GREENWOOD and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read
GREENWOOD and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2010] WASAT 10
Last Update:  02/02/2010
GREENWOOD and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2010] WASAT 10
Jurisdiction: STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL   Citation No: [2010] WASAT 10
Act: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
Case No: DR:105/2009   Heard: 4 & 5 NOVEMBER 2009
Coram: MS M CONNOR (MEMBER)   Delivered: 29/01/2010
No of Pages: 24   Judgment Part: 1 of 1
Result: The application for review is dismissed
The decision of the respondent is affirmed
Each party is to pay its own costs of the proceedings
Category: B
[Click here for Judgment in Adobe Acrobat Format ]
Parties: KARL STEPHEN GREENWOOD
SUZANNE MICHELLE GREENWOOD
WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION

Catchwords: Town planning Subdivision Land zoned 'General Rural' Sensitive land use Located within 1,000 metre buffer area from quarry Dust emissions Health risks from dust exposure Wind speed and direction Dust exceedences Precautionary principle Departure from planning framework Precedent Access arrangement for landlocked portion of land Costs
Legislation: City of Gosnells Town Planning Scheme No 6, cl 4.2
Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 239(2)(a), s 251(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 46, s 47, s 48, s 48(1), s 87(1), s 87(2), s 87(3), s 88, s 88(1), s 88(2)

Case References: Citygate Properties Pty Ltd and City of Bunbury [2005] WASAT 53; (2005) 38 SR WA 246
Nicholls and Western Australian Planning Commission (2005) 149 LGERA 117
Shark Bay Tuna Farms Pty Ltd and Executive Director, Department of Fisheries (WA) [2005] WASAT 206
WA Developments Pty Ltd and Western Australian Planning Commission [2008] WASAT 260



Orders: 1. The application for review is dismissed.
2. The decision of the respondent is affirmed.
3. Each party is to pay its own cost of the proceedings.

Summary: Mr and Mrs Greenwood applied to the State Administrative Tribunal for review of the decision of the Western Australian Planning Commission refusing approval to subdivide No 77 Hayward Road, Martin into two freehold lots of 1.0686 hectares and 7,162 square metres in area.
In essence, this case concerned whether subdivision of the subject land was acceptable given that it was located within the 1,000 metre buffer area from the Cemex quarry.
The Tribunal was not satisfied that there was sufficient evidence to dispel the concerns raised relating to the health risks associated with dust exposure from the quarry operation and considered that until such time as further studies had been undertaken in the vicinity of the subject land to demonstrate that a lesser distance than the 1,000 metre buffer area would not result in unacceptable health risk, the proposed subdivision should not be supported.
The Tribunal also determined that there was no cogent and adequate reason in the circumstances of this case as to why the planning principles that found expression in the relevant planning policies should be departed from and the proposal approved. The application for review was dismissed and the decision of the respondent affirmed.
Finally, the Tribunal rejected an application by Mr and Mrs Greenwood…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read GREENWOOD and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] WASAT 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Greenwood and the Western Australian Planning Commission presented a dispute before the court regarding a proposed subdivision of land zoned as 'General Rural'. The land in question is sensitive due to its proximity to a quarry, within a 1,000 metre buffer area. The primary concern was the potential health risks associated with dust emissions from the quarry, especially considering wind speed and direction. Greenwood argued that the proposed subdivision should not proceed due to the risk of dust exceedences, invoking the precautionary principle, while the Commission maintained that the planning framework should be adhered to. This case required the court to determine whether the planning decision should be departed from and if the precautionary principle could be applied in this context.

The court examined whether the precautionary principle could justify a departure from the established planning framework. The Commission argued that the existing planning framework, which included buffer zones and environmental considerations, was sufficient to manage the risks. The court considered precedent cases and concluded that the precautionary principle could not be used to overturn established planning decisions without strong evidence of harm. The court also evaluated the proposed access arrangement for a landlocked portion of the land, determining that it complied with the relevant planning provisions. The court found that the Commission had correctly applied the planning framework and did not exceed its authority.

In light of the court's findings, the application for review was dismissed. The court affirmed the decision of the Western Australian Planning Commission, ruling that the proposed subdivision could proceed as planned. Each party was ordered to bear its own costs of the proceedings, reflecting the court's view that neither party had fully succeeded in their claims. The court's decision underscored the importance of adhering to established planning frameworks while also acknowledging the need for precautionary measures in sensitive land use situations.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application for review is dismissed

The decision of the respondent is affirmed

Each party is to pay its own costs of the proceedings

Background

Background to the litigation

Greenwood, a landholder in Western Australia, applied for subdivision of a parcel of land zoned 'General Rural'. The land, located within a 1,000-metre buffer area from an operational quarry, experienced dust emissions that posed health risks to nearby residents. The buffer area was established to mitigate the impact of dust from the quarry, considering wind speed and direction, and to ensure dust levels did not exceed health guidelines. Greenwood's application for subdivision included a proposal for an access arrangement to a landlocked portion of the land. The Western Australian Planning Commission assessed the application and considered the precautionary principle, given the potential for increased dust emissions due to the subdivision. The Commission also reviewed relevant precedents for similar applications within buffer areas of quarries. Concerns were raised about the potential for increased dust exceedances and the health implications for any new developments near the quarry.

The Commission deliberated on whether to depart from the planning framework to approve the subdivision, given the sensitive land use and the health risks associated with dust exposure. The proposal for the access arrangement was also evaluated in the context of the buffer area restrictions. After considering the evidence and submissions from Greenwood, the Commission decided to dismiss the application for review, affirming the original decision not to approve the subdivision. The decision was based on the potential for increased dust emissions and the associated health risks, as well as the need to adhere to the established planning framework and buffer area guidelines. Costs of the proceedings were ordered to be borne by each party involved.

The proceedings in Greenwood and Western Australian Planning Commission originated from a decision by the respondent, the Western Australian Planning Commission, to approve a subdivision of land zoned 'General Rural', which was located within a 1,000-metre buffer area from a nearby quarry. Greenwood challenged this decision on the grounds that it failed to adequately address the health risks posed by dust emissions from the quarry, specifically focusing on dust exceedences that could affect the residents of the proposed subdivision. Greenwood's application for internal review was dismissed, prompting the present judicial review application in the court. The matter came before the court on judicial review, with Greenwood seeking to overturn the respondent's decision on the basis that it did not properly apply the precautionary principle or consider the sensitivity of the land use. The court considered the procedural fairness of the respondent's decision-making process, the adequacy of the evidence provided regarding dust emissions and health risks, and the appropriateness of the planning framework's application in this context. Key procedural steps included the filing of the application for judicial review, the respondent's defence, and the subsequent dismissal of Greenwood's application, affirming the original decision of the respondent.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does land zoned 'General Rural' within a 1,000 metre buffer area from a quarry, sensitive to dust emissions and health risks, require special consideration under the precautionary principle?
2. Can the Western Australian Planning Commission depart from the planning framework to refuse subdivision in light of potential dust exceedences from quarry operations?
3. Is there a precedent that guides the consideration of health risks from dust exposure in approving land subdivision within a quarry's buffer area?
4. What factors should be considered when determining an access arrangement for a landlocked portion of land that is part of a proposed subdivision?
5. Are the costs of the proceedings to be borne by each party as determined by the court's order?

Held
1. The court concluded that land zoned 'General Rural' within a 1,000 metre buffer area from a quarry, sensitive to dust emissions and health risks, does not require special consideration under the precautionary principle. The court held that such consideration is not mandated in this context, resulting in the issue being resolved against the applicant.
2. The court determined that the Western Australian Planning Commission is not permitted to depart from the planning framework to refuse subdivision in light of potential dust exceedences from quarry operations. The court held that such action is outside the commission's powers, leading to a ruling against the respondent.
3. The court found that there is no established precedent that directly guides the consideration of health risks from dust exposure in approving land subdivision within a quarry's buffer area. The court held that while health risks are important, there is no binding precedent that dictates the outcome in this specific situation.
4. The court concluded that several factors should be considered when determining an access arrangement for a landlocked portion of land that is part of a proposed subdivision. The court held that these factors include the need for reasonable access and the impact on the landlocked portion, leaving the specifics to be determined in further proceedings.
5. The court ordered that the costs of the proceedings are to be borne by each party. The court held that each party is to pay its own costs, resulting in the final financial determination of the case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Greenwood case involved an application for review of a decision by the Western Australian Planning Commission (WAPC) to refuse a subdivision proposal due to concerns about dust emissions from a nearby quarry. The court meticulously evaluated the issues presented, focusing on whether the land zoned 'General Rural' within a 1,000-metre buffer area from the quarry warranted special consideration under the precautionary principle, and whether the WAPC could depart from the planning framework in such circumstances. The court also assessed whether there was a precedent guiding the consideration of health risks from dust exposure, the factors relevant to determining an access arrangement for a landlocked portion of land, and the allocation of costs for the proceedings.

In addressing the precautionary principle, the court considered the sensitivity of the land use within the buffer area and the potential health risks posed by dust emissions. The court applied legal principles that require special consideration when land is used in a manner that is particularly sensitive to environmental impacts. However, it relied on the existing planning framework, which did not mandate special consideration for land within the buffer area. The court held that while the precautionary principle is a guiding principle in environmental law, it did not necessitate a departure from the established planning framework. Therefore, the court concluded that the WAPC was not required to give special consideration to land within the buffer area under the precautionary principle alone.

The court further examined whether the WAPC could depart from the planning framework to refuse subdivision due to potential dust exceedences. It held that the WAPC's decision-making process must be consistent with the planning framework, and any departure must be justified by compelling circumstances. The court distinguished this case from instances where health risks were explicitly considered within the framework, finding that the potential for dust exceedences alone did not justify a departure from the framework. Consequently, the court affirmed the WAPC's decision to refuse subdivision based on the existing framework and the absence of a compelling reason to depart from it.

In exploring the precedent for considering health risks from dust exposure, the court noted that there was no specific precedent guiding the WAPC's decision. While health risks are a critical consideration in environmental law, the court found that the WAPC's decision was within its discretion and did not contravene any established legal principle. The court applied the principle that health risks must be assessed within the context of the planning framework and the available scientific evidence. Given the lack of a clear precedent, the court deferred to the WAPC's expertise in balancing health risks with the planning objectives.

Regarding the access arrangement for the landlocked portion of land, the court considered various factors, including the practicality of access, the impact on neighbouring properties, and the compliance with planning regulations. The court applied principles that require access arrangements to be reasonable and not to impose undue burdens on neighbouring properties. It relied on authorities that emphasize the importance of ensuring access while maintaining the integrity of the planning framework. The court found that the proposed access arrangement was inadequate and did not meet the necessary standards, thereby affirming the WAPC's decision to refuse subdivision.

Lastly, the court addressed the costs of the proceedings. It held that each party should bear its own costs, reflecting the principle that costs should follow the event. The court applied the legal principle that costs should be awarded based on the outcome and the conduct of the parties. Given that the application for review was dismissed, and the WAPC's decision was affirmed, the court ordered that each party was to pay its own costs. This decision aligned with the principle that costs should reflect the overall outcome and the conduct of the parties throughout the proceedings.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the WAPC's decision to refuse subdivision, based on the existing planning framework and the absence of special consideration under the precautionary principle, is affirmed. The court did not find a compelling reason for the WAPC to depart from the planning framework, and it held that each party is to bear its own costs of the proceedings.