Gralton & Anor v. Hopfner

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CIVIL JURISDICTION

[2009] QSC 16

FRYBERG J

No 1525 of 2009

DAVID JOHN GRALTON AND ANOTHER Applicants

and

RUDOLF RICHARD HOPFNER AND OTHERS Respondents

BRISBANE

..DATE 10/02/2009

DAY 2

CONTINUED FROM 02/02/09

ORDER

HIS HONOUR:  I have before me an application for orders that the first respondent be held in contempt of Court and punished for failing to cause the second respondent to comply with orders 3 and 4 of this Court made by Justice Dutney on the 10th of March, 2008, and that the second respondent be held in contempt and fined for failing to comply with order 3.

Another ground of contempt referred to in the application, that is, failure to comply with order 5 of the orders, has not been pressed.

The corporate respondent carried on business in 2007 providing business services including business administration, business management, book keeping, accounting, tax accounting consultancy and the cash flow funding.

In the course of carrying on that business it set up an arrangement with the Bank of Queensland.  Under that arrangement, amounts in which the company's customers were indebted to it would be assigned to the bank.  The bank would advance the amount of the assigned debts to the company, the debts would be payable to the bank, and when received by the bank, would be dealt with in a way that I shall describe shortly.  The amount advanced by the bank in the first place was 80 percent of the face value of the relevant invoice, and after the invoice was paid, and the possibility of any refund removed, the bank would pay the remaining 20 percent of the value of the invoice to the company.

In January 2008, arrangements were made between the respondents and the applicants for some services to be provided by the respondents for the applicants, but it seems that this arrangement was not formally reduced to writing beyond some apparent heads of agreement, and did not last very long.

By February 2008 it had been terminated.  Before its termination a number of invoices had been sent out on behalf of the applicants requiring payment of the amount owing to them to the Bank of Queensland via an account, the last three digits of the number of which were 805.  It seems that the applicants were unaware of the detail of the arrangements between the respondents and the bank.

After the arrangements between the applicants and the respondents ceased to operate, the applicants sent out their invoices to customers marked for payment by cheque or remittance in some other way but not marked for direct credit to the account previously specified on invoices sent to customers.

The applicant also made a substantial effort to contact customers and to tell them not to remit money to the Bank of Queensland in the manner specified on earlier invoices.  However, it was apparent by the beginning of February that there would be some of the applicants' customers who might have older invoices unpaid,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gralton & Anor v. Hopfner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] QSC 16
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Gralton and Another v. Hopfner was a case before the Supreme Court of Queensland, where the applicants sought to hold the respondents in contempt of court for failing to comply with certain orders. The applicants alleged that the respondents did not pay certain sums of money to the applicants, as directed by orders made by Justice Dutney. The applicants also alleged that the second respondent did not provide the required statutory declaration regarding the inability to pay. The respondents argued that they were not in contempt as the payments were not properly received by them and that the bank was responsible for the funds. The respondents also argued that the orders did not apply to the payments in question.

The court examined the legal issues concerning the interpretation of the orders and whether the respondents were in contempt for failing to comply with them. The court found that the respondents were not in contempt as the orders did not apply to the payments in question. The court held that the payments in question were not payments received by the respondents in payment of invoices rendered by the applicants, as required by the orders. The court further held that the terms of order 3 were not satisfied, and therefore, order 4 never fell to be complied with. Consequently, the application was dismissed.

In conclusion, the Supreme Court of Queensland dismissed the applicants' claim that the respondents were in contempt of court for failing to comply with certain orders. The court held that the orders did not apply to the payments in question, and therefore, the respondents were not in contempt. The applicants' application was dismissed, and no orders were made against the respondents.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established