal, the District Court may: (a) confirm, annul, vary or reverse the Tribunal's determination; or
(b) remit the case to the Tribunal for further hearing; or (c) make consequential or ancillary orders or directions.

It is plain from the use of the word "may" that there is no mandatory obligation on the part of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Habul Building Group v Lae Roofing & Plumbing and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] QCA 417
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the appeal case of Habul Building Group v Lae Roofing & Plumbing, the appellant, Omar Habul trading as Habul Building Group, sought leave to appeal against a decision of the District Court. The respondent, David Graham trading as Lae Roofing & Plumbing, is a plumber who installed roof guttering at residential premises in Annerley on behalf of the Queensland Housing Commission. The dispute revolves around the dimensions of the gutter installed by the respondent, which was allegedly not in accordance with the relevant standard and the wrong size for the job, causing rainwater problems. The original claim for payment by the respondent was for $11,000, which was reduced to $6,159.95 by the Queensland Building Tribunal. The builder's appeal against the Tribunal decision was dismissed by a Judge of the District Court, leading to the current application for leave to appeal.

The legal issues before the court were whether the District Court Judge should have remitted the matter for determination in the District Court pursuant to s.94(4) of the Queensland Building Services Authority Act, and whether there was an error in the measurement of the gutter as required by the relevant standard. The first ground of appeal was deemed to be without merit as the District Court has a discretionary power to remit the case to the Tribunal, and the second ground was considered to be one of fact or mixed fact and law, but not sufficient to warrant an appeal due to the amount involved and the multiple hearings already conducted.

The court found that the difference in measurement between 400 millimetres and 450 millimetres was not significant enough to grant leave to appeal. The court also noted that the amount involved was approximately $6,000, which did not justify further proceedings. Therefore, the application for leave to appeal was refused by the Chief Justice and Jones J. The final orders of the court were to deny the leave to appeal in this case.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between Omar Habul, trading as Habul Building Group, and David Graham, trading as Lae Roofing & Plumbing. David Graham installed roof guttering at residential premises in Annerley, which were being erected by Omar Habul on behalf of the Queensland Housing Commission. The dispute centres around the dimensions of the gutter installed by David Graham, which is alleged to have been not in accordance with the relevant standard and the wrong size for the job. This allegedly caused problems with rainwater, although it was noted that there had been no such problems for two years after some repair work was done. David Graham was initially not paid by Omar Habul and subsequently made a claim for payment, originally seeking $11,000. This claim was referred to the Queensland Building Tribunal, which found deficiencies in the work and allowed only part of the claim, amounting to $6,159.95. Omar Habul appealed this decision to a Judge of the District Court, which was ultimately dismissed.

The procedural history of the case begins with David Graham's claim for payment against Omar Habul for work done on the residential premises in Annerley. The matter was referred to the Queensland Building Tribunal, which found deficiencies in the work and allowed only part of the claim. Dissatisfied with the Tribunal's decision, Omar Habul appealed to a Judge of the District Court. The District Court dismissed the appeal, and Omar Habul subsequently applied for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal under s.118(3) of the District Courts Act. The Court of Appeal heard the application and ultimately refused leave to appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Should the District Court Judge have remitted the matter for determination in the District Court under s.94(4) of the Queensland Building Services Authority Act?
2. Was there an error in the measurement of the gutter's girth as required by the relevant standard?

Held
1. The Court of Appeal held that the District Court Judge was not obliged to remit the matter for determination in the District Court under s.94(4) of the Queensland Building Services Authority Act. The appeal against this decision was dismissed.
2. The Court of Appeal held that the alleged error in the measurement of the gutter's girth was not sufficient to grant leave to appeal. The application for leave to appeal on this ground was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the first issue regarding whether the District Court Judge should have remitted the matter for determination in the District Court under s.94(4) of the Queensland Building Services Authority Act. The Court noted that s.94(4) provided that the District Court "may" remit the case to the Tribunal, which indicated that there was no mandatory obligation to do so. The Court found that the submission on this ground did not succeed as the statute did not impose a duty on the District Court to remit the matter. Consequently, the appeal against the District Court's decision not to remit the matter was dismissed.

Regarding the second issue, the Court of Appeal examined whether there was an error in the measurement of the gutter's girth as required by the relevant standard. The Court acknowledged that the issue of how a gutter should be measured could be a matter of fact or mixed fact and law. However, the Court observed that the error, if any, was not of such a nature as to induce the Court to grant leave to appeal. The Court pointed out that the matter had already been heard twice and that granting leave to appeal would lead to further hearings, potentially including a remit back to the Tribunal. Given the relatively small amount in dispute and the need to avoid unnecessary prolongation of the proceedings, the Court exercised its discretion to refuse the application for leave to appeal on this ground.