Gresham and Gresham (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GRESHAM & GRESHAM (NO. 2) [2019] FamCA 707

FAMILY LAW – PROPERTY – final property orders – where the wife seeks to retain the former matrimonial home – division of matrimonial property – assessment of contributions – overseas pension plans and overseas funds - treatment of add backs – superannuation – Capital Gains Tax – section 75(2) and 79 factors – assessment of what is just and equitable.

FAMILY LAW – PARENTING – final parenting orders – best interests of the children.

Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) s 60CC, 75(2), 79
Ferraro & Ferraro [1992] FamCA64
Hickey & Hickey [2003] FamCA 395
Stanford v Stanford [2012] HCA 52
APPLICANT: Ms Gresham
RESPONDENT: Mr Gresham
FILE NUMBER: SYC 7914 of 2016
DATE DELIVERED: 11 October 2019
PLACE DELIVERED: Sydney
PLACE HEARD: Sydney
JUDGMENT OF: Henderson J
HEARING DATE: 1, 2, 3, 4 July 2019

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: Ms Clifford
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: Barkus Doolan
COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: Mr Lethbridge SC
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: Watson & Watson Solicitors

Orders

Parenting Orders

  1. The children Y born … 2009, X born … 2007 and Z born … 2011 live with the mother.

  2. The parties have equal shared parental responsibility for the children.

  3. The children spend time with the father as follows:

    (a)       In Week 1, from after school Thursday until before school Friday, and each alternate week thereafter; and

    (b)       In Week 2, from after school Thursday until before school Monday, and each alternate weekend thereafter.

  4. The children are to spend the first half of the Christmas school holidays in 2019 with the mother and the second half of the Christmas school holidays in 2019 with the father and alternating each year thereafter.

  5. For the parent with whom the children are spending the first period of the Christmas school holidays will return the children to the other parent’s care at 4 pm Christmas Eve, and the parent with whom the children are spending Christmas Eve and Christmas Day will return the children to the other parent at 4 pm Boxing Day.

  6. On special occasions in the event that the children are not already with the relevant parent the children shall spend time with their parents as agreed, and failing agreement:

    (a)       With the father on Father’s Day from 9am to 7:30pm;

    (b)       With the mother on Mother’s Day from 9am to 7:30pm;

    (c)       In each odd-numbered year, with the father from 10am on Christmas Eve until 10am on Christmas Day and with the mother from 10am on Christmas Day until 10am on Boxing Day;

    (d)       In each even-numbered year, with the mother from 10am on Christmas Eve until 10am on Christmas Day and with the father from 10am on Christmas Day until 10am on Boxing Day;

    (e)       The children shall spend time with the father from the conclusion of school until 5pm on each child’s birthday on a school day and from 9am until 1pm on a non-school day; and

    (f)       The children shall…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gresham and Gresham (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FamCA 707
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Henderson J made final parenting and property orders in the matter of *Gresham and Gresham (No 2)*. The dispute concerned the division of matrimonial property and the best interests of the three children of the marriage.

The court was required to determine the appropriate parenting arrangements for the children, including living arrangements, parental responsibility, and time spent with each parent. In relation to property, the court had to assess the division of various assets, including overseas pension plans, overseas funds, superannuation, and the former matrimonial home, taking into account factors such as contributions, capital gains tax, and the section 75(2) and 79 factors of the *Family Law Act 1975* (Cth) to achieve a just and equitable outcome.

The parenting orders established that the children would live with the mother and that the parties would have equal shared parental responsibility. Specific time arrangements were detailed for the father, including weekday and weekend time, as well as provisions for holidays and special occasions. The court also made orders regarding communication, notification of appointments, and overseas travel for the children. For property, the court ordered an equal division of certain funds and provided options for the disposition of the former matrimonial home and English properties. The wife was given a period to decide whether to retain the former matrimonial home, with specific financial adjustments to be made to the husband in either scenario. The court also addressed the division of overseas pensions and the husband's responsibility for mortgage payments and private health insurance for the children.

Orders

Orders of the court

Parenting Orders

1.

The children Y born … 2009, X born … 2007 and Z born … 2011 live with the mother.

2.

The parties have equal shared parental responsibility for the children.

3.

The children spend time with the father as follows:

(a) In Week 1, from after school Thursday until before school Friday, and each alternate week thereafter; and

(b) In Week 2, from after school Thursday until before school Monday, and each alternate weekend thereafter.

4.

The children are to spend the first half of the Christmas school holidays in 2019 with the mother and the second half of the Christmas school holidays in 2019 with the father and alternating each year thereafter.

5.

For the parent with whom the children are spending the first period of the Christmas school holidays will return the children to the other parent’s care at 4 pm Christmas Eve, and the parent with whom the children are spending Christmas Eve and Christmas Day will return the children to the other parent at 4 pm Boxing Day.

6.

On special occasions in the event that the children are not already with the relevant parent the children shall spend time with their parents as agreed, and failing agreement:

(a) With the father on Father’s Day from 9am to 7:30pm;

(b) With the mother on Mother’s Day from 9am to 7:30pm;

(c) In each odd-numbered year, with the father from 10am on Christmas Eve until 10am on Christmas Day and with the mother from 10am on Christmas Day until 10am on Boxing Day;

(d) In each even-numbered year, with the mother from 10am on Christmas Eve until 10am on Christmas Day and with the father from 10am on Christmas Day until 10am on Boxing Day;

(e) The children shall spend time with the father from the conclusion of school until 5pm on each child’s birthday on a school day and from 9am until 1pm on a non-school day; and

(f) The children shall spend time with the father from the conclusion of school until 5pm on each child’s birthday on a school day and from 9am until 1pm on a non-school day.

7.

For the purposes of implementing changeover, changeover is to take place at the mother’s home at the commencement of time with the father and the mother shall collect the children from the father’s home at the conclusion of time with the father.

8.

The father shall have contact with the children during the time that they are with the mother via telephone, skype, facetime or video conference on a minimum of two occasions per week with the times to be agreed between the parties, but in the absence of agreement the mother shall facilitate such time between 5pm and 7pm.

9.

Each parent shall have such authority as is necessary to obtain information as would normally be available to a parent from any professional body or organisation that holds information about the children including, but not limited to doctors, hospitals, schools and sporting associations.

10.

Each parent shall forthwith notify the other at the earliest opportunity if any of the children are required to attend upon a doctor or a hospital for any reason, or are absent from school due to illness.

11.

Each parent shall forthwith notify the other of any medical, therapist, school or any other appointment concerning the children at the earliest opportunity but not less than 24 hours prior to that appointment.

12.

Each parent shall forthwith notify the other of any major health issue concerning the children which come to the attention of that parent whilst they are in his or her care.

13.

Each parent shall keep the other informed of his or her current landline and mobile telephone number.

14.

The mother and father be at liberty to take the children outside of the Commonwealth of Australia for travel to and through any country that is a member of The Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction only, unless travel to a non-member country is agreed to by the other parent in writing not less than 28 days prior to the proposed date of departure, conditional on the parents’ compliance with all the following:

(a) Such time occur during that parent’s time with the children in a school holiday period unless otherwise agreed to between the parties in writing;

(b) That they give the other party at least 6 weeks’ written notice of the intended travel dates;

(c) They give the other parent not less than 28 days’ notice prior to the date of departure, a detailed itinerary including the contact details for the children whilst overseas;

(d) Not less than 7 days prior provide a detailed itinerary of such overseas travel including copies of all airline tickets (or electronic ticket details if available) and accommodation address and contact details; and

(e) They ensure that the children contact the other parent whilst travelling on not less than 2 occasions in each week.

15.

Each parent is permitted to take the children on an overseas holiday to a Hague Convention country only, unless otherwise agreed.

Property orders

16.

That the parties forthwith divide equally funds in the UK investment bond and ANZ joint bank account.

17.

That the wife forthwith sign all documents and execute all consents necessary to transfer her interest in the property known as G Street to the husband with any costs associated therewith to be equally borne.

18.

The husband to notify the wife within 42 days of these Orders whether he proposes to sell English properties, being one or either of them.

19.

In the event the husband chooses not to sell one either or one of the English properties he is to pay the wife in cash from the payment to him of his interest in the former matrimonial home 50 per cent of the net value of the English property retained by him.

20.

In the event the husband chooses to sell the English properties he is to pay the wife one half of the net proceeds of sale after payment of Capital Gains Tax and costs of sale.

21.

The wife to notify the husband within six weeks of the date of these Orders whether she intends to retain the former matrimonial home or place the property on the market for sale.

22.

In the event the wife chooses to retain the former matrimonial home the wife to pay to the husband $1,988,563 within 90 days of the date of these Orders less:

(a) The sum of $266,110, being one half of the net value of the VPLC pension in the husband’s name;

(b) The sum of $50,000 to be paid into the husband’s solicitor’s trust account to effect division of the Country Q pensions and any net proceeds remaining after this order has been brought into effect are to be paid to the husband;

(c) The husband to transfer his interest in the property to the wife upon her compliance with Order 22 herein.

23.

Thereafter, the wife is to indemnify the husband in respect of all monies owing to her parents.

24.

The wife to forthwith sign all documents and give all consents necessary to affect an equal division of the Country Q pensions in the husband’s name being BB pension and CC pension forthwith.

25.

The husband to do all acts and things necessary to affect an equal division of the Country Q pensions referred to in Order 22(b) and if required by the wife for entitlement in respect of both pensions to be placed into one pension fund at the with the wife to pay any costs associated with such a requirement.

26.

In the event the wife elects to sell the former matrimonial home both parties are to do all acts and things to place the property on the market for sale with an agent of their choosing at a price as agreed between them or by way of auction and as agreed and to equally share the costs of having the pool fence made compliant for the purposes of sale.

27.

The proceeds of sale are to be disbursed as follows:

(a) Discharge of the current mortgage;

(b) Agent’s commission, solicitor’s costs and usual conveyancing adjustments;

(c) To the husband, 40 per cent of the net proceeds of sale, less the following amounts:

(i) $100,000 to the wife’s parents;

(ii) $266,110 to the wife;

(iii) The sum of $50,000 to be paid into the husband’s solicitor’s trust account to affect a division of the Country Q pensions. Any net proceeds remaining after a division of the Country Q pensions has been brought into effect are to be paid to the husband.

28.

The balance of the net proceeds of sale are to be paid to the wife with the wife to pay her parents $550,000 being the balance of monies owed to her parents.

29.

Thereafter, all assets including, but not limited to, superannuation and monies in bank accounts or other financial institutions are assets of the parties absolutely.

30.

Pending transfer of the home to the wife or upon settlement of the sale of the former matrimonial home the husband to be responsible for payments of the mortgage and other outgoings in respect of the property. The wife will join in with the husband if necessary to minimise payments of the mortgage and his obligation to pay the mortgage is limited to interest only.

31.

The Court notes the husband will continue to pay for private health insurance for the three children of the marriage.

32.

I discharge all prior orders in respect of the children including and in particular the husband’s obligation to pay private school fees for the children.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry of the order in the Court’s records.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established