Grima and K & S Freighters Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

Grima and K & S Freighters Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2023] AATA 769 (17 April 2023)

ReviewNumber:     2022/2714, 2022/2718

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2022/2714, 2022/2718

Re:Daniel Grima

APPLICANT

AndK & S Freighters Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

Date:17 April 2023

Place:Melbourne

The decisions under review dated 15 February 2022 and 24 March 2022 are affirmed.

..............................[sgd]..........................................

Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – rehabilitation – whether failure to undertake program without reasonable excuse – consideration of meaning of undertake – decisions affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988

Cases

Ahmed Ismailjee and Australian Postal Corporation [1995] AATA 555
Australian Postal Corporation v Forgie [2003] FCAFC 223
Ripper and Australian Postal Corporation [2015] AATA 15

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

17 April 2023

BACKGROUND

  1. Mr Grima lodged two applications for review of decisions related to his return to work following a collision in September 2020 in the course of his employment as a driver. His claim for compensation was accepted in November 2020, on the basis of the condition of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), and the Applicant subsequently undertook several rehabilitation programs.

  2. In November 2021, the Respondent determined that Mr Grima should undertake a further program and he duly commenced work under that program, subsequently taking leave in December 2021. Mr Grima’s leave was due to end on 7 February 2022, at which time approximately one week of this program remained to be completed.

  3. Prior to his returning from leave, the Respondent issued another draft rehabilitation plan in late January 2022. Following this, and according to Mr Grima as a result of the nature of this plan, he declined to return to work due to a deterioration in his mental health. At this point Mr Grima formally sought reconsideration of the November program.

  4. Both applications were lodged with the Tribunal on 30 March 2022. Application 2022/2714 is in respect of the Respondent’s determination, dated 15 February 2022, affirming the November program. Application 2022/2718 is in respect of the Respondent affirming a separate decision dated, 24 March 2022, in which Mr Grima’s rights to compensation were suspended pursuant to s 37(7) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act).

  5. The Applicant lodged a Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SFIC), a reply to written submissions of the Respondent (AR), and further written submissions (AFS). The Respondent lodged documents pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (T), an amended SFIC (RSFIC), and two sets of written submissions (RS and RFS, respectively). The parties lodged a joint hearing book (HB).

  6. Several documents were tendered by the Applicant during evidence:
    an email to Ms Mari from Mrs Grima dated 29 October 2021 (Exhibit A1); a general practitioner (GP) patient health summary (Exhibit A2); and, a letter to the Applicant from the Respondent dated 25 August 2021 (Exhibit A3). The Respondent tendered a bundle of email correspondence (Exhibit R1).

  7. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Grima and K & S Freighters Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 769
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Grima against K & S Freighters Pty Ltd regarding compensation for a workplace injury. The central dispute revolved around whether Mr Grima had a reasonable excuse for failing to undertake a rehabilitation program, specifically the final element of SDP 5.1, on 7 February 2022. The case was heard by Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member.

The legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine if Mr Grima had a reasonable excuse for not attending work to complete the last part of his rehabilitation program. This required considering the meaning of "undertake" in the context of rehabilitation programs and assessing whether Mr Grima's mental state, purportedly deteriorating upon receiving draft SDP 6, constituted a valid reason for non-compliance with SDP 5.1. The Tribunal also considered the conduct of the Respondent in developing and presenting the rehabilitation programs.

The Tribunal reasoned that while Mr Grima's mental state was a relevant consideration, the evidence did not unequivocally demonstrate a further deterioration prior to his medical appointments in early February 2022. Particular weight was given to the opinion of Dr Mohr, Mr Grima's treating specialist, who considered Mr Grima fit to complete the duties outlined for the week of 7 February 2022 and that it was in his best interests to do so. The Tribunal noted that Mr Grima had been aware for some time that his usual regional run had been contracted out, and that prior rehabilitation programs had been developed consultatively. The Tribunal found that the inclusion of the regional run in draft SDP 6 was an administrative error that could be rectified, and that Mr Grima's capacity to engage legal advisers indicated he had the faculties to confront his concerns.

Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed the original determination that Mr Grima was required to undertake SDP 5.1, finding it to be reasonable in all the circumstances, particularly based on Dr Mohr's opinion. The Tribunal concluded that Mr Grima had wholly ceased performance of the program without a reasonable excuse.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Neither party made comprehensive written or oral submissions with respect to the issues arising in Application 2022/2714, and the matter was conducted solely on the above issue. However, I have made relevant findings with respect to the question of the suitability of the November 2021 program.EVIDENCEMr Grima I will summarise briefly from Mr Grima’s written statement (HB3):(a)at the time of his injury in 2020, his usual driving run involved a return trip to a regional Victorian town from the Respondent’s Geelong depot ([10]);(b)following the accident, he experienced a range of symptoms affecting his mood and temperament ([15]);(c)the Respondent put together a number of rehabilitation programs and while he continued to experience symptoms, he also expressed to Ms Mari his wish to return to truck driving ([17]–[18]);(d)the November 2021 plan, known as Suitable Duties Plan (SDP) 5.1, accommodated his need to avoid driving past the scene of the accident, and he tried to avoid driving longer distances in general due to related anxiety ([19]);(e)just before Christmas 2021, he spoke with Ms Mari about returning to driving work in a graduated manner after his return from annual leave on 7 February 2022 ([20]–[21]);(f)a week or two before returning from leave he received SDP 6, which involved him returning to independent driving in the form of his original regional run. This caused his mental state to deteriorate significantly at the prospect of returning at the pace and in the manner outlined ([23]); and(g)he had travelled to Queensland by car as a passenger during the holidays as a travelling companion for a relative and this trip had caused a lot of anxiety ([25]). In his evidence at the hearing Mr Grima could not recall exactly when in early February he saw either Dr Mohr or his GP. He was unable to answer questions about the development or processing of SDP 6. Mr Grima confirmed that he was informed in mid-2021 that the regional run had been ‘subbed out’, meaning a contractor was performing the duties, noting that this affected the level of his benefits. Mr Grima stated that he and his wife both had a conversation with Ms Mari, which occurred in late 2021 (according to Mrs Grima’s statement (HB8)). The Applicant remembered Ms Mari saying that he could lose his benefits after 52 weeks. In cross-examination, Mr Grima agreed that his work hours increased over the course of SDP 5.1 to nearly full-time, and that upon his return from leave he would have just one week of the program left. He agreed that the process of approving programs followed the pattern of a draft including recommendations from the Respondent based on medical evidence, with input from himself. When pressed, he could not remember specifically having discussions with the Respondent about earlier plans. Mr Grima confirmed that his conversation with Ms Mari took place before Christmas 2021 but was unable to recall the context, or how the matters discussed came up. He could also not recall the circumstances leading to various notes made in late 2021 about his progress with programs, including about his desire to return to driving. He agreed that he discussed his return to driving with Dr Mohr, but was not certain when.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I noted above the limited attention afforded to the issue arising in matter 2022/2714. However for completeness, I find that the original determination that Mr Grima undertake SDP 5.1 was reasonable in all the circumstances. I make this finding in particular based on the opinion of Dr Mohr in February 2022 that Mr Grima could, and should, undertake this program.DECISION For the reasons given above, the Tribunal affirms the decisions under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

With respect to Ripper, the submissions essentially contend that this decision should be distinguished because the Tribunal there found that 75% compliance with the hours required in a rehabilitation program was the best the Applicant could attain; and, it may have been open to the Tribunal to find that the program in that instance was unsuitable ([27]–[31]). In summary, it is contended that there is no support in previous decisions for the view that ‘undertake’ may mean no more than to commence a program. Such a finding would deprive s 37(7) to address the mischief to which it is aimed ([32]–[33]). In any event, the analogy with Ripper is weak since in Mr Grima’s case, ‘he had wholly ceased performance of the program’ ([39]).CONSIDERATION The question at the centre of this matter is whether Mr Grima had a reasonable excuse not to attend work on 7 February 2022 to complete the last element of his then existing rehabilitation program. It is necessary to address this issue with some care, since the essential claim is that Mr Grima suffered a deterioration in his mental health upon receiving draft SDP 6. Unfortunately, the evidence as to the sequence of events in early February 2022 is not entirely clear, and Mr Grima himself did not provide particularly helpful evidence on these critical days. Equally, the Applicant’s case has to a significant extent, sought to construct an argument that there was some form of unreasonable conduct on the Respondent’s behalf that somehow excuse Mr Grima’s reaction. While the conduct of the Respondent’s representatives forms part of the evidentiary background, it is not, with respect, the true focus of the inquiry. I agree with the Applicant’s contention that limited emphasis should be put on the narrative around conversations about Mr Grima’s entitlements ending after 52 weeks. This narrative does appear to have some relevance to the Applicant’s state of mind, but I consider the evidence that the Respondent was somehow implicated to be very weak indeed. It is far more clear that there was an error in including the regional run in SDP 6. However, I accept the Respondent’s contentions that this was, from an administrative point of view, a relatively simple error to fix. Further, whatever Mr Grima’s personal competencies, the evidence demonstrates that all prior programs were developed in a consultative manner. Moreover, and more importantly, Mr Grima knew for many months that the regional run had been contracted out. In addition, the evidence strongly favours the view that Mr Grima had directly expressed a view that he was eager to return to driving. This was not understood by the Respondent as some supervening element of program development, but as a factor to consider, mediated by medical advice. Turning to the events in early February, I consider it appropriate to place particular weight on the opinion of Dr Mohr, Mr Grima’s treating specialist, that he was fit to complete SDP 5.1, or at least the duties as described for the week of 7 February 2022, and that it was in his interests to do so. It is also important to note that Dr Mohr came to this view despite observing Mr Grima to be distressed. There is no unequivocal evidence that he deteriorated further prior to seeing his GP and I consider the evidence of Dr Adesonaye to have been patchy and unsatisfactory. Equally, Dr Mohr was unable to substantiate in her evidence any further deterioration in Mr Grima’s situation. Furthermore, during this critical period, Mr Grima had demonstrated the capacity to engage legal advisers, which I consider demonstrates that he did not entirely lack the faculties or capacity to confront his concerns.