Grow Asset Finance Pty Ltd v Bassi

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  Grow Asset Finance Pty Ltd v Bassi & Anor [2022] QDC 23
PARTIES:  GROW ASSET FINANCE PTY LTD
(plaintiff)
v
JATINDER SINGH BASSI
(first defendant)
and
SATNAM KAUR SAHOTA
(second defendant)
FILE NO:  3149/2021
DIVISION:  Civil
PROCEEDING:  Application
ORIGINATING  Brisbane District Court
COURT: 
DELIVERED ON:  17 February 2022
DELIVERED AT:  Brisbane
HEARING DATE:  Listed for hearing on the papers on 11 February 2022.
JUDGE:  Byrne QC DCJ
ORDERS: 
1.  The application is dismissed.
2.  There be no order as to costs.
CATCHWORDS:  PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – JUDGMENTS AND ORDERS – SUBSTITUTED SERVICE – EX PARTE – EVIDENCE - whether application for substituted service should be granted – where the affidavit supporting the application attached a
report from a process service firm – where the affidavit did not directly depose to the truth of the contents of the report – where the report contained hearsay on hearsay - whether there is sufficient admissible evidence to grant the application
LEGISLATION:  Evidence Act 1977
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules
CASES:  Bendigo & Adelaide Bank Limited v Wilkin & Anor [2018]
QDC 16
Permanent Custodians Limited v Smith [2006] QSC 333
COUNSEL:  No appearance
SOLICITORS:  SLF Lawyers for the applicant.
Introduction 
  1. The plaintiff has applied, ex parte, for an order authorising substituted service pursuant to r 116 of the UCPR on the first defendant in an action earlier commenced in this Court. It was requested that the matter be heard on the papers.

  2. The application is not, in my view, supported by sufficient admissible evidence and so must be refused. Alternatively, if the material is admissible, I am not satisfied of the matters required to grant the application.

    Background

  3. On 3 December 2021 the plaintiff commenced an action against the first and second defendants claiming monies owing under a Rental Agreement and Guarantee executed in respect of certain goods, possession of specified real property, interest and other ancillary orders.

[4]

The second defendant was served with the Claim and Statement of Claim on for the whole of the money claim.

  1. On 19 January 2022 the plaintiff filed the present application for substituted service on the first defendant. An affidavit has been sworn in support of the application and is the only source of evidence to support it.

  2. The application relies on two categories of evidence. The first is a Title Search showing the first defendant to be the registered owner of a particular parcel of land. As is the usual course, that document does not refer to that land in terms of a street address. The manner of drafting the affidavit tends to imply that it refers to the stated address the subject of the application. This issue may not have caused the application to be refused if it stood alone, but it does not.

  3. The second category of evidence relied on is a report from a process service firm outlining the attempts that were said to have been undertaken to serve the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Grow Asset Finance Pty Ltd v Bassi and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QDC 23
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Grow Asset Finance Pty Ltd v Bassi involved the plaintiff, Grow Asset Finance, seeking to serve a writ of summons on the first defendant, Mr. Bassi, through substituted service. The plaintiff had already initiated legal proceedings against Mr. Bassi and a second defendant, seeking various reliefs including the recovery of monies under a rental agreement and guarantee, possession of property, and ancillary orders. Despite attempts to serve the writ on Mr. Bassi personally, the plaintiff filed an application for substituted service, relying on an affidavit and a report from a process service firm. The application was dismissed by the court.

The central legal issue the court had to address was whether the application for substituted service was supported by sufficient admissible evidence and, if so, whether it met the requirements for granting such an application. The court scrutinized the affidavit, which was the sole source of evidence in support of the application. The affidavit included a title search indicating Mr. Bassi as the registered owner of a specific parcel of land and a report from a process service firm detailing attempts to serve the writ and a conversation with a nearby resident about the occupancy status of the address in question. The court found that the affidavit did not adequately depose to the truth of the contents of the report and that the statements of belief regarding conclusions the court must make were not proper subject matter for the deponent to swear to.

The court further noted that the report itself was insufficient as it did not specify the identity of the agent who attempted service, making it unclear whether the same individual was involved in all attempts. The court concluded that the application was not supported by sufficient admissible evidence and, even if the material was admissible, it was not satisfied of the matters required to grant the application. Consequently, the application for substituted service was dismissed. No order was made as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The application is dismissed.

2.

There be no order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The application is not, in my view, supported by sufficient admissible evidence and so must be refused. Alternatively, if the material is admissible, I am not satisfied of the matters required to grant the application. Background On 3 December 2021 the plaintiff commenced an action against the first and second defendants claiming monies owing under a Rental Agreement and Guarantee executed in respect of certain goods, possession of specified real property, interest and other ancillary orders. On 19 January 2022 the plaintiff filed the present application for substituted service on the first defendant. An affidavit has been sworn in support of the application and is the only source of evidence to support it. The application relies on two categories of evidence. The first is a Title Search showing the first defendant to be the registered owner of a particular parcel of land. As is the usual course, that document does not refer to that land in terms of a street address. The manner of drafting the affidavit tends to imply that it refers to the stated address the subject of the application. This issue may not have caused the application to be refused if it stood alone, but it does not. The second category of evidence relied on is a report from a process service firm outlining the attempts that were said to have been undertaken to serve the first defendant, as well as the nature of a conversation with a nearby resident concerning the occupancy status of the stated address. This report is exhibited to the affidavit, apparently in an attempt to place the matter before this Court on the basis of information and belief – r 430(2) of the UCPR. The nature and scope of information that can be properly placed before the court on an “information and belief” basis was considered by Porter QC DCJ in Bendigo & Adelaide Bank Limited v Wilkin & Anor[1] (“Wilkin”). It is unnecessary to repeat what his Honour there noted, but I adopt his observations. Many of the same issues concerning inadmissibility of the assertions in the affidavit that arose in Wilkin arise here. [1] [2018] QDC 16, [9]-[17]. First, while the deponent identifies the source of the information as being the report exhibited to the affidavit, she does not specifically depose to a belief in the truth of any or all of its contents. Towards the end of the affidavit, and after a summary of the report, that she does “verily believe” that reasonable efforts have been made to effect personal service, that service is being avoided, that further attendance at the stated address will not guarantee personal service and that the documents will come to the attention of the first defendant if posted by Express Post to the stated address. These are all statements of belief about conclusions the court must make. They are not proper subject matter for the deponent to swear to and they do not cure the Second, the report refers to “our agent” having attempted service at various times at the stated address. It does not refer to the identity of the agent, nor if it was the same agent on each occasion. While it might be reasonably inferred as being the same person who effected service on the second defendant when referring to an attempt on 6 December 2021, the Court cannot be expected to trawl through the Court file to find the identity of that person.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established