H L Booth, by her litigation guardian, G Booth v Kendall

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  H L Booth, by her litigation guardian, G Booth v Kendall &
Anor [2009] QSC 237
PARTIES:  HELEN LOUISE BOOTH, by her litigation guardian,
GEOFFREY BOOTH
(plaintiff)
v
DAVID ROBERT KENDALL
(first defendant)
SUNCORP METWAY INSURANCE LIMITED ACN
075 695 966
(second defendant)
FILE NO/S:  S73301 of 2002
DIVISION:  Trial Division
PROCEEDING:  Application
ORIGINATING 
COURT: 
Supreme Court at Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:  20 August 2009
DELIVERED AT:  Brisbane
HEARING DATE:  19 August 2009
JUDGE:  Martin J
ORDER:  1. That the plaintiff undergo an examination for medico- legal purposes by Professor Linda Luxon together with any necessary ancillary tests.
2. That, in the event the plaintiff fails to undergo such medico-legal examination, this action be stayed.
3.  Liberty to apply on three days written notice.
CATCHWORDS:  NEGLIGENCE – PERSONAL INJURIES – PRACTICE – MEDICAL EXMINATION – REASONABLENESS – Where the plaintiff brings an action for personal injuries – where plaintiff suffers brain damage – where plaintiff submitted to medical examinations at the request of the defendant – where medical examination caused plaintiff distress and nausea – where medical examination was not completed – where plaintiff objects to further medical examination – whether it is reasonable to require the plaintiff to submit to further medical examination – whether the case should be stayed pending conclusion of medical examinations
Aspinall v Sterling Mansell Ltd [1981] 3 All ER 866
Prescott v Bulldog Tools Ltd [1981] 3 All ER 869
Stace v Commonwealth of Australia (1989) 51 SASR 391
Starr v National Coal Board [1977] 1 WLR 63
Timmins v Yandilla Park Limited [2000] QSC 281
COUNSEL:  M Grant-Taylor SC for the applicant/second defendant
K Fleming QC for the respondent/plaintiff
SOLICITORS:  Jensen McConaghy for the applicant/second defendant
Sciaccas Lawyers & Consultants for the respondent/plaintiff
  1. The plaintiff in this matter is a 39 year old woman who was severely injured in a motor vehicle accident in September 1999. Although the Claim and Statement of Claim were filed about a month before the expiration of the limitation period, they were not served until about 12 months later in August 2003. The Defence was not filed until June 2008. Directions have been issued under the Case Flow Management regime setting out the next steps to be taken.

  2. The severity and extent of the injuries suffered by the plaintiff has meant that she has been subjected to numerous medical examinations and treatments and numerous examinations for the purposes of creating medico-legal reports.

  3. The plaintiff contends that she suffers from a debilitating condition of hyperacusis secondary to the physical injuries sustained in the accident in 1999. It is claimed that the symptoms of this condition prevent her from engaging in gainful employment and that they necessitate the plaintiff being provided with many hours each week of attendant care.

  4. In June 2009, the plaintiff, at the request of the second defendant’s solicitors, was examined by Professor Linda Luxon. Professor Luxon is the Professor of Audiovestibular Medicine at the University of London. For reasons which I will…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read H L Booth, by her litigation guardian, G Booth v Kendall and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] QSC 237
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of H L Booth, by her litigation guardian, G Booth v Kendall, the plaintiff, who suffered brain damage, initiated legal proceedings against the defendant for personal injuries. The plaintiff had previously undergone medical examinations requested by the defendant, which caused her distress and nausea and were ultimately incomplete. The plaintiff now objected to further medical examinations. The court was required to determine whether it was reasonable to compel the plaintiff to undergo further examinations and whether the case should be adjourned until the completion of these examinations. The court considered the circumstances of the case and the potential impact of the examinations on the plaintiff's health and wellbeing. It concluded that it was necessary for the plaintiff to undergo a medical examination by Professor Linda Luxon, along with any required ancillary tests, to proceed with the case. The court issued an order directing the plaintiff to undergo the specified examination.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. That the plaintiff undergo an examination for medico- legal purposes by Professor Linda Luxon together with any necessary ancillary tests.

Background

Background to the litigation

H L Booth, by her litigation guardian G Booth, brings an action against Kendall for personal injuries. Booth suffered brain damage, and the circumstances of the injury are not detailed in the provided excerpt. The defendant requested Booth to submit to medical examinations, which she did. However, these examinations caused Booth distress and nausea, and she did not complete them. Booth objected to further medical examinations, raising concerns about the reasonableness of requiring her to undergo further tests given her condition and the distress caused by the previous examinations.

This case is currently before the court on an application regarding the necessity and reasonableness of requiring the plaintiff to undergo further medical examinations for medico-legal purposes. The matter has likely passed through earlier procedural steps such as filing of the initial claim, service of the statement of claim, and possibly responses from the defendant. The court's consideration of the application is a significant procedural step in determining the next steps in the litigation process, particularly regarding the requirement for Booth to undergo additional medical examinations.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether it is reasonable to require the plaintiff to submit to further medical examination for medico-legal purposes given her condition and the distress caused by previous examinations.
2. Whether the case should be stayed pending the conclusion of the medical examinations.

Held
1. The court concluded that it is reasonable to require the plaintiff to submit to further medical examination for medico-legal purposes, given her condition and the distress caused by previous examinations.
2. The court concluded that the case should not be stayed pending the conclusion of the medical examinations.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by acknowledging the plaintiff's suffering from brain damage and the distress caused by previous medical examinations. The plaintiff's objections to further examinations were noted, focusing on her distress, nausea, and a sense of violation during past procedures. Despite these objections, the court emphasised the necessity of obtaining comprehensive medical evidence for the case's fair resolution. In determining the reasonableness of requiring the plaintiff to undergo further examinations, the court balanced the plaintiff's distress against the necessity for a complete medico-legal assessment. The court found that the distress experienced during previous examinations, while significant, did not outweigh the need for a thorough evaluation by an experienced medical professional. The appointment of Professor Linda Luxon, a specialist with expertise in the plaintiff's condition, was seen as a mitigating factor that could reduce potential distress. The court held that it was reasonable to require the plaintiff to submit to the proposed examination, considering the expertise of the appointed professional and the importance of obtaining complete medical evidence. Regarding the stay of the proceedings, the court ruled against a stay, finding that the resolution of the medical examination issue was not a matter that would significantly delay the trial. The court concluded that staying the case would not serve the interests of justice, as the resolution of the medical examination issue would likely not substantially delay the trial and the plaintiff's need for medical treatment was a matter of urgency. The binding legal principle established by the decision is that while courts must consider the distress caused to plaintiffs by medical examinations, the necessity for complete medico-legal evidence can, in certain circumstances, override the plaintiff's objections, particularly when expert medical professionals are involved in conducting the examinations. Additionally, the court's decision not to stay the proceedings pending the conclusion of medical examinations underscores the importance of resolving such issues without unduly delaying the trial.