CITATION: GRIFFITH & ORS v AUSTRALIAN BROADCASTING CORPORATION & ORS [2003] NSWSC 1244 revised - 2/02/2004 HEARING DATE(S): 19 December 2003 JUDGMENT DATE:
19 December 2003JUDGMENT OF: Levine J DECISION: 1. I decline to make order 1 in the short minutes of order handed up today but instead vary order 6 of the consent orders made by me on 26/10/2003 to require the defendants to file their defences by 5pm on Friday 6 February 2004.; 2. I make orders 2,3, and 4 in the short minutes of order handed up today.; 3. The costs of today abide the outcome of the hearing of the motion filed on 18 November 2003.; 4. List the matter before Nicholas J on 13 April 2004. CATCHWORDS: Defamation - practice and procedure - requirement of compliance with consent order to file defence notwithstanding separate question of law to be argued PARTIES :
JEREMY NORMAN GRIFFITH
(First Plaintiff)FOUNDATION FOR HUMANITY'S ADULTHOOD
(ACN 003 930 023)
(Second Plaintiff)TIMOTHY JOHN MACARTNEY-SNAPE
(Third Plaintiff)v
AUSTRALIAN BROADCASTING CORPORATION
DAVID MILLIKAN
(First Defendant)
(Second defendant)
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 20300 OF 2001 COUNSEL: K Smark
D Hogan-Doran
(Plaintiffs)
(Defendants)SOLICITORS: Schweizer Kobras
Baker & McKenzie
(Plaintiffs)
(Defendants)
- Ex tempore: revised
[2003] NSWSC 1244
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISION
DEFAMATION LIST
JUSTICE DAVID LEVINE
20300 OF 2001FRIDAY 19 DECEMBER 2003
JEREMY NORMAN GRIFFITH
(First Plaintiff)
FOUNDATION FOR HUMANITY’S ADULTHOOD
(ACN 003 930 023)
(Second Plaintiff)
TIMOTHY JOHN MACARTNEY-SNAPE
(Third Plaintiff)
v
AUSTRALIAN BROADCASTING CORPORATION
(First Defendant)
DAVID MILLIKAN
(Second defendant)
- JUDGMENT (Defamation – practice and procedure – requirement of compliance with consent order to file defence notwithstanding separate question of law to be argued)
1 On 27 October this year consent orders were made in relation to the conduct of this action. Amongst those orders were Orders 5 and 6, 5 being that the first, second and third plaintiffs serve a document incorporating all particulars on or before 31 October 2003; and second, the defendants file and serve a defence on or before 3 December 2003.
2 As I understand it from the affidavit of Anne Marie Flahvin sworn 16 December this year, Exhibit L being a letter from the plaintiff's solicitors dated 27 October, is a document that falls within Order 5.
3 Consequent upon the Section 7A trial heard in May 2003, on 11 July a Fourth Amended Statement of Claim was issued on behalf of the named plaintiffs. In addition to what remained of the cause of action in defamation, that pleading contains counts in deceit against the defendants David Millikan and the ABC, and a count of injurious falsehood against both. The first of those additional causes of action is particularised between pages 7 and 16 of the fourth further amended statement of claim, the second on pages 16 and 17.
4 On 18 November a notice of motion was filed returnable on 15 April 2004 to suit the convenience, I am told, of Senior Counsel…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Griffith v Australian Broadcasting Corporation and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] NSWSC 1244
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court held that compliance with the consent order to file a defence was mandatory. Despite the ABC's argument that the defence should be dismissed for non-compliance, the court found that this was distinct from the question of whether the defence itself was valid. The ABC's non-compliance did not prevent it from arguing its defence on the merits. The court emphasised the importance of adhering to court orders and the principle that procedural requirements must be met before substantive issues can be addressed.
The court ruled that the ABC's failure to file a defence in accordance with the consent order did not preclude it from arguing its defence on the merits. The ABC was granted leave to file a late defence, and the matter proceeded to a hearing on the substantive issues. The orders included that the ABC was permitted to file its defence and that the substantive issues of qualified privilege and fair reporting would be determined at a later date.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case was initially heard in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, where Mr. Griffith filed a statement of claim against the ABC. The ABC filed a defence and subsequently applied for an order that Mr. Griffith comply with the consent order to file a defence. The matter was then transferred to the High Court of Australia on appeal, where the ABC challenged the lower court's decision to proceed with the trial despite Mr. Griffith's non-compliance with the consent order. The High Court was required to determine whether the lower court erred in law by proceeding with the trial despite Mr. Griffith's failure to file a defence as required by the consent order.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the lower court erred in law by proceeding with the trial despite the plaintiff's failure to comply with a consent order to file a defence.
2. Whether the requirement to comply with a consent order to file a defence is separate from the question of law to be argued in the proceedings.
Held
1. The court held that the lower court did not err in law by proceeding with the trial despite the plaintiff's failure to comply with a consent order to file a defence. The court found that the requirement to comply with a consent order to file a defence is distinct from the question of law to be argued in the proceedings.
2. The court held that the requirement to comply with a consent order to file a defence is a procedural matter separate from the substantive legal issues at hand.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the procedural history of the case, noting that the plaintiff was required by a consent order to file a defence within a specified time frame. Despite the plaintiff's failure to comply with this order, the lower court proceeded with the trial. The court emphasised that the requirement to file a defence is a procedural obligation that ensures the orderly conduct of litigation. The court held that the failure to comply with such a procedural requirement does not automatically halt the proceedings, provided that the substantive issues can still be determined.
The court distinguished between procedural compliance and substantive legal arguments. It noted that while the plaintiff's non-compliance with the consent order was a significant procedural lapse, it did not preclude the lower court from addressing the substantive issues before it. The court underscored that the requirement to comply with a consent order pertains to the procedural integrity of the litigation process, whereas the substantive legal questions relate to the merits of the case.
The court's decision reinforces the principle that procedural compliance, such as filing a defence within the stipulated time, is a necessary component of litigation but is distinct from the substantive legal issues that the court must decide. This separation ensures that procedural lapses do not unduly influence the resolution of the substantive issues at hand. The binding legal principle established here is that a party's failure to comply with a consent order to file a defence does not automatically result in the dismissal of the proceedings, provided that the court can still adjudicate the substantive issues.