Grebnev v Perpetual Corporate Trust Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

Supreme Court of South Australia

(Appeal to a Single Judge)

GREBNEV v PERPETUAL CORPORATE TRUST LIMITED

[2022] SASC 154

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Blue  

20 December 2022

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES

CONSUMER CREDIT - CREDIT PROTECTION - GENERAL - OPERATION OF CREDIT LEGISLATION - INTERPRETATION AND DEFINITIONS - LOAN CONTRACT

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - FORMATION OF CONTRACTUAL RELATIONS - GENERAL OFFERS AND THEIR ACCEPTANCE

Appeal against summary judgment granted by a Magistrate in favour of the respondent against the appellant for the balance of a loan found to have been made by Australian Executor Trustee Limited, which loan was found to have been assigned by Australian Executor Trustee to the respondent. The Magistrate also dismissed the appellant’s application for summary judgment dismissing the respondent’s claim.

Held:

1The Magistrate erred in granting summary judgment in favour of the respondent against the appellant because the appellant failed to prove:

(a)    entry into a loan contract (at [104]);

(b)    assignment of the debt (at [121]); or

(c)     the giving of notice of assignment (at [130]).

2The Magistrate did not err in refusing summary judgment in favour of the appellant against the respondent because:

(a)    the appellant failed to prove entry into a private settlement agreement or any other agreement precluding the appellant’s claim (at [140]);

(b)    the discontinuance by the appellant of an earlier action in the Local Court of New South Wales for the same cause of action did not preclude institution of the action in the Magistrates Court (at [142]); and

(c)     the Magistrate did not make the procedural errors alleged by the appellant (at [149], [153], [156], [164]).

3Appeal allowed. Orders relating to summary judgment in favour of the respondent set aside. Matter remitted to the Magistrates Court (at [166]).

Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) s 12; Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) s 5(1), s 21(1); National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (Cth) s 35, s 37, referred to.

GREBNEV v PERPETUAL CORPORATE TRUST LIMITED

[2022] SASC 154

Single Judge Appeal: Civil

  1. BLUE J: A Magistrate granted summary judgment in favour of the respondent Perpetual Corporate Trust Limited (Perpetual) against the appellant Nikolay Grebnev (Nikolay) for $23,555.30 as the balance of a loan found to have been made by Australian Executor Trustees Limited (AET), which loan was found to have been assigned by AET to Perpetual. The Magistrate also dismissed Nikolay’s application for summary judgment dismissing Perpetual’s claim.

  2. Nikolay appeals against the summary judgment in favour of Perpetual and the dismissal of his own summary judgment application. 

    Background

  3. Plenti RE Limited was in 2019 called RateSetter Australia RE Ltd. I refer to the company variously as RateSetter RE or Plenti RE, primarily having regard to the period when it was using each name. Benjamin Milsom was the Director and Chief Commercial Officer of the company.

  4. RateSetter RE was (and still is), amongst other things, the responsible entity for a managed investment scheme (the RateSetter Platform)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Grebnev v Perpetual Corporate Trust Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] SASC 154
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Grebnev v Perpetual Corporate Trust Limited concerns the validity and enforceability of a loan contract between Nikolay Grebnev and Perpetual Corporate Trust Limited (Perpetual), as well as the application of summary judgment in this context. The primary dispute revolves around whether Perpetual properly established the existence of a loan agreement with Nikolay and if Nikolay's defence was reasonable or groundless, thereby justifying summary judgment in Perpetual's favour. The case was heard and determined in the Magistrates Court of Victoria, with the decision being appealed to a higher court.

The legal issues at the heart of this appeal revolve around the formation of the loan contract and the appropriate application of the summary judgment mechanism. Specifically, the court had to determine whether Perpetual had sufficiently demonstrated the existence of a valid contract between the parties and whether Nikolay's defence was reasonable or frivolous. This involved scrutinising the evidence presented by Perpetual, including the affidavit of Benjamin Milsom and the documentary evidence tendered, to ascertain whether a binding loan agreement existed and whether Nikolay had a reasonable basis for disputing the debt.

The court, in its initial judgment, found that Perpetual had provided substantial evidence supporting the existence of a loan contract, including the quote issued on 27 March 2019, Nikolay's offer on 29 March 2019, and the acceptance by Australian Executive Trustee Limited (AET) on the same day. The court noted that the Milsom affidavit detailed a series of communications and documents that corroborated Perpetual's claims. The court also dismissed Nikolay's reliance on a Private Settlement Agreement, ruling that it was irrelevant and did not bind Perpetual, as it was allegedly between Nikolay and Plenti RE, which was not a party to the proceeding. Based on these findings, the court concluded that Perpetual had a reasonable cause of action and granted summary judgment in its favour.

In the appeal, the court will likely review the reasoning and evidence underpinning the initial summary judgment, ensuring that all legal and factual considerations were properly addressed. The court will also assess whether the lower court correctly applied the principles of summary judgment and if Nikolay's defence was indeed groundless. The outcome of the appeal will hinge on whether the court finds any errors in the lower court's judgment or if it affirms the initial decision based on the evidence and legal principles applied.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Nikolay appeals against the summary judgment in favour of Perpetual and the dismissal of his own summary judgment application. Background Plenti RE Limited was in 2019 called RateSetter Australia RE Ltd. I refer to the company variously as RateSetter RE or Plenti RE, primarily having regard to the period when it was using each name. Benjamin Milsom was the Director and Chief Commercial Officer of the company. RateSetter RE was (and still is), amongst other things, the responsible entity for a managed investment scheme (the RateSetter Platform) that in 2019 was called the RateSetter Retail Lending Platform and is now called the Plenti Retail Lending Platform. The custodian for the RateSetter Platform was AET in 2019. The RateSetter Platform provided credit to consumers. RateSetter RE provided credit assistance to potential borrowers from the RateSetter Platform and other entities. RateSetter RE held an Australian Credit Licence (a Licence) issued by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission under sections 35 and 37 of the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (Cth) (the Credit Act). Since at least March 2019 RateSetter RE (either in its own right or as the responsible entity of the RateSetter Platform) has maintained a public website (the Website). The purpose of the Website is, amongst others, to enable consumers to apply for the provision of credit. On 23 March 2019 Lachlan Fursman at “RateSetter” sent an email addressed to an email address in the name of Nikolay (the Grebnev email address). Mr Fursman said that RateSetter had received Nikolay’s bank statements but required evidence of his income and salary credits for assessment under its credit policy. He requested bank statements for another account showing evidence of income. Between 23 March 2019 and 26 March 2019 there were a series of emails between Mr Fursman or Glenn Clissold of “RateSetter” on the one hand and the Grebnev email address on the other hand referring to the provision of bank statements by Nikolay. Mr Milson in his affidavit made on 13 May 2022 said that on 27 March 2019 Plenti RE provided a quote to Nikolay for a loan. Perpetual in its statement of claim pleaded that on 27 March 2019 Plenti RE provided a quote to Nikolay entitled “RateSetter Pre-Contractual Disclosure and Loan Contract” (the 27 March Quote). Perpetual pleaded that the loan contract was comprised by three communications: the 27 March Quote, an Offer by Nikolay on 29 March 2019 and an Acceptance by AET on 29 March 2019. Perpetual did not tender the 27 March 2019 Quote. On 28 March 2019 Mr Clissold received an email from the Grebnev email address inquiring if there was any news yet. Tahlia Smith at “RateSetter” responded saying that the application had been passed to RateSetter’s credit team to be assessed. Perpetual tendered at the summary judgment hearing exhibit 11 to Mr Milsom’s affidavit being a schedule setting out details of communications said to have been made between RateSetter RE and Nikolay (Exhibit 11 or the Schedule). Exhibit 11 comprised a date and time column, type of communication column, template column, addressee column, status column, delivered column, message column and resend column. The communications ranged from 29 March 2019 at 11.02 am to 4 June 2019 at 10.30 am. Mr Milsom did not describe how Exhibit 11 was compiled or the sources of information for it. The delivered column is blank for each row in the document.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Magistrate delivered ex tempore reasons for judgment.[3][3] The reasons were delivered on 27 May 2022. However, the Magistrate subsequently produced reasons for judgment in formal form on 17 August 2022.The Magistrate’s reasons for judgment The Magistrate addressed the legal principles applying to summary judgment and summarised the background. The Magistrate said that Nikolay denied the debt, submitted that Perpetual had failed to prove the debt and relied on the Private Settlement Agreement. The Magistrate first addressed Nikolay’s summary judgment application. The Magistrate accepted that Perpetual had a reasonable cause of action. The Magistrate held that the Private Settlement Agreement was not relevant and did not bind Perpetual because it was alleged to be between Nikolay and Plenti RE, which was not a party to the proceeding. The Magistrate then addressed Perpetual’s summary judgment application. The Magistrate referred to the Milsom affidavit. The Magistrate said:In summary, the Milsom Affidavit exhibits a number of significant and contemporary documents, which confirm that on or about 27 March 2019, the Respondent obtained a quote for a personal loan. The original about sought was $40,000.00.… The documents in the Milsom Affidavit confirmed the contract for the loan would be between Australian Executive Trustee Limited and the Respondent, and that Plenti was simply the credit provider. In this regard, see document 4 of the Milsom affidavit.[4] After finalisation of the paperwork (see paras.12-18 of the Milsom Affidavit) and on 29 March 2019, the sum of $23,000.00 was distributed to the Respondent. This is supported by the Milsom affidavit in document 5 being the loan statement issued for the loan.[5]…The Milsom Affidavit further indicates the loan was assigned on or about 24 March 2020 to the current Applicant. The Respondent was given notice by letter dated 24 June 2020 (see document 7)[6] and further letter dated 3 June 2008 (see document 8 of the Milsom affidavit).[7] …Based on the Mr Milsom Affidavit, the Applicant submits there is no positive denial in the Respondent’s defence. The defence merely is seeking to put the Applicant to proof.I accept the Applicant’s submissions that in view and in light of the Milsom Affidavit, the defence of the Agreement between Plenti and the Respondent has no reasonable basis to defend the claim and further, all other grounds in the defence cannot possibly succeed and are groundless.Further, the Applicant submits this is supported by the admission made by the Respondent to Mr Maley on 29 October 2021 (and supported by Annexure C file note).[8]As such, I grant the Applicant’s Application pursuant to rule 144.2(1)(a) on the basis that the Respondent has no reasonable basis for a defence and find that the Milsom and Maley Affidavits support a judgement being entered against the Respondent in the amount of $23,555.30 as at 16 May 2022.[4] This is the Exhibit 4 referred to at [12] above.[5] This is the loan statement dated 13 July 2021 referred to at [42] above.[6] This is the letter referred to at [34] above.[7] This is the letter dated 3 June 2021 referred to at [40] above.[8] This is the file note dated 8 September 2021 referred to at [61] above.The appeal hearing

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.