Background
Background to the litigation
The appellant appeals against the dismissal by the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission (QIRC)[1] of his application for orders to stop bullying in the workplace.[2][1]Industrial Commissioner Power.[2]Greenall v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services) [2021] QIRC 264.Background The appellant, Mr Greenall, was employed by the State of Queensland in the Department of Queensland Corrective Services. He is a skilled worker holding a substantive position as a dog handler. The second respondent, Mr Swann, is also a State Government employee working in Queensland Corrective Services. He is the Manager, Statewide Dog Squad Development and Standards. Mr Greenall alleged that over a period of time Mr Swann bullied him. The bullying was particularised by Mr Greenall in his application to the QIRC as 17 separate incidents. After hearing all the witnesses, the Industrial Commissioner found that there were three instances where Mr Swann had “behave[d] unreasonably towards” Mr Greenall.[3] The Industrial Commissioner was not satisfied that any of the other 14 alleged incidents constituted unreasonable behaviour towards Mr Greenall.[3]Industrial Relations Act 2016, s 272(1)(a). The first incident of unreasonable behaviour which the Industrial Commissioner found proved occurred in September 2018.[4] The findings of the Industrial Commissioner were these:[4]I have approached them chronologically.“Mr Swann’s conduct regarding an altercation between Mr Scott and Mr Hurikino[121]The Applicant states that a further example of bullying behaviour was Mr Swann’s note in the Chronology document, that on 18 September 2018, the Applicant was involved in an altercation with two other personnel, being Mr Scott and Mr Hurikino.[122]The Applicant submits that at first glance this would appear to be a serious performance issue, however, the facts are that the Applicant reported the altercation between Mr Scott and Mr Hurikino to Mr Swann.[123]The Applicant states in his affidavit that Mr Swann asked him to provide a written report on the altercation. The Applicant states that Mr Swann later abused him because he claimed the Applicant did not stand up for Mr Scott.[124]Mr Swann acknowledged in his affidavit that the Applicant had reported the altercation to him and Mr Swann subsequently asked all those involved to each provide a report. Mr Swann gave evidence that Mr Hurikino did not submit a report as requested.[125]In the Applicant’s report, he stated he had not wanted to get involved. Mr Swann states in his affidavit that he later told the Applicant that he had expected that he would step in to stop the altercation but denies raising his voice.[126]The Respondents submit that it was not unreasonable to expect that another staff member would step in to try to bring the altercation to a close or to voice that expectation.[127]I accept that it was reasonable management action for Mr Swann to request a report from the Applicant given that the Applicant had witnessed the altercation between Mr Scott and Mr Hurikino.[128]Mr Swann’s admission that he told the Applicant, as I understand it, that he had expected that the Applicant would step in to stop the altercation was unusual. The two personnel involved in the altercation were not the Applicant’s subordinates and were not answerable to him. The Applicant acted appropriately by informing Mr Swann of the incident and providing the subsequent report. Mr Swann’s expectation that the Applicant insert himself into the disagreement in order to end the altercation was not reasonable. This was particularly so given that Mr Swann did not witness the incident and so did not have a firsthand understanding of what had occurred. Mr Swann’s expectation that the Applicant step in to end such an altercation was not reasonable management action taken in a reasonable manner.” (emphasis added)
Decision
Reasons for decision
The second incident which the Industrial Commissioner found proved occurred in February 2019. The findings in relation to that incident were as follows:“Mr Swann’s conduct toward the Applicant during the debrief of the dog bite by CSD Ox on Mr Fox[88]The Applicant submits that Mr Swann returned to the Dog Training Unit at the Academy after taking Mr Fox to hospital and conducted a debrief on the incident, during which he stood over the Applicant, who was seated, pointed his finger toward his chest and berated him over the incident, as if it were the Applicant’s fault. The Applicant submits that this is corroborated by several other witnesses, including some who made a complaint about Mr Swann’s conduct to Mr Butler. The Applicant states that he made a formal complaint to Mr Butler about the alleged conduct of Mr Swann during the debrief.[89]In Mr Swann’s affidavit, his evidence is that the Applicant was ‘panicked and in a heightened state’ after Mr Fox was bitten. In cross-examination, Mr Swann maintained that the Applicant was emotional after the bite took place.[90]Mr Swann’s affidavit describes the course participants as gathering in the dog squad room to debrief before he addressed everyone and reminded them that in such situations as the one just experienced with the dog bite, they should remain mechanical and not emotional. Mr Swann noted that the Applicant was in a heightened state, however, denies the address was targeted at the Applicant and denies standing over him or making him the focus of the debrief. [91]In cross-examination, the Applicant stated that he did not panic but rather was motivated by a duty of care towards Mr Fox.[92]Mr Hageman gave evidence that he witnessed the Applicant getting a ‘dressing down’ by Mr Swann during the debrief, and in his statement to the Applicant stated that Mr Swann spoke down to the Applicant in an elevated voice in an unprofessional manner, making himself and the other course participants feel very uncomfortable.[93]In his affidavit, Mr Hurikino stated that Mr Swann stood over the Applicant and addressed him in a raised tone with his finger pointed at the Applicant. Mr Hurikino gave evidence that he felt the debrief should have been done in private, away from the course participants. In re-examination, Mr Hurikino stated that the Applicant was ‘probably excited by it all, emotional, because he was the handler to the instructor, that was working the dog and his priority concern was the handler’.[94]Mr Butler stated in his affidavit that the Applicant complained to him about Mr Swann’s debrief following the CSD Ox incident, following which he interviewed the four witnesses identified by the Applicant. These witnesses were Mr Hurikino, Mr Hageman, Mr Morris and Mick Ciccolini.[95]Mr Butler gave evidence that he took contemporaneous notes of his meeting with the dog handlers involved. The Applicant submits that Mr Butler’s evidence under cross-examination is different to that contained in his affidavit, in that rather than diarising a contemporaneous note of his meeting with the attendees, the oral evidence shows that notes were made after the meeting and were recorded on a page in a notepad which was later torn out. Mr Butler stated in evidence that his notes were a ‘reflection’ of his earlier conversation with the Dog Squad officers, complaining about Mr Swann’s treatment of the Applicant.[96]Mr Butler stated that Mr Ciccolini and Mr Hageman said that there had been no verbal or threatening behaviour by Mr Swann.[97]Mr Butler said that Mr Hurikino and Mr Hageman said that they thought that Mr Swann’s debrief could have been delivered in private. Mr Butler denies that Mr Hurikino used terms such as ‘unprofessional’, ‘inappropriate’ behaviour or anything about standing over or point at the Applicant.[98]Both Mr Hurikino and Mr Hageman disagreed with the affidavit evidence of Mr Butler as to how they responded when asked about the incident as part of Mr Butler’s investigation into the incident. In re-examination, Mr Hurikino states that he told Mr Butler that he thought Mr Swann’s debrief was inappropriate and he told him why he thought it was inappropriate. Mr Hageman’s evidence was that he conveyed to Mr Butler his view that Mr Swann could have handled the debrief in a much more professional manner. [99]This matter was subsequently referred to the Ethical Standards Unit and no further action was taken against Mr Swann. [100]On the question of whether Mr Butler was aware that the Applicant believed himself to be the subject of bullying, Mr Butler stated in his affidavit that the Applicant spoke to him on occasions about his work and that he felt undervalued in relation to his experience and contributions and that Mr Scott was held in higher regard than him. The Applicant felt that his training methods were not appreciated by Mr Swann, that he did not fit into the team and that his performance was subject to greater scrutiny than other team members. Mr Butler did not however recall the Applicant complaining that he was the subject of bullying by Mr Swann. [101]The Respondents submit that Mr Swann’s debrief was taken by the Applicant and others present to be directed at the Applicant because of his response to the dog bite on Mr Fox, however, Mr Swann denies that was his intention. [102]The Respondents submit that while it was not delivered in an ideal way, it was reasonable for Mr Swann to speak to the Applicant about the incident. The Respondents submit that the way the Applicant was spoken to in front of the others is a blemish on otherwise reasonable management action. [103]I am satisfied that the witness evidence of the Applicant, Mr Hurikino and Mr Hageman supports the conclusion that, in the debrief following the dog bite on Mr Fox, Mr Swann directed his comments toward the Applicant. [104]The evidence of Mr Swann was that the Applicant became somewhat emotional during the incident. Mr Swann indicated that his comments were directed at ensuring that employees did not become emotional during incidents such as the one that had just occurred. Mr Hurikino’s evidence was that the Applicant was probably excited and emotional given that he was the trainer and his priority was the handler. In these circumstances, Mr Swann holding a debrief was a reasonable course of action to provide employees with guidance as to how situations such as that which occurred should be handled. [105]Although Mr Swann’s evidence is that he did not address the Applicant specifically during the debrief, the evidence of Mr Hurikino and Mr Hageman suggests otherwise. On the basis of Mr Hageman and Mr Hurikino’s evidence, I accept that Mr Swann directed his comments at the Applicant in a manner that was not reasonable. If Mr Swann felt that the Applicant needed to be spoken to about being mechanical rather than emotional, this conversation should not have taken place in front of other employees and should have been conducted in more professional manner. [106]In situations in which there is an urgent need for an employee to be spoken to about their conduct, it may be necessary to do so in front of others. However, in this situation there was no urgency as the incident had resolved and consequently, there was no requirement that the Applicant be singled out in the debrief. Mr Swann’s decision to address his concerns with respect to emotional responses was reasonable management action, however, the manner in which he spoke to the Applicant in the debrief demonstrates that this action was not conducted in a reasonable manner. The Applicant rightfully felt aggrieved by this occurrence.”