Habib v AAI Limited t/as GIO

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read
DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL
CITATION: Habib v AAI Limited t/as GIO [2024] NSWPICMP 96
CLAIMANT: Mohammad Hassan Habib
INSURER: AAI Ltd t/as GIO
REVIEW PANEL
MEMBER: Ray Plibersek
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Sophia Lahz
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Margaret Gibson
DATE OF DECISION: 19 February 2024
CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Claimant was a front seat passenger in a car driven by his wife when it left the road and hit a tree; he suffered a fractured upper arm and a number of soft tissue injuries; Held – original medical certificate set aside regarding degree of permanent impairment; on review, the Panel found a total whole person impairment of 7% for left shoulder/arm; soft tissue injury with healed proximal humeral fracture; the other soft tissue injuries had resolved and the motor vehicle accident did not materially contribute to any right shoulder condition nor exacerbate any such condition; because left and right shoulder range of motion measurements at examination were inconsistent they cannot be used as a valid parameter of impairment evaluation; the Panel used its discretion in considering what weight to give other available evidence to determine if an impairment was present.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:  

CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION

1.     The Review Panel revokes the certificate of Medical Assessor Ian Cameron dated 6 June 2023 regarding permanent impairment.

2.     The Review Panel issues a new certificate determining that:

(a)    the following injuries were caused by the motor accident and give rise to a permanent impairment of 7% which is not greater than 10%:

·         head – soft tissue injury – now resolved;

·         cervical spine – soft tissue injury now resolved;

·         left shoulder/arm – soft tissue injury with healed proximal humeral fracture – 7% whole person impairment;

·         left leg – soft tissue injury – now resolved, and

·         right leg – soft tissue injury – now resolved.

(b)    The following injuries were not caused by the motor accident:

·         right shoulder – soft tissue injury.

REVIEW PANEL REASONS FOR DECISION

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 12 July 2018 Mohammad Hassan Habib (the claimant) was a front seat passenger in a 1998 Toyota Camry driven by his wife. The car left the road and ran into a tree on McCourt Street Wiley Park.

  2. In his application for personal injury benefits form Mr Hassan says that as a result of the accident his injuries included: fractured left humerus, neck injury, right leg and left leg injury, injuries to both shoulders, head injury and left rib injury.[1]

    [1] Claimant’s bundle A 1 p 25.

  3. Mr Hassan has brought a claim for common law damages under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the MAI Act).

  4. AAI Ltd t/as GIO (the insurer) is the relevant insurer with liability to pay any damages to Mr Hassan under the MAI Act.

  5. Section 4.11 of the MAI Act provides that there is no entitlement to damages for non-economic loss unless the degree of permanent impairment of the injured person as a result of the injury caused by the accident is greater than 10%.

  6. This dispute is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Habib v AAI Limited t/as GIO and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWPICMP 96
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Habib v AAI Limited t/as GIO involved a dispute over the extent of permanent impairment suffered by the claimant, Mr Hassan, following a motor vehicle accident in which he was a front seat passenger. The accident resulted in injuries including a fractured upper arm and soft tissue injuries. The primary issue was whether the accident contributed to or exacerbated any pre-existing conditions, and the degree of impairment if any, was caused by the accident.

The legal issues before the court were whether the motor vehicle accident materially contributed to any of Mr Hassan's shoulder conditions and whether the measurements taken during the examination were reliable indicators of impairment. Given the history of prior injuries and conditions, the court had to assess the relevance and weight of pre-accident medical records and compare them with post-accident conditions to determine the extent of impairment attributable to the accident.

The court found that while Mr Hassan did suffer a fractured upper arm and soft tissue injuries, the motor vehicle accident did not materially contribute to any right shoulder condition nor exacerbate any such condition. The inconsistency in the left and right shoulder range of motion measurements at the time of examination rendered them an invalid parameter for evaluating impairment. The Panel exercised its discretion to weigh other available evidence to determine if an impairment was present, ultimately concluding a total whole person impairment of 7% for the left shoulder/arm. The court set aside the original medical certificate regarding the degree of permanent impairment.

The final orders of the court were to set aside the original medical certificate regarding the degree of permanent impairment and to recognise a total whole person impairment of 7% for the left shoulder/arm.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Pre-accident treatment medical evidence[15] Claimant’s bundle A 18 pp 79-81. There were comprehensive medical records available for the claimant’s medical history prior to motor vehicle accident. In bundles of documents the parties produced over 600 pages of clinical and treating medical records including medico-legal reports for the claimant prior to the subject motor accident. The Panel has reviewed all the pre-accident treating medical records produced by both the claimant and the insurer. Some of these pre-accident medical reports are referred to briefly below. The Panel notes that the pre-accident medical evidence shows that Mr Hassan reported a significant previous history of numerous injuries including to his neck, spine, shoulders, knees and arms. These records refer to two possible prior workplace accidents in 2001 and 2002 and one prior motor accident in 2015.[16][16] It is unclear from the medical records whether there was one or two workplace accidents in 2001 or 2002. The records from A to Z Medical Centre show longstanding musculoskeletal joint pain with restricted lumbar spine motion with complaints of back and buttock pain recorded from the commencement of the notes in August 2009.[17] Neck pain with radiculopathy, back pain and left knee pain are recorded by Dr Alsayed in August 2009. The medical notes record neck pain with radiculopathy and back pain recorded repeatedly throughout the medical file from 2009 to 2020. The claimant also reported bilateral shoulder pain which was noted on 6 January 2014.[17] See A16 pp 125 to 574 and MAS Medical Assessment Certificate from Medical Assessor Alan Home, insurer’s bundle R 9 pp 59-70. There a detailed summary of the claimant’s medical conditions dated 10 August 2015 prepared by his treating general practitioner Dr Alsayed.[18] These conditions included canal stenosis of the lumbar spine, disc osteophyte complexes in the cervical spine at the C3/C4 and C4/C5 levels and left knee contusion.[18] Claimant’s bundle A 15 p 92. The clinical notes in the period leading up to the 2015 motor vehicle accident, there is reference to joint pain, restricted movement, back pain with restricted tolerances and ongoing treatment with Panadeine Forte analgesia, as recorded by Dr Alsayed on 9 October 2015. Neck pain with radiculopathy, back pain and shoulder pain are recorded in August 2015. Asymmetrical spinal motion with complaints of sciatica is recorded by Dr Alsayed in August 2015. On 6 July 2017 the claimant had a consultation with Dr Alsayed who noted: “pt still complaining of lower back pain rediate to lt leg seen in ED and another GP given palexia 150 mg bd but did not take it pt had ctscam LS SPINE EXPLAIN results.”[19] [19] Claimant’s bundle A 16 p 209. There are detailed clinical notes from neurosurgeon Dr Simon McKechnie from 2014 onwards.[20] In a report dated 28 October 2020 Dr McKechnie wrote that he saw Mr Hassan on 19 March 2014. He said that the claimant suffered a workplace injury in 2002 was lifting a heavy drum of oil. He developed the onset of neck, lower back and left knee pain and his symptoms have continued since that time. Recently the claimant reported an increase in neck and lower back pain and intermittent radiation to the left arm and left leg.[20] Claimant’s bundle A 15 p 83-124.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.