| [2022] FWC 2393 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
| DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal
Greg Searle
v
Luxwood Homes Pty Ltd
(U2022/1035)
| DEPUTY PRESIDENT LAKE | BRISBANE, 23 SEPTEMBER 2022 |
Application for costs
Introduction
On 5 April 2022, I heard Mr Searle’s application for unfair dismissal against Luxwood Homes Pty Ltd (Luxwood Homes). On 30 June 2022, I decided that Mr Searle was not unfairly dismissed by Luxwood Homes and the application had been made outside of the statutory timeframe. lodged.[1]
On 14 July 2022, Luxwood Homes filed an application for costs to be ordered (Costs Application) against Mr Searle.
Both parties consented to my determination of the Costs Application on the papers.
In determining the Costs Application, I have had regard to Luxwood Homes submissions dated 14 July 2022 and Mr Searle’s submissions dated 15 August 2022.
Basis for Costs Application
Luxwood Homes seeks payment of its legal costs pursuant to sections 400A and 611 of the Fair Work Act2009 (Cth) (Act). Submissions were sought from both parties regarding the Costs Application.
Luxwood Homes’ primary contentions in support of its Costs Application are as follows:
· Luxwood Homes submitted that Mr Searle’s application did not have reasonable cause as the application was doomed to fail because it was effectively a claim for underpayment of wages and/or breaches of contract, which the Commission lacked the jurisdiction to have referring to Hardy v Aus North Refrigeration & Air Conditioning [2020] FWC 5549 at [143].
· Mr Searle knew or ought to have known that there was no employment relationship and therefore did not have reasonable cause to pursue the matter.
· Mr Searle failed to consider a reasonable offer of settlement made on 16 March 2022 to resolve all matters on dispute. Luxwood Homes stated that there was not a possibility of further settlement discussions because of Mr Searle’s consistent unauthorised access of their information systems. Luxwood Homes cite Ferry v GHS Regional WA Pty Ltd [2016] FWC 3120 at [75].
· Luxwood Homes submitted that indemnity costs should be awarded for its costs incurred in connection with Mr Searle’s application for $18,994.93. At minimum, Luxwood Homes should be awarded a minimum of $7040.13 for its costs incurred for steps taken after 16 March 2022 when the settlement discussions broke down because of Mr Searle’s unreasonable refusal of a settlement offer and delinquent conduct.
Mr Searle has provided a response to the submissions of Luxwood Homes. His primary contentions in opposition to the application for costs are as follows:
· Mr Searle submitted that he acted with reasonable cause as he genuinely believed that he had a good chance of success that he was unfairly dismissed. He acknowledged that he incorrectly assumed that he lodged the Application out of time until the decision was handed down regarding the jurisdictional objection.
· Mr Searle acknowledged that it was not unreasonable to continue with his case because of a lack of skill, knowledge, experience, and appropriate training to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Greg Searle v Luxwood Homes Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] FWC 2393
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether Searle's application for unfair dismissal was made vexatiously or without reasonable cause, and whether Luxwood Homes incurred costs due to Searle's unreasonable act or omission. Luxwood Homes argued that Searle's application was without reasonable cause as it was essentially a claim for underpayment of wages and/or breaches of contract, which the Commission lacked jurisdiction to hear. Additionally, they argued that Searle had unauthorised access to their business computer system post-engagement as a contractor, and that he rejected a reasonable offer of settlement on 16 March 2022. In opposition, Searle argued that he acted with reasonable cause and that he sought legal advice regarding the offer to settle, making amendments to achieve a fair settlement.
The court found that Searle's application was not without reasonable cause, as the potential remedy available to him was not clearly understood and he had presented some arguments that could have led to a conclusion that was arguable that he may have been an employee. The court also found that it was not satisfied that Searle caused Luxwood Homes to incur the costs in question because of an unreasonable act or omission on his part in connection with the conduct or continuation of the matter. As such, the court decided not to exercise its discretion to award costs in favour of Luxwood Homes against Searle.
In conclusion, the court dismissed Luxwood Homes' Costs Application pursuant to s 400A and/or s 611 of the Act, finding that the application was not made vexatiously or without reasonable cause, and that Searle did not incur the costs in question because of an unreasonable act or omission on his part in connection with the conduct or continuation of the matter.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.