Greenhill Homes Pty Ltd v Domestic Building Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

CAUSES JURISDICTION

Not Restricted

No. 4420 of 1998

GREENHILL HOMES PTY LTD and OTHERS Plaintiffs
(ACN 006 540 521)
v
DOMESTIC BUILDING TRIBUNAL and OTHERS Defendants

---

JUDGE: Byrne, J.
WHERE HELD  Melbourne
DATE OF HEARING: 31 July 1998
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 14 August 1998
MEDIA NEUTRAL CITATION  [1998] VSC 34

---

Building contracts - Domestic Building Tribunal - whether claim against builder for deceptive and misleading conduct contrary to the Fair Trading Act s.11 justiciable in the Tribunal - whether claim against directors of the builder for aiding and abetting its deceptive and misleading conduct pursuant Fair Trading Act s.31 is justiciable in the Tribunal - whether directors might be joined as parties to the proceeding in the Tribunal - whether director is “another person”.

Domestic Building Contracts and Tribunal Act 1995 ss.53(1), 53(2)(b)(ii), 54(1)(a), 55, 56.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiffs  Mr V. Ruta Maddock Lonie & Chisholm
First Defendant  No Appearance
Second and Third Defendants  Mr A. Laird Wainwright Ryan

HIS HONOUR:

  1. By agreement entered into on or about 11 July 1996 the second and thirdnamed respondents, Pat Volpe and Tina Volpe, as proprietors entered into a building agreement with the firstnamed plaintiff, Greenhill Homes Pty Ltd. Under this agreement Greenhill Homes agreed to construct a single storey brick veneer dwelling with cellar and attached garage at Lot 35 Collins Lane, Yarrambat (particulars of demand 1, 5). The contract price was $450,000 so that the contract was a major domestic building contract within the definition of that term in s.3 of the Domestic Building Contracts and Tribunal Act 1995 (“the Act”). The second and thirdnamed plaintiffs, Aldo Zumpano and Rosemary Zumpano, were at all material times directors of Greenhill Homes.

  2. The work was put in hand and proceeded, at least to base stage, until late August 1996 when the Proprietors requested Greenhill Homes to suspend or cease performance because of their concerns about the standard of the work. These concerns arose from aspects of the setting out of the building, the earthworks and the size and location of floor joists. On 21 April 1997 Greenhill Homes gave notice terminating the agreement for common law repudiation (particulars of demand 10). The Proprietors in turn treated this as repudiation which they accepted on 9 May 1997 (particulars of demand 12). And, so, the building contract came to an end. So much appears from the contentions of the Proprietors in their particulars of demand.

  3. On 21 May 1997 Greenhill Homes lodged with the firstnamed defendant, the Domestic Building Tribunal (“the Tribunal”), an application pursuant to s.55 of the Act, No.D344/97, seeking a declaration that the contract was terminated by the repudiation of the Proprietors and payment of $82,000 as the value of work completed prior to that date.

  4. On 2 June 1997 the Proprietors in turn filed in the Tribunal a cross-application No.D367/97 against Greenhill Homes and the Directors. The particulars of claim attached to this application run to some 17 pages. The amount…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Greenhill Homes Pty Ltd v Domestic Building Tribunal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] VSC 34
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Greenhill Homes Pty Ltd, the builder, was sued by the Domestic Building Tribunal for deceptive and misleading conduct under the Fair Trading Act. The dispute arose from the builder's dealings with the plaintiffs, who were homeowners. The Domestic Building Tribunal, established under the Domestic Building Contracts and Tribunal Act 1995, was tasked with determining the justiciability of claims against the builder and its directors. The Tribunal had to decide if it had the authority to hear the claim against the builder for deceptive and misleading conduct, as well as the claim against the directors for aiding and abetting the builder's conduct. Additionally, the Tribunal needed to determine whether the directors could be joined as parties to the proceeding and if a director could be considered "another person" under the Fair Trading Act.

The court examined the jurisdictional provisions of the Domestic Building Contracts and Tribunal Act 1995 to address these issues. It found that the claim against the builder for deceptive and misleading conduct was justiciable, as it related directly to the domestic building contract. However, the claim against the directors for aiding and abetting the builder's conduct was not justiciable because it did not fall within the scope of the Tribunal's jurisdiction as defined by the Act. Furthermore, the court concluded that directors could not be joined as parties to the proceeding under the Act, as the Act did not provide for such a mechanism. Lastly, the court interpreted "another person" under the Fair Trading Act to exclude directors from its scope, limiting their liability to the Tribunal.

The Domestic Building Tribunal's decision was upheld in part and overturned in part. The claim against the builder was deemed justiciable, allowing the Tribunal to proceed with that aspect of the case. Conversely, the claim against the directors was found to be outside the Tribunal's jurisdiction. The directors could not be joined as parties to the proceeding, and they were not considered "another person" under the Fair Trading Act. These findings clarified the Tribunal's jurisdiction and the limitations on claims that could be brought before it.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established