Grant Olver Investments Pty Ltd v Pilgrim A/S [Sec=Unclassified]

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Grant Olver Investments Pty Ltd to protection of International Registration Designating Australia 981508 (6,14,20) - PILGRIM - (International Registration No. 682561) filed in the name of Pilgrim A/S.

Delegate: Alison Windsor
Representation: Opponent:  Maria Schwartz, of Schwartz Barristers and Solicitors
Holder:  Wayne Willis of FB Rice & Co
Decision: 2009 ATMO 70
Reg 17A.29 opposition: Grounds under ss 44, 58 and 60 pursued in respect of goods in class 14 only– opposition decided under s 58 – opponent was owner of trade mark under common law because of earliest use in Australia – opposition successful– costs awarded against holder.

Background

  1. Application 980508, an international registration designating Australia (“IRDA”), was filed in the name of Pilgrim A/S (“the holder”) of Denmark under the Madrid Protocol on 3 October 2003 (“the priority date”). IP Australia was notified of this on 11 December 2003 and, following examination of the IRDA, advertised on 13 October 2005 its intention to extend protection to Australia under the provisions of subsection 44(4) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (“the Act”).[1] 

    [1] See regulation 17.28 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (“the regulations”) which covers the application of the provisions of this section of the Act to an IRDA.

  2. Current details of the IRDA are as follows:

    Application Number:  981508
    International Number:          682561
    Priority Date:   3 October 2003

    Goods:  Class 6: Semi-finished articles of common metals for use in the manufacture of jewellery and sunglasses

    Class 14:Jewellery

    Class 20:Furniture, mirrors, picture frames; goods (not included in other classes) of wood, cork, reed, cane, wicker, horn, bone, ivory, whalebone, shell, amber, mother-of-pearl, meerschaum and substitutes for all these materials, or of plastic

    Trade Mark:  PILGRIM

  3. Grant Olver Investments Pty Ltd (“the opponent”) filed a notice of opposition (“the notice”) on 15 December 2005.  Evidence in support, in answer and in reply were filed and served, the process being completed by mid January 2009. 

  4. The opponent then requested to be heard, and the matter came before me, as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, in Canberra on 10 June 2009.  Maria Schwartz of Schwartz Barristers and Solicitors appeared for the opponent via telephone conference.  Wayne Willis of F B Rice & Co appeared for the applicant via video link.

    Grounds of opposition and onus

  5. The notice was wide ranging, nominating grounds under sections 41, 42, 43, 44, 58, 59, 60 and 62.  At the hearing, the opponent advised that it would only be pursuing grounds under sections 44, 58, 60 and 62, and those grounds would be pursued in respect of goods in class 14 alone, namely “jewellery”. 

  6. For completeness, I decide that grounds under the provisions of sections 41, 42, 43 and 59 in the notice have not been established.  As the opponent did not make any specific claims or submissions in respect of the ground under section 62, it is also not established.

  7. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Grant Olver Investments Pty Ltd v Pilgrim A/S [Sec=Unclassif... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] ATMO 70
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an opposition by Pilgrim A/S to the registration of a trade mark by Grant Olver Investments Pty Ltd. The dispute centred on Pilgrim A/S's claim to prior use of the word "PILGRIM" as a trade mark in Australia, specifically in relation to jewellery. The decision was made by Hearing Officer Alison Windsor.

The primary legal issue before the Hearing Officer was whether Pilgrim A/S had established grounds for opposing the registration of Grant Olver Investments Pty Ltd's trade mark, particularly concerning the use of the word "PILGRIM" for jewellery. This involved assessing evidence of trade mark use in Australia from as early as 1993.

The Hearing Officer found that Pilgrim A/S had successfully established its ground for opposition under section 58 of the relevant legislation, based on evidence of prior use of the "PILGRIM" trade mark in relation to jewellery. The evidence presented included declarations attesting to the sale and knowledge of jewellery bearing the "PILGRIM" mark from various dates between 1993 and 2002, along with examples of swing tags, receipts, and adhesive tape used in the course of trade.

Consequently, the Hearing Officer ordered that protection for the trade mark be refused in respect of jewellery (class 14). Protection was to be extended for goods in classes 6 and 20, with an endorsement related to acceptance under subsection 44(4) to be removed. Pilgrim A/S was awarded costs against Grant Olver Investments Pty Ltd.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence in reply consisted of a single declaration, being the following:· Kenneth Ross Olver with exhibit K1 (referred to as Olver 2), made 15 January 2009The Opponent’s evidence The opponent’s evidence goes to establishing its claim to use of the word PILGRIM as a trade mark in respect of jewellery in Australia from as early as 1993. The Bella and Olver 1 declarations refer to use of the word in respect of sales of jewellery in Australia, as well as clothing and clothing accessories from late 1993 or early 1994. The Robertson and Landeman declarations attest to knowledge of the sale of jewellery under the PILGRIM trade mark in Australia from some time in 1996. The remaining declarations refer to knowledge of this use at varying times from 1995 to 2002. Several of the declarations provide examples of the trade mark as it was in use according to the particular declarant’s experiences as set out in their declarations. The Landeman, Calabro and Bella declarations exhibit copies of receipts for the purchase of items of jewellery in the opponent’s Australian stores, all of which are dated in the years 2000 and 2001. At the top of all of these receipts are the words “PILGRIM - THANKS YOU”. The Bella declaration exhibits a copy of the swing tags used within the business on all of the goods sold at the time she was first employed in 1993. She states that a green and blue swing tag, a reproduction of which appears below, was attached to all items of jewellery, and that a stick-on label in the same form was also applied to the tissue paper used to wrap each item at the time of sale. The declaration also notes that the company changed its branding to pink and black colours at some unspecified time. The Olver 1 declaration states that this change occurred around 1999 at which stage the company was trading under the word “PILGRIM” as well as using its trade mark 959624, which is shown in the following swing tag reproduction: From the time the company colours changed in 1999 up until at least the dates of declaration, both Bella and Robertson refer to use of adhesive tape in the colours pink and black used to close bags of purchases at the point of sale. A representation of a piece of this adhesive tape is reproduced below: The Michaelides and Reeves declarations are both made by persons who manufactured and sold jewellery to the opponent. Teresa Maree Reeves states that she designed and manufactured jewellery in the early 1990s at which time she occupied a workshop situated above the premises of one of the opponent’s retail stores. She states that all the jewellery she sold to the opponent was advertised for sale in the opponent’s stores, and subsequently sold, bearing a green and blue swing tag the same as that shown previously at paragraph 14. She also recalls a range of watches sold in the opponent’s stores which had the word PILGRIM on the watch face. Estelle Michaelides states that she designed and manufactured an exclusive range of jewellery and headware for the opponent in the five years up to the date of her declaration (made 12 July 2007). She says that all the jewellery she sold to the opponent in that period had been labeled with a swing tag or card, a reproduction of which is shown below:

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having established the ground under section 58 the opponent has been successful in its opposition, and there is no requirement that I consider any of the other grounds pressed at the hearing. Decision Subregulation 17A.34(1) provides:17A.34(1) Unless the opposition proceedings are discontinued or dismissed, the Registrar must decide:(a) to refuse protection in respect of all of the goods or services listed in the IRDA; or(b) to extend protection in respect of some or all of the goods or services listed in the IRDA (with or without conditions or limitations);having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the IRDA was opposed has been established. The opponent has been successful in its opposition. I therefore refuse to extend protection to the goods listed in class 14, namely “jewellery”. I will extend protection to the goods listed in classes 6 and 20, as set out in paragraph 1 of this decision, one month from the date of this decision. I note also that the endorsement referring to acceptance under the provisions of subsection 44(4) becomes redundant once class 14 is deleted, and that endorsement will be removed prior to the application proceeding to protection. If the Registrar is notified of an appeal from this decision within the time allowed by the Court, the above decision will not take effect until the appeal has been discontinued, or in the event of a decision issuing from the court, the IRDA will be subject to those orders.Costs The opponent has been successful and is entitled to its costs. I award costs against the holder according to the official scale.Alison WindsorHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings3 September 2009

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established