Habitat Holding BV v KMM Enterprises Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Oppositions by Habitat Holding BV to applications under section 92 of the Act by KMM Enterprises Pty Ltd to remove trade mark numbers 271498(24), 271499(21), 271500(20) and 734266(8, 11, 16, 18, 27, 28, 35, 42) - Habitat - in the name of Habitat Holding BV

Delegate: Alison Windsor
Representation: Opponent:  Trevor Stevens of Davies Collison Cave , Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys
Applicant:  Did not appear, but provided written submissions
Decision: 2007 ATMO 65
S92 opposition: applicant is person aggrieved –no use demonstrated in Australia during relevant period – Registrar’s discretion under s101(3) not applied – opposition unsuccessful – trade marks to be removed.

Background

  1. On 26 August 2005, KMM Enterprises Pty Ltd (“KMM”) filed applications to remove four trade mark registrations on the basis of non-use, specifying the provisions of paragraph 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (“the Act”).  The dates relevant to the non-use actions are therefore 26 July 2002 to 26 July 2005, and the actions are in respect of all the goods and services covered by the registrations.

  2. The owner of the trade marks, Habitat Holding BV (“Habitat” or “the opponent”) filed a notice of opposition to the non-use application on 24 November 2005, claiming use of the trade marks in respect of the goods for which they are registered within the relevant period, and challenging KMM’s status as a person aggrieved.

  3. The registrations subject of the non-use applications are all for the same trade mark, being the word HABITAT.  Registrations 271498, 271499 and 271500, registered from 21 August 1973, claim all goods in classes 24, 21 and 20 respectively.  Registration 734266, registered from 12 May 1997, claims a range of goods in classes 8, 11, 16, 18, 27 and 28 as well as a range of services in classes 35 and 42. 

  4. Evidence in support, in answer, and in reply were filed as required by the Regulations, and on 22 December 2006 Habitat requested a hearing.  The matter came before me, as a delegate of the Registrar, in Sydney on 16 May 2007.  Trevor Stevens of Davies Collison Cave, Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys in Sydney attended on behalf of Habitat.  KMM did not attend, but provided written submissions.

    Application to serve further evidence

  5. KMM’s initial written submissions to support their case at the hearing were received on 16 April 2007, and these were followed by additional submissions on the morning of the hearing.  Immediately following receipt of these submissions, Habitat sought leave to serve further evidence under the provisions of regulation 5.15.  KMM objected to the proposal to file further evidence, expressing a view that the application was effectively an ambush on the morning of the hearing. 

  6. At the hearing, I asked Mr Stevens to give his submissions in respect of his application, and then advised I would issue a decision on whether to allow the evidence into proceedings at the same time as issuing the decision…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Habitat Holding BV v KMM Enterprises Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] ATMO 65
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by KMM Enterprises Pty Ltd for the removal of certain trade mark registrations held by Habitat Holding BV from the register due to non-use. The application was heard by Alison Windsor, a delegate of the Registrar, in Sydney. KMM Enterprises Pty Ltd did not attend the hearing but provided written submissions, while Habitat Holding BV was represented by Trevor Stevens.

The primary legal issues before the delegate were whether to grant Habitat Holding BV leave to serve further evidence, and if so, whether the trade marks should be removed from the register due to non-use. Habitat Holding BV sought to introduce evidence relating to advertisements and invoices for its goods, arguing it was relevant to the Registrar's discretion under subsection 101(3) of the Act, which allows for trade marks to remain on the register even if grounds for removal are established, if it is reasonable to do so. KMM Enterprises Pty Ltd objected to the late filing of this evidence, characterising it as an ambush.

In determining the admissibility of the further evidence, the delegate applied a three-factor test: whether the evidence could have been obtained with reasonable diligence, whether it would likely influence the result, and whether it was credible. While the evidence was found to be credible, the delegate determined that it could have been obtained earlier with reasonable diligence and, crucially, was unlikely to have a significant effect on the decision as the material post-dated the relevant non-use period by at least 12 months. Consequently, the delegate found no reason to exercise discretion in favour of Habitat Holding BV.

The delegate found that KMM Enterprises Pty Ltd's application for removal was properly made and that Habitat Holding BV had failed to rebut the application. Accordingly, the delegate directed that the specified trade mark registrations be removed from the register within one month, subject to any appeal. Habitat Holding BV was also ordered to pay KMM Enterprises Pty Ltd's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Evidence in support, in answer, and in reply were filed as required by the Regulations, and on 22 December 2006 Habitat requested a hearing. The matter came before me, as a delegate of the Registrar, in Sydney on 16 May 2007. Trevor Stevens of Davies Collison Cave, Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys in Sydney attended on behalf of Habitat. KMM did not attend, but provided written submissions.Application to serve further evidence KMM’s initial written submissions to support their case at the hearing were received on 16 April 2007, and these were followed by additional submissions on the morning of the hearing. Immediately following receipt of these submissions, Habitat sought leave to serve further evidence under the provisions of regulation 5.15. KMM objected to the proposal to file further evidence, expressing a view that the application was effectively an ambush on the morning of the hearing. At the hearing, I asked Mr Stevens to give his submissions in respect of his application, and then advised I would issue a decision on whether to allow the evidence into proceedings at the same time as issuing the decision on the substantive matter. This I shall consider now. Provided an application complies with procedural requirements under the Act and Regulations, there are three major factors to consider for a determination of admissibility of further evidence.[1] These are: (1) Could the evidence have been obtained at an earlier stage by the exercise of reasonable diligence? (2) Would the evidence, if admitted, probably have an important influence on the result for this opposition matter? (3) Is the material submitted apparently credible?[1] Oxon Italia SpA's Application [1981] FSR 408 at 409 following Ladd v Marshall (1954) 1 WLR 1489 The proposed evidence consists of references to advertisements of Habitat’s goods in New Zealand published magazines which are accessible in Australia and examples of invoices in respect of the sales of Habitat goods via the internet from shops in New Zealand to customers in Australia. It is significant that none of the goods purchased in this way were actually delivered to Australia, but were sent to addresses in New Zealand. It is also significant that all these examples, magazines and invoices, are dated outside the relevant period. Mr Stevens submitted that the further evidence he sought to file was appropriate to the matter of the Registrar’s discretion under subsection 101(3) of the Act, which reads as follows: If satisfied that it is reasonable to do so, the Registrar or the court may decide that the trade mark should not be removed from the register even if the grounds on which the application was made have been established. In considering the three factors above, I find the material provided to be credible. I do consider that, with reasonable diligence, it could have been provided earlier, even if only a few weeks earlier. Even that short length of time would have given both parties more time in which to consider their positions. However, in this particular matter, what has most relevance to my determination of the application is that this material is unlikely to have any significant effect on my eventual decision. The examples post date the final date of the non-use period by at least 12 months. Even if I were to decide to invoke the provisions of subsection 101(3), this material would not be of relevance to my decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Under these circumstances, I can find no good reason for allowing these trade marks to remain on the register where they are likely to serve only to interfere with the legitimate rights of bona fide Australian traders operating within the Australian market. I do not intend to apply the Registrar’s discretion in this matter in Habitat’s favour.Decision I have found that KMM’s application for removal was properly made, and that KMM was a person aggrieved. Having considered the evidence put before me, I find that Habitat has not been successful in rebutting the removal application, and I can find no reason to exercise discretion in favour of allowing the trade marks to remain on the register. I find that KMM has been successful in establishing a case for the removal from the register of the trade mark registrations subject of the non-use applications. I direct that the registrations 271498, 271499, 271500 and 734266 be removed from the register after one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar has been served with a notice of appeal before that time, I direct that removal shall not occur until the appeal has been discontinued or, in the event of a decision from the Court, the applications be subject to its orders.Costs Both parties claimed their costs. It is usual for costs to follow the event. Therefore I direct that Habitat pay KMM’s costs, such costs to be determined according to the official scale set out in Schedule 8 to the Trade Mark Regulations. Alison WindsorHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings4 October 2007

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.