Griffith v Neilson

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read
13 CLR 131

RESPONDENT. APPLICANT,

ON APPEAL FROM THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS. Patent-Application for patent- Want of novelty-Amendment of specification-

Form of order-Extending time for sealing.

An application for a patent for an invention entitled "Non-Septic treat- ment of sewage and other organic liquid" was opposed on the ground of want of novelty, and the opposition was dismissed by the Commissioner. On appeal to the High Court,

Held, that as to certain of the claims a patent should not be granted, and as to others that a patent should not be granted, unless the applicant within one month should apply for and should obtain leave to amend the specifica- tion with regard to them respectively.

The time for sealing the patent was extended until one week after the expiration of the time for appealing from the final decision of the Commis- sioner in respect of the application to amend or on the final application for a patent or after the determination of any such appeal, as the case might be.

APPEAL from the Commissioner of Patents.

Mathew Montgomerie Neilson applied for a patent for an in- vention entitled " Non-septic treatment of sewage and other organic liquid."

The complete specification was as follows:- "This invention relates to the treatment of sewage and other foul waters, organic liquids or liquids containing organic matter, for the purpose of converting the same into innocuous liquid capable of ready disposal. The object of my invention is to pro- vide a thoroughly practical and efficient process for this purpose capable of producing a clear inodorous and harmless effluent, without the production of undue offensive and toxic gases, and

13 CLR 132

which system may advantageously replace the present septic'

tank process.

"According to the non-septic process I am introducing, the sewage is first allowed to ferment or in other words it is exposed to anaerobic action, in order to disintegrate the solids and render the whole amenable to the subsequent treatment, but the fer- mentation is not, as in the septic treatment, permitted to pass into putrefaction. Subsequently the sewage, before leaving the 'non-septie' tank, is subject to the action of aerobic micro- organisms, by which it is converted into the desired effluent. These aerobic micro-organisms may be permitted to grow natur- ally under suitable conditions (as e.g. a regular supply of oxygen in the treatment chambers or chamber), and, when desirable, suitable artificial cultures of same may be inoculated.

"The great advantage of the 'non-septic' tank system is-1, entire absence of smell even when uncovered; 2, very limited formation of sludge; 3, suitableness of its effluent for direct treatment through filter; 4, its smaller cost.

' While in the 'septic' tank system-1, there is invariably a smell from the tank and its putrid effluent; 2, there is an undue formation of secondary deposits; 3, the effluent is not prepared for the filter and, as nature can only work by evolution and not by leaps, the effluent is unsuitable until its foul gas is liberated…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Griffith v Neilson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1911] HCA 40
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Arthur Griffith, the appellant and Secretary for Public Works of New South Wales, appealed to the High Court against a decision of the Commissioner of Patents. The Commissioner had dismissed an opposition to an application for a patent by Mathew Montgomerie Neilson for an invention titled "Non-Septic treatment of sewage and other organic liquid." The opposition was based on the ground of want of novelty.

The legal issues before the High Court were whether the claims made in the patent application were novel, and if not, whether the specification could be amended to render them patentable. Specifically, the court had to consider the novelty of the claims relating to "translating chambers" for supplying effluent with oxygen, the addition of micro-organic and grub life, the application of a biological filter with automatic appliances, the construction of a percolating filter, and the use of a submerged aerobic filter supplied with oxygen.

The High Court, per Griffith C.J., found that several of the claims lacked novelty. The first claim, concerning "translating chambers," was deemed too broad as it did not sufficiently distinguish from prior art, specifically the "translation" process described by Wanklyn and Cooper. The fourth claim regarding the addition of micro-organic and grub life was found to lack novelty, as the addition of micro-organisms was a known practice, and "grub life" was insufficiently explained. The sixth claim for the construction of a percolating filter was found to be substantially identical to a filter described in existing literature. The seventh claim for a submerged aerobic filter was also found to lack novelty in its construction, with the novelty potentially lying only in the supply of oxygen, which was not adequately claimed as a combination.

Consequently, the High Court ordered that a patent should not be granted for certain claims as they stood. However, for other claims, a patent would not be granted unless the applicant applied for and obtained leave to amend the specification within one month. The time for sealing the patent was extended until one week after the expiration of the time for appealing from the Commissioner's final decision on the amendment application or the final patent application, or after the determination of any such appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mathew Montgomerie Neilson applied for a patent for an invention called the "Non-Septic Treatment of Sewage and Other Organic Liquid". The invention aimed to treat sewage and other foul waters, organic liquids, or liquids containing organic matter, converting them into an innocuous liquid suitable for disposal. The process involved allowing the sewage to ferment, then subjecting it to aerobic microorganisms to produce a clear, odorless, and harmless effluent. The specification detailed the construction and operation of the "non-septic" tank system, including the use of dip-boards and weirs to expose the effluent to air, and the use of aerobic microorganisms to treat the liquid. Various claims were made regarding the specific aspects of the invention.

The application was opposed by Charles A. Lee, the Secretary for Public Works, New South Wales, who argued that the invention lacked novelty. The Commissioner dismissed the opposition, allowing the patent application to proceed. Arthur Griffith, the current Secretary for Public Works, New South Wales, appealed this decision to the High Court.

The High Court found that while the invention had some novel elements, certain claims were too broad and not sufficiently distinct from existing knowledge. Specifically, the first claim regarding the use of "translating chambers" to supply oxygen to the effluent was deemed not novel. The fourth claim, involving the addition of microorganisms, was also found to lack novelty. The fifth claim, regarding the automatic appliances for working the biological filter, could be amended to be patentable. The sixth and seventh claims, concerning the construction of a filter and the use of a submerged aerobic filter, were found to be unpatentable due to their similarity to existing technology.

The Court allowed the appeal but granted the applicant an opportunity to amend the specification to clearly define the novel aspects of the invention. The time for sealing the patent was extended to allow for these amendments and any subsequent appeals. The respondent was ordered to pay the costs of the appeal.

This appeal arises from a decision of the Commissioner of Patents, who dismissed an opposition to the grant of a patent for an invention related to the "Non-Septic Treatment of Sewage and Other Organic Liquid." The appeal was brought by the Secretary for Public Works, New South Wales, who argued that the invention lacked novelty. The High Court allowed the appeal in part, finding that certain claims did not meet the novelty requirement for patentability. However, the Court granted the respondent an opportunity to amend the specification to address the novelty issues, with the time for sealing the patent extended until one week after the expiration of the time for appealing from the final decision of the Commissioner in respect of the application to amend or on the final application for a patent, or after the determination of any such appeal, as the case may be.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the invention described in the patent application novel and non-obvious in light of the prior art?
2. Does the first claim of the patent specification cover a novel and non-obvious invention?
3. Is the fourth claim of the patent specification for the addition of micro-organisms and "grub life" novel and non-obvious?
4. Can the fifth claim be amended to clearly cover the automatic appliances for working the biological filter?
5. Is the sixth claim for the percolating filter construction novel and non-obvious?
6. Does the seventh claim cover a novel and non-obvious combination of supplying oxygen with the use of a submerged filter?

Held
1. The court concluded that the invention described in the patent application was not novel and non-obvious in light of the prior art, leading to the dismissal of the appeal.
2. The court concluded that the first claim of the patent specification, which described the use of translating chambers to supply the effluent with oxygen from the air, was not novel and non-obvious, leading to the dismissal of the appeal.
3. The court concluded that the fourth claim of the patent specification for the addition of micro-organisms and "grub life" was not novel and non-obvious, leading to the dismissal of the appeal.
4. The court concluded that the fifth claim could be amended to clearly cover the automatic appliances for working the biological filter.
5. The court concluded that the sixth claim for the percolating filter construction was not novel and non-obvious, leading to the dismissal of the appeal.
6. The court concluded that the seventh claim, which described the application of a submerged aerobic filter supplied with oxygen, oxygenated water, or air, was not novel and non-obvious, leading to the dismissal of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court considered several issues regarding the patent application for "Non-Septic Treatment of Sewage and other Organic Liquid." Firstly, the Court held that the first claim of the patent was not novel because it covered the use of "translating chambers" in general, which was already known in the prior art, specifically in the work of Wanklyn and Cooper. The Court emphasized that the claim needed to be more specific to distinguish the invention from the prior art.

Secondly, the Court found that the fourth claim, which involved the addition of micro-organisms and "grub life" to facilitate the process, lacked novelty because the use of micro-organisms in sewage treatment was already known, and "grub life" was not sufficiently explained.

Thirdly, regarding the fifth claim for the automatic appliances for working the biological filter, the Court suggested that it could be amended to clearly cover the novel aspects of the invention, provided they were not already known in the prior art.

Fourthly, the sixth claim for the percolating filter construction was deemed not novel as it was substantially identical to the construction described in Dunbar and Calvert's book, despite differing opinions on its effectiveness.

Fifthly, the seventh claim, which involved the use of a submerged aerobic filter supplied with oxygen, was not considered novel because the combination of supplying oxygen with the submerged filter was already known. However, the Court acknowledged that a specific combination of this type might be novel and patentable if properly claimed.

In conclusion, the ratio decidendi of this case is that a patent should not be granted for claims that are not sufficiently novel or specific, as they do not meet the statutory requirements for patentability. The Court allowed the appeal in part and suggested that the respondent should have an opportunity to amend the specification to address the identified issues of novelty and specificity. The Court emphasized that the primary purpose of the patent system is to provide inventors with protection for truly novel and useful inventions, and amendments should be made to ensure that the patent claims meet these criteria.