Griffith Narrabundah Community Association v ACT Planning and Land Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

GRIFFITH NARRABUNDAH COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION v ACT PLANNING AND LAND AUTHORITY & ANOR (Administrative Review) [2011] ACAT 61

AT 11/17

Catchwords:             ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – planning and land development – land in the community facilities zone (CFZ) – proposal to build 160 bed residential aged care facility – provisions of CFZ Development Code – whether Rule R6 of CFZ Development Code means that Residential Zones Multi Unit Housing Development Code applies – whether proposed development is a multi unit dwelling – definition of dwelling – proposed removal of trees presently on unleased Territory land – trees will become protected trees on issuing of Crown lease – application of Tree Protection Act2005 – whether advice of Conservator required – whether decision can be inconsistent with advice of Conservator – consideration of matters under section 120 of the Planning and Development Act 2007 – relevant zone objectives – suitability of the land - probable impact including environmental impact of the proposed development – compliance with Rules and Criteria of CFZ Development Code.

Legislation:               Planning and Development Act 2007, ss. 119, 120 & 148

Tree Protection Act 2005, ss. 15, 21, 22, 23, 32, 35 & 39
Tree Protection (Interim Scheme) Act 2001(Repealed)

List of Regulations: Planning and Development Regulation 2008, ss. 5 &26

Tree Protection (Approval Criteria) Determination 2006 (N0 2) Disallowable Instrument D12006 – 60. 
Tree Protection (Tree Management Precinct) Declaration 2009 (No 1)  Notifiable Instrument N12009-213
Tree Protection (Built-Up Urban Areas) Declaration 2010
(No2)  Notifiable Instrument N12010 – 414
Territory Plan 2008

Access and Mobility General Code

Bicycle Parking General Code

Community and Recreation Facilities Location  Guidelines General Code


Community Facility Zone Development Code

Parking and Vehicular Access General Code

           Residential Zones Multi Unit Housing Development   

Code

List of Texts/Papers: Griffith Neighbourhood Plan

Cases:Bozin v Conservator of Flora and Fauna (Administrative Review) [2010] ACAT 91

Lourandos and Yiannokopoulis v ACTPLA (Administrative Review)[2011] ACAT 25

Paxevanos and ACT Planning and Land Authority & Ors [2008] ACTAAT 20

Tribunal:         Mr B. Hatch               Presiding Member

Dr D. McMichael       Senior Member

Date of Orders:   12 September 2011 
Date of Reasons for Decision: 12 September 2011 

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY            )
CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          AT11/17

BETWEEN:            GRIFFITH NARRABUNDAH

COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION INC.

Applicant

AND:              ACT PLANNING AND

LAND AUTHORITY

Respondent

AND:             BAPTIST COMMUNITY

SERVICES – NSW and ACT

Party Joined

TRIBUNAL:            Mr B. Hatch               Presiding Member

Dr D. McMichael       Senior Member

DATE:  12 September 2011

ORDERS

1.The decision under review is varied by imposing the following additional or varied conditions on the approval:

Additional Conditions

A1(c)       revised site plan of car parking provision based on an estimate,  
           certified by Baptist Community Services, of the number of

peak shift employees of the facility when fully operational;

A1(d)        a study of current and likely future external noise affecting the
                 proposed development to be undertaken by a qualified noise

management consultant and revised plans showing

any necessary noise amelioration measures;

Varied conditions

B11TREE PROTECTION

The trees shown…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Griffith Narrabundah Community Association v ACT Planning an... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] ACAT 61
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Griffith Narrabundah Community Association challenged a decision by the ACT Planning and Land Authority to approve a proposed development for a facility for the care of the elderly. The application was for a development that would provide accommodation for 160 residents, comprising 100 dementia-specific units and 60 respite care units. The community association argued that the approval was inconsistent with the objectives of the Canberra Functional Zone and that the land was unsuitable for the proposed development. The ACTPLA defended the decision, asserting that the development was permissible and suitable for the site.

The legal issues before the court involved whether the proposed development was inconsistent with the objectives of the Canberra Functional Zone and whether the land was suitable for the proposed development. The court examined the objectives of the zone, particularly objectives (c) and (e), which concerned the protection of residential areas and the garden suburb character of the area, respectively. The court also considered the meaning of “suitability” in the context of the approval process, and whether the land was suitable for the proposed development. The court considered the evidence presented by both parties and the relevant planning and zoning codes.

The court found that the proposed development did not conflict with the objectives of the Canberra Functional Zone. The court found that there was no evidence that the facility would create unacceptable impacts on the surrounding residential areas, and that the facility would not affect the privacy of nearby residences. The court also found that the proposed development was suitable for the site, despite the applicant’s concerns about the size of the site and the design of the building. The court found that the site was suitable for the development because it was close to open space, the commercial area, and the adjacent residential area, which would integrate the residents into the community. The court found that the CRFLG Code considered access to open space, shops, and other facilities to be desirable for this type of facility.

The court varied the decision under review by imposing additional or varied conditions on the approval. The conditions included a revised site plan of car parking provision based on an estimate of the number of peak shift employees of the facility when fully operational, a study of current and likely future external noise affecting the proposed development to be undertaken by a qualified noise management consultant, and revised plans showing any necessary noise amelioration measures. The court also required the applicant/lessee to prepare and submit a Tree Management Plan covering the protected trees that will remain on the site and to protect and maintain all existing trees and shrubs on adjoining blocks overhanging the subject site, on the verge, and on unleased Territory land immediately adjacent.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision under review is varied by imposing the following additional or varied conditions on the approval:

Additional Conditions

A1(c) revised site plan of car parking provision based on an estimate,

certified by Baptist Community Services, of the number of

peak shift employees of the facility when fully operational;

A1(d) a study of current and likely future external noise affecting the

proposed development to be undertaken by a qualified noise

management consultant and revised plans showing

any necessary noise amelioration measures;

Varied conditions

B11 TREE PROTECTION

The trees shown as “to be removed” on drawing numbered TMP1C Sheet 2 are to be removed and a Tree Management Plan covering the protected trees that will remain on the site is to be prepared and submitted for approval by the Conservator of Flora and Fauna.

C2 TREE PROTECTION

The applicant/lessee shall protect and maintain all existing trees and shrubs on adjoining blocks overhanging the subject site, on the verge, and on unleased Territory land immediately adjacent and shall protect and maintain those protected trees on the subject land (other than those approved for removal) in accordance with the approved Tree Management Plan.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As to objective (e), we were given no evidence that the operation of the facility would create unacceptable impacts on the surrounding residential areas, other than possible impacts from increased traffic, which we will deal with under Code issues. The suggestion that privacy of nearby residences would be affected cannot be substantiated. The proposed development is to be sited more than 30 m from the adjacent residential zone on the north side of Blaxland Crescent while the houses opposite are themselves set back considerable distances from their block boundaries, with substantial street trees and other vegetation separating them from the facility. It will also be sited considerably lower than, and at a substantial distance from, any existing or future residential development on the west side of Stuart Street (even though it will be in part three stories). No privacy issues can arise, as a sketch of the relative levels prepared by Mr Melloh demonstrates (Exhibit 13). As to the impact on the garden suburb character of the area, that is not something which arises from the operation of the proposed facility but will also be addressed below under Code issues. We conclude that, having carefully considered the objectives (c) and (e) of the CFZ, we do not consider that the proposed development will be inconsistent with those objectives.Section 120 item (b) - Suitability of the land for the kind of development proposed Section 120 (b) requires the decision-maker to consider the suitability of the land for a development of the kind proposed. The applicant contended that the land was unsuitable for such a development, primarily because the site was too small for the size of the proposed development and would not be large enough to allow the development of landscaped gardens, and secondarily because it would not be possible to design a building to accommodate 160 residents in sole occupancy units such that each would receive what it described as “the minimum requirement for three hours direct sunlight”. It was also contended that the location was unsuitable because most (if not all) of the residents would not be able to make use of the nearby commercial area or other facilities. We have already addressed the last of these contentions in paragraph 41 above. In the Statement of Findings accompanying the decision, it was simply asserted that Residential Care Accommodation was a permissible use in the CFZ and that the land was therefore suitable, but that is an inadequate approach to this matter. The meaning of “suitability” in this section is not clear. The Tribunal made some suggestions about possible meanings in Lourandos and Yiannokopoulis v ACTPLA [2011] ACAT 25 at [216] but, as Mr Erskine observed, nothing has changed since that decision was published. Mr Hawke did turn his mind to the question in his witness statement (Exhibit 17) observing that the site was considered suitable because it was close to open space and the commercial area (which could be accessed by residents without crossing any roads) as well as to the adjacent residential area which would integrate the residents into the community, rather than them being isolated far from residential areas. He considered that the adjacent open space would provide visual amenity and noted that access to open space, shops and other facilities was considered desirable for this type of facility in the Community and Recreation Facilities Location Guidelines General Code (“the CRFLG Code”).