Gray v Hart; Estate of Harris (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Gray v Hart; Estate of Harris (No. 2) [2012] NSWSC 1562
Hearing dates:10 December 2012
Decision date: 11 December 2012
Jurisdiction:Equity Division - Probate List
Before: White J
Decision:

Refer to paras [49] and [50] of judgment.

Catchwords: COSTS - WILLS, PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION - exceptions in probate litigation to ordinary rule that costs follow the event - competing reasons of policy which affect how discretion to award costs should be exercised in probate litigation - deceased was the cause of litigation and so prima facie costs of unsuccessful defendants should come out of estate - adjustment necessary in relation to first and second defendants because they raised issues that do not fall within rationale for ordering unsuccessful parties' costs to be paid out of estate in probate litigation and because those issues were raised unreasonably - half of first and second defendants' costs to be paid out of estate
Cases Cited: Estate of Harris; Gray v Hart [2010] NSWSC 55
Mitchell v Gard (1863) 3 Sw & Tr 275 at 277; 164 ER 1280
Re Hodges; Shorter v Hodges (1988) 14 NSWLR 698
Shorten v Shorten (No. 2) [2003] NSWCA 60
Redroff v Miegoch (Supreme Court of New South Wales, Santow J, 22 April 1996, unreported, BC9601491)
Moyle v Moyle (Supreme Court of New South Wales, Santow J, 18 June 1998, unreported)
Hubbard v Mason (Supreme Court of New South Wales, Santow J, 8 July 1998, unreported, BC9803106)
Perpetual Trustee Co Ltd v Baker [1999] NSWCA 244
The Estate of Grounds; re Page v Sedawie [2005] NSWSC 1311
Davies v Gregory (1873) LR 3 P&D 28
Johnston v Public Trustee (1929) 24 Tas LR 71 In the Will of Millar [1908] VLR 682
Kenny v Wilson (1911) 11 SR(NSW) 460
Levy v Leo (1909) 25 TLR 717 and Oldcorn v Tenniswood (1909) 25 TLR 825
Mead v Watson [2005] NSWCA 133; (2005) 23 ACLC 718
Texts Cited: Tristram and Coote's Probate Practice, Butterworths LexisNexis, 29th ed
Williams, Mortimer and Sunnucks, Executors, Administrators and Probate, 18th ed
Category:Costs
Parties: Beatrice Anne Gray (Plaintiff)
Coralie Anne Hart (1st Defendant)
Richard Bernard Spinak (2nd Defendant)
Warwick Robert Mertell (3rd Defendant)
Philip Fletcher Mertell (4th Defendant)
Anne Elizabeth Nickolls (5th Defendant)
Representation: Counsel:
C Harris SC (Plaintiff)
L Ellison SC with M Pringle (1st & 2nd Defendants)
C Vindin (3rd - 5th Defendants)
Solicitors:
Teece Hodgson Ward Solicitors (Plaintiff)
Pigott Stinson Lawyers (1st & 2nd Defendants)
Heckenberg Lawyers (3rd - 5th Defendants)
File Number(s):2009/319943

Judgment

  1. HIS HONOUR: Two questions concerning costs arise in these proceedings.

  1. The first is what order for costs should be made in relation to applications concerning the appointment of an administrator pending the determination of the proceedings. Those applications were heard and dealt with by Palmer J on 8 February 2010 (Estate of Harris; Gray v Hart [2010] NSWSC 55). His Honour declined to appoint either Mr Swindells, as sought by the first…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gray v Hart; Estate of Harris (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NSWSC 1562
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court, Gray commenced proceedings against Hart, seeking to have a will of Harris declared invalid. Hart was the executor of the will and the first and second defendants were beneficiaries. Gray's claim was unsuccessful, and Hart and the first and second defendants applied for costs against Gray. The first and second defendants raised their own claim against Gray, which was dismissed. The first and second defendants appealed the decision that they pay their own costs. The court had to decide the extent to which the ordinary rule that costs follow the event may be departed from in probate litigation, and the appropriate division of costs between the first and second defendants and Gray.

The court found that the ordinary rule that costs follow the event may be departed from in probate litigation, but only in exceptional circumstances. The court held that the deceased was the cause of the litigation, and so the prima facie rule was that the costs of the unsuccessful party should come out of the estate. The court also found that the first and second defendants had raised issues that did not fall within the rationale for ordering unsuccessful parties' costs to be paid out of the estate in probate litigation, and that those issues were raised unreasonably. The court held that the first and second defendants should pay half of their costs out of the estate.

The court held that the first and second defendants should pay half of their costs out of the estate, and that the remainder should be paid by Gray. The court held that the first and second defendants' costs should be divided equally between them. The court also held that the costs of the appeal should be divided between Gray and the first and second defendants, with Gray to pay one-third of the costs and the first and second defendants to pay two-thirds.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established