Guild Insurance Limited v Chief Executive Medicare

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Guild Insurance Limited v Chief Executive Medicare [2020] FCA 1170

File number(s): NSD 490 of 2019
Judge(s): PERRY J
Date of judgment: 14 August 2020
Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – judicial review of decisions by respondent rejecting application by insurer/applicant for payment of a high cost indemnity under s 30(1) of the Medical Indemnity Act 2002 (Cth) (“Act”) – proper construction of s 30(1)(a) providing that a high cost indemnity is payable to an insurer where “a claim” as defined in s 4(1) is “made against a person (the practitioner)” – where “person” means individual practitioner and not corporation – whether claim made against a “person” where the person was not party to legal proceedings for damages against her employer but the employer was said to be vicariously liable for the person’s breach – whether deed settling legal proceedings against the employer constituted or was evidence of a claim against the person for the purposes of s 30(1)(a) – whether pre-action notice issued directly to the person under s 9A, Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 (Qld), constituted a claim against the person for the purposes of s 30(1) of the Act – whether conceded error in application of s 30(2) of the Act was material so as to establish jurisdictional error – whether grant of relief under Administrative Appeals (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) lacks utility - application dismissed
Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) ss 2, 2C, 15AA

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth)

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth)

Medical Indemnity Act 2002 (Cth) ss 4, 30(1), 30(2)

Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 (Qld) ss 9, 9A

Cases cited:

Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue (Northern Territory) [2009] HCA 41; (2009) 239 CLR 27

CIC Insurance Ltd v Bankstown Football Club Ltd [1997] HCA 2; (1997) 187 CLR 384

Commonwealth v Baume (1905) 2 CLR 405

Corporate Affairs Commission (NSW) v Yuill [1991] HCA 28; (1991) 172 CLR 319

Hollis v Vabu Pty Ltd [2001] HCA 44; (2001) 207 CLR 21

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZMTA [2019] HCA 3; (2019) 264 CLR 421

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang [1996] HCA 6; (1996) 185 CLR 259

Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority [1998] HCA 28; (1998) 194 CLR 335

SZTAL v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] HCA 34; (2017) 262 CLR 362

Date of hearing: 31 July 2020 and 12 August 2020
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 72
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr D Lloyd
Solicitor for the Applicant: Meridian Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr S Lloyd SC with Ms J Davidson
Solicitor for the Respondent: Sparke Helmore

ORDERS

NSD 490 of 2019
BETWEEN:

GUILD INSURANCE LIMITED ACN 004 538 863

Applicant

AND:

CHIEF EXECUTIVE MEDICARE

Respondent

JUDGE:

PERRY J

DATE OF ORDER:

14 AUGUST 2020

THE…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Guild Insurance Limited v Chief Executive Medicare and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1170
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Guild Insurance Limited brought an application for judicial review of two decisions by Chief Executive Medicare to reject applications by the Insurer for payment of a high cost indemnity under s 30(1) of the Medical Indemnity Act 2002 (Cth) (“Act”) for two separate claims. The first related to a claim made against Ms Suzanne Jarschke, a chiropractor and sole director of Wellspring Chiropractic Centre Pty Ltd, trading as Wellspring Chiropractic. The second related to a claim made against Ms Clare Buckley, also a chiropractor employed by Wellspring. The Court was required to determine whether the Chief Executive’s delegate correctly interpreted s 30(1)(a) of the Act to require that a “claim” be made against a person within the meaning of that section, and whether the delegate’s failure to do so was a jurisdictional error. The Court was also required to determine whether the concession by the Insurer that it had erred in its application of s 30(2) of the Act meant that the grant of relief under the Administrative Appeals (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) would be futile.

The Court found that the term “person” in s 30(1)(a) of the Act referred to an individual practitioner and not a corporation. The Court also found that there was no jurisdictional error in the Chief Executive’s delegate’s decision that there was no claim against Ms Jarschke because she was not a party to the legal proceedings, and that the deed settling the claim against her employer did not constitute a claim against her for the purposes of s 30(1)(a). The Court also found that a pre-action notice issued directly to Ms Jarschke under s 9A, Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 (Qld), did not constitute a claim against her for the purposes of s 30(1) of the Act. Finally, the Court found that the concession by the Insurer that it had erred in its application of s 30(2) of the Act did not mean that the grant of relief under the Administrative Appeals (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) would be futile.

The application was dismissed and costs were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application filed on 27 March 2019 is dismissed insofar as the application sought judicial review under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) and s 39B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) of the following decisions made by delegates of the respondent:

(a) Decision with Medicare reference number ARN2581-1G-H dated 27 February 2019 in respect of the applicant’s application for payment of a high cost indemnity under the Medical Indemnity Act 2002 (Cth) in relation to a claim allegedly made against Ms Suzanne Jarschke;

(b) Decision with Medicare reference number ARN2585-1G-H dated 29 November 2018 in respect of the applicant’s application for payment of a high cost indemnity under the Medical Indemnity Act 2002 (Cth) in relation to a claim allegedly made against Ms Clare Buckley.

2. Costs are reserved.

3. In the event that the parties are not agreed as to the appropriate order as to costs:

(a) on or before 4pm on 28 August 2020, the applicant is to file and serve written submissions of no more than 5 pages in support of the orders as to costs which it seeks, together with any evidence in support;

(b) on or before 4pm on 4 September 2020, the respondent is to file and serve written submissions of no more than 5 pages in response, together with any evidence in response; and

(c) on or before 4pm on 9 September 2020, the applicant is to file and serve any written submissions of no more than three pages in reply.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts set out below pertaining to the two decisions have been drawn from the SAF, save where otherwise indicated. 3.1 Facts pertaining to the Jarschke decision In 2012 and 2013, Wellspring Chiropractic Centre Pty Ltd, trading as Wellspring Chiropractic (Wellspring), carried on the business of providing chiropractic health services in Queensland. Ms Jarschke worked as a registered chiropractor for Wellspring and was the sole director of Wellspring. The Insurer and Ms Jarschke entered into an insurance contract comprising the Guild Chiropractors Insurance Policy and Schedule for policy number 44/40CHR0219007 for a period of insurance from 4 March 2013 to 4 March 2014 (Jarschke Insurance Policy) (Annexure A to the SAF). Under the Jarschke Insurance Policy, the Applicant agreed to provide chiropractors’ liabilities insurance to Ms Jarschke and any corporation having an interest in her liabilities on a “claims made” basis (SAF at [7]). It was also agreed that Wellspring had an interest in the liabilities of Ms Jarschke (SAF at [8]). The schedule set out the details of Ms Jarschke’s cover under the policy. In the Schedule to the Jarschke Insurance Policy:(1)Ms Jarschke was named as “The Insured”;(2)insurance coverage under “Section 9 - Chiropractors’ Liabilities” was selected; and(3)31 December 1985 was the “Retroactive Date”. Section 9 in turn contained the following relevant definitions: You or YourThe person or persons named in the Schedule;The firm or incorporated body or unincorporated body named in the Schedule;Any corporation … having an interest in the liabilities of the party or parties named in the preceding sub-clauses 1 or 2 …Chiropractic PracticeThe professional work or practice of a registered chiropractor.Professional Duty as a ChiropractorThe professional duty owed by You in the course of providing those services, including the provision of information and advice, which You are empowered to provide by virtue of registration as a chiropractor under the terms of the Chiropractors Registration Act or other similar legislation in the relevant state or territory of Australia.ClaimA demand or assertion of a right to compensation by reason of an actual or alleged breach of duty arising out of any act, error, omission or conduct and which is defined in legal proceedings instituted and served upon You. The operative part of cl 9 of the Jarschke Insurance Policy relevantly provided that:We will to the extent provided for in this Section and limited to the Sum Insured shown in the Schedule provide cover for:Claims MadeAny Claim including all legal costs and expenses for which You become legally liable in respect of the Cover provided under this Section being a Claim:i.Made against You during the Period of Cover shown in the Schedule; andii.Immediately notified to Us in writing by You during the Period of Cover; andiii.Arising out of any act, error, omission or conduct which occurred after the Retroactive Date.What is CoveredWe will Cover You for Your civil liability:A. Breach of Professional Duty as a Chiropractor:Arising from any Breach of Professional Duty as a Chiropractor by reason of any actual or alleged act, error, omission or conduct committed by:1. You; or2. Your employees and any persons for whom You are vicariously liable in the conduct of The Practice at the Practice Premises;

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Finally, I note that this matter was originally listed for hearing on 17 March 2020 but was adjourned by consent on 16 March 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic.2. EVIDENCE The parties were in agreement as to the relevant facts which were set out in a Statement of Agreed Facts (Ex A1) (SAF), to which the relevant documents were annexed. I note that the SAF was amended so as to omit those paragraphs and documents relating to six other decisions which were originally challenged on the basis that the respondent’s delegate had erred in her or his construction of s 30(2)(b) of the Act (the s 30(2)(b) decisions). However orders were made by consent on 30 October 2019 quashing the s 30(2)(b) decisions and writs of mandamus were issued requiring Medicare to determine the applications in question according to law: see below at [62] and [72]. Those paragraphs which remain relevant and were received in evidence were paragraphs 1 to 24 and 111 to 125 of the SAF with their associated annexures. The applicant also relied upon the affidavit of Mr Rhett Clayton, National Liability Claims Manager for the Insurer, affirmed on 27 March 2019, together with exhibits 1 to 5, 21 to 23 and 29 to his affidavit (Exhibit A3). In addition a letter dated 11 April 2014 from Rees R & Sydney Jones Solicitors dated 11 April 2014 to Ms Buckley enclosing an “Initial Notice – Section 9A of the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002” was received as exhibit A2. Aside from tendering Form 2 – Notice of Claim under the PIP Act (Exhibit R1) in relation to the Buckley decision, Medicare did not seek to rely upon any additional evidence.3. BACKGROUND The facts set out below pertaining to the two decisions have been drawn from the SAF, save where otherwise indicated. 3.1 Facts pertaining to the Jarschke decision In 2012 and 2013, Wellspring Chiropractic Centre Pty Ltd, trading as Wellspring Chiropractic (Wellspring), carried on the business of providing chiropractic health services in Queensland. Ms Jarschke worked as a registered chiropractor for Wellspring and was the sole director of Wellspring. The Insurer and Ms Jarschke entered into an insurance contract comprising the Guild Chiropractors Insurance Policy and Schedule for policy number 44/40CHR0219007 for a period of insurance from 4 March 2013 to 4 March 2014 (Jarschke Insurance Policy) (Annexure A to the SAF). Under the Jarschke Insurance Policy, the Applicant agreed to provide chiropractors’ liabilities insurance to Ms Jarschke and any corporation having an interest in her liabilities on a “claims made” basis (SAF at [7]). It was also agreed that Wellspring had an interest in the liabilities of Ms Jarschke (SAF at [8]). The schedule set out the details of Ms Jarschke’s cover under the policy. In the Schedule to the Jarschke Insurance Policy:(1)Ms Jarschke was named as “The Insured”;(2)insurance coverage under “Section 9 - Chiropractors’ Liabilities” was selected; and(3)31 December 1985 was the “Retroactive Date”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The parties were in agreement as to the relevant facts which were set out in a Statement of Agreed Facts (Ex A1) (SAF), to which the relevant documents were annexed. I note that the SAF was amended so as to omit those paragraphs and documents relating to six other decisions which were originally challenged on the basis that the respondent’s delegate had erred in her or his construction of s 30(2)(b) of the Act (the s 30(2)(b) decisions). However orders were made by consent on 30 October 2019 quashing the s 30(2)(b) decisions and writs of mandamus were issued requiring Medicare to determine the applications in question according to law: see below at [62] and [72]. Those paragraphs which remain relevant and were received in evidence were paragraphs 1 to 24 and 111 to 125 of the SAF with their associated annexures. The applicant also relied upon the affidavit of Mr Rhett Clayton, National Liability Claims Manager for the Insurer, affirmed on 27 March 2019, together with exhibits 1 to 5, 21 to 23 and 29 to his affidavit (Exhibit A3). In addition a letter dated 11 April 2014 from Rees R & Sydney Jones Solicitors dated 11 April 2014 to Ms Buckley enclosing an “Initial Notice – Section 9A of the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002” was received as exhibit A2. Aside from tendering Form 2 – Notice of Claim under the PIP Act (Exhibit R1) in relation to the Buckley decision, Medicare did not seek to rely upon any additional evidence.3. BACKGROUND The facts set out below pertaining to the two decisions have been drawn from the SAF, save where otherwise indicated. 3.1 Facts pertaining to the Jarschke decision In 2012 and 2013, Wellspring Chiropractic Centre Pty Ltd, trading as Wellspring Chiropractic (Wellspring), carried on the business of providing chiropractic health services in Queensland. Ms Jarschke worked as a registered chiropractor for Wellspring and was the sole director of Wellspring. The Insurer and Ms Jarschke entered into an insurance contract comprising the Guild Chiropractors Insurance Policy and Schedule for policy number 44/40CHR0219007 for a period of insurance from 4 March 2013 to 4 March 2014 (Jarschke Insurance Policy) (Annexure A to the SAF). Under the Jarschke Insurance Policy, the Applicant agreed to provide chiropractors’ liabilities insurance to Ms Jarschke and any corporation having an interest in her liabilities on a “claims made” basis (SAF at [7]). It was also agreed that Wellspring had an interest in the liabilities of Ms Jarschke (SAF at [8]). The schedule set out the details of Ms Jarschke’s cover under the policy. In the Schedule to the Jarschke Insurance Policy:(1)Ms Jarschke was named as “The Insured”;(2)insurance coverage under “Section 9 - Chiropractors’ Liabilities” was selected; and(3)31 December 1985 was the “Retroactive Date”. Section 9 in turn contained the following relevant definitions: You or YourThe person or persons named in the Schedule;The firm or incorporated body or unincorporated body named in the Schedule;Any corporation … having an interest in the liabilities of the party or parties named in the preceding sub-clauses 1 or 2 …Chiropractic PracticeThe professional work or practice of a registered chiropractor.Professional Duty as a ChiropractorThe professional duty owed by You in the course of providing those services, including the provision of information and advice, which You are empowered to provide by virtue of registration as a chiropractor under the terms of the Chiropractors Registration Act or other similar legislation in the relevant state or territory of Australia.ClaimA demand or assertion of a right to compensation by reason of an actual or alleged breach of duty arising out of any act, error, omission or conduct and which is defined in legal proceedings instituted and served upon You.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.