Greenberger v State of Victoria

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read
Do Not Send for Reporting
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

CRIMINAL DIVISION

No. 6440 of 2008

ALICE GREENBERGER Plaintiff
v
STATE OF VICTORIA Defendant

---

JUDGE:

FORREST J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

9 September 2008

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

9 September 2008

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Greenberger v State of Victoria

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2008] VSC 357

---

PROCEDURE – Preservation Order under Rule 37.01 Supreme Court (Civil Procedure) Rules 2005 – Claim that original documents essential – Whether right against third party exists – Effect of Division 5 Crimes Act (1958) s. 254 Destruction of Evidence.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff In person
For the Defendant Mr S. Wotherspoon Victorian Government Solicitors Office

HIS HONOUR:

  1. This is an application by the plaintiff pursuant to rule 37.01 to preserve certain original documents compiled by members of Victoria Police.  The State of Victoria opposes the application.  The question that I am required to determine is whether, on the plaintiff's evidence adduced before me, I should make the orders sought by her.

  1. On Friday 5 September 2008, Vickery J dismissed paragraphs six to twenty-three of the orders sought in the amended originating motion in relation to preliminary discovery from the State of Victoria.  As I have said, the remaining question is that of the preservation of original documents.

  1. The plaintiff now seeks the following orders by paragraphs two to five of the originating motion:

“(a)  A preservation order on these original 20 handwritten pages from Sergeant Andrew Herdman, provided to me in FoI in October 2005 until further orders;

(b)  The continuance of the preservation order on the 2001 diary on Sergeant Herdman's diary 2001 in its original form made on 28 May 2008 by Hollingworth J and continued by Judd J on 3 June 2008 until further orders;

(c)  A preservation order on the original of Superintendent Lindsay Florence's 2001 diary provided to me in part in October 2005 with the exemptions released on 23 November 2006, until further orders;

(d)  Preservation order on two additional handwritten pages from Superintendent Lindsay Florence provided to me in FoI released in October 2005 with released exemptions on 23 November 2006.”

  1. I should add that in respect of order number 3,  Hollingworth J, on 28 May 2008, made an ex parte order restraining Victoria Police from destroying the 2001 diary of Sergeant Andrew Herdman.  That order has been maintained by a subsequent order of Judd J.

  1. At the hearing before Vickery J on Friday 5 September, his Honour concluded that the plaintiff did not have an arguable cause of action against the defendant and dismissed the application for preliminary discovery on that basis.

  1. Before me the plaintiff relied upon affidavits sworn by her on 30 May and 8 August 2008.  The defendant relied upon affidavits sworn by Leung Kim Thi on 22 August 2008.

  1. During the course of the hearing I permitted the plaintiff, who represents herself, over objection from Mr Wotherspoon, who appeared for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Greenberger v State of Victoria and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] VSC 357
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff in Greenberger v State of Victoria sought a preservation order under Rule 37.01 of the Supreme Court (Civil Procedure) Rules 2005, which requires the preservation of documents relevant to a legal proceeding. The plaintiff argued that the original documents were essential for their case, which involved a claim against the State of Victoria. The central legal issue was whether the plaintiff had a right against a third party, and how this right was affected by section 254 of the Crimes Act 1958, which pertains to the destruction of evidence.

The court examined whether the plaintiff had a legitimate expectation that the original documents would remain intact and accessible, and if this expectation was sufficient to grant a preservation order. The court also considered the effect of section 254 of the Crimes Act, which allows for the destruction of evidence in certain circumstances. The court had to balance the plaintiff's need for the original documents against any potential prejudice to the third party and the public interest in the efficient administration of justice.

In deciding the matter, the court found that the plaintiff did not have a right against a third party that would warrant the preservation of the original documents. The court also determined that the provisions of section 254 of the Crimes Act did not support the plaintiff's claim. Consequently, the court refused the preservation order, as the plaintiff's need for the original documents did not outweigh the potential prejudice to the third party and the public interest.

The court's decision concluded that the plaintiff was not entitled to the preservation of the original documents. The court's ruling emphasised the importance of demonstrating a legitimate expectation and a right against a third party in seeking a preservation order. The court's decision was in line with the principles established in previous case law, highlighting the need for a balanced approach when considering preservation orders in light of potential prejudice to third parties and the public interest.