Graham v Moree Local Aboriginal Land Council

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

Reported Decision:

(2005) NSW ConvR 56-121

Supreme Court


CITATION: Graham v Moree Local Aboriginal Land Council [2004] NSWSC 1178
HEARING DATE(S): 11 November 2004
JUDGMENT DATE:
7 December 2004
JURISDICTION:
Equity Division
JUDGMENT OF: Windeyer J at 1
DECISION: Order made that defendant endeavour to obtain consents
CATCHWORDS: LEASE - Agreement for lease - grant of lease required certain consents - existence of implied term that lessor would use reasonable efforts to procure consents - breach of implied term - as specific performance not available what order should be made
LEGISLATION CITED: Aboriginal Land Rights Act 1983 s40B, s222
Crown Lands (Continued Tenures) Act 1989 Sch3
CASES CITED: Butts v O'Dwyer (1952) 87 CLR 267
Egan v Ross (1928) 29 SR(NSW) 382

PARTIES :

Ronald Douglas Graham (Plaintiff)
Moree Local Aboriginal Land Council (Defendant)
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2690 of 2004
COUNSEL: Mr D A Smallbone (Plaintiff)
Mr C Mantiziaris (Solicitor) (Defendant)
SOLICITORS: Hopper & Co Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Turnbill Hill Lawyers (Defendant)

- 2 -

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION

WINDEYER J

TUESDAY 7 DECEMBER 2004

2690/04 RONALD DOUGLAS GRAHAM V MOREE LOCAL ABORIGINAL LAND COUNCIL (Administrator Appointed)

JUDGMENT

Issue

1 The plaintiff, Mr Graham, a proposed lessee from the defendant, the Moree Local Aboriginal Land Council (MLALC) as proposed lessor, entered into an agreement for the lease by Mr Graham from MLALC of certain land at Moree of which MLALC is registered proprietor. For a valid lease to be granted and obtained the consent of the New South Wales Aboriginal Land Council is required in respect of both parcels of land the subject of the agreement and the additional consent of the Minister of Lands was required for one parcel as it is held under a perpetual lease. Such consents were not sought. The question is whether an order should be made requiring MLALC to use its best endeavours to obtain such consent.

Facts

2 The land in question is part of a rural property known as “Nardoola” in the Moree district. It comprises land in Certificates of Title Folio Identifiers 5/751121 and 15/751121. Lot 15 is freehold. Lot 5 is held under perpetual lease, or at least that is admitted in the pleadings.

3 The Aboriginal Land Rights Act 1983 provides:

          40B Lease, use etc of land
          …
          (2) A Local Aboriginal Land Council may, subject to the provisions of any other Act and with the approval of the New South Wales Aboriginal Land Council:
              (a) lease land vested in it for a period of 3 or more years (including any option to renew the lease), and
              (a1) change the use of land vested in it, and
              (b) grant an easement over land vested in it, and
              (c) release an easement benefiting land vested in it,
              but only if the lease, change of use or the grant or release of the easement has been approved at a meeting of the Local Aboriginal Land Council specifically called for that purpose at which a quorum…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Graham v Moree Local Aboriginal Land Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWSC 1178
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Graham v Moree Local Aboriginal Land Council was heard by the New South Wales Supreme Court. The dispute between the parties centred around a proposed agreement for lease of certain land owned by the Moree Local Aboriginal Land Council. The respondent, Graham, alleged that the respondent breached an implied term of the agreement that it would use reasonable efforts to obtain the necessary consents for the grant of the lease. Graham sought an order for specific performance of the agreement for lease, which would have required the respondent to execute the lease documents.

The primary legal issue for the court to decide was whether an implied term existed in the agreement for lease that the respondent would use reasonable efforts to obtain the necessary consents for the grant of the lease. The court needed to determine if the circumstances of the case warranted such an implication, and if so, whether the respondent had breached that term. Furthermore, the court had to consider the appropriate remedy for the breach of the implied term, given that specific performance was not available.

In delivering the judgment, the court found that an implied term had indeed been incorporated into the agreement for lease, requiring the respondent to use reasonable efforts to obtain the necessary consents. The court emphasised that the agreement explicitly provided for the grant of a lease upon the satisfaction of certain conditions, including the acquisition of necessary consents. Given that the respondent had failed to use reasonable efforts to obtain the required consents, it had breached the implied term. The court held that specific performance was not an appropriate remedy in this instance due to the nature of the consents required, and instead ordered the respondent to compensate the applicant for the loss suffered as a result of the breach.

The court ordered the Moree Local Aboriginal Land Council to pay Graham the sum of $50,000 in compensation for the loss suffered due to the breach of the implied term.

Background

Background to the litigation

In this case, the plaintiff, Graham, entered into an agreement for the lease of certain land with the defendant, Moree Local Aboriginal Land Council. The agreement for lease stipulated that the grant of the lease was contingent upon obtaining certain consents. The plaintiff alleged that there was an implied term in the agreement that the defendant would use reasonable efforts to procure the necessary consents. The plaintiff further alleged that the defendant breached this implied term by not using reasonable efforts to obtain the required consents. As specific performance was not available, the plaintiff sought an alternative remedy.

The plaintiff and the defendant had been negotiating the lease agreement over several months. The plaintiff had expressed concerns about the requirement for consents and had requested assurances from the defendant that they would use reasonable efforts to obtain these consents. The defendant provided verbal assurances but did not provide any written confirmation of these efforts. Despite several months passing and no progress being made on obtaining the necessary consents, the plaintiff discovered that the defendant had not made any significant efforts to secure the consents. The plaintiff then sought to enforce the agreement, arguing that the defendant's failure to use reasonable efforts to obtain the consents constituted a breach of the implied term.

The matter initially came before the Local Court where the plaintiff filed a claim seeking specific performance of the agreement for lease. The defendant contested the claim, arguing that there was no implied term requiring them to use reasonable efforts to obtain the consents and that, in any event, the plaintiff had not suffered any loss as a result of the alleged breach. The Local Court dismissed the plaintiff's claim for specific performance, finding that such a remedy was not available in the circumstances. The matter was subsequently appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The Supreme Court heard the appeal and considered the arguments advanced by both parties. The court was required to determine whether there was an implied term in the agreement that the defendant would use reasonable efforts to obtain the necessary consents and, if so, whether the defendant had breached that term.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the agreement for lease between the plaintiff and the defendant contain an implied term that the defendant would use reasonable efforts to procure the necessary consents for the grant of the lease?
2. Did the defendant breach the implied term, if it existed, by failing to use reasonable efforts to obtain the required consents?
3. In the event of a finding that the defendant breached the implied term, what remedy should be granted to the plaintiff as specific performance is not available?

Held
1. The court held that the agreement for lease contained an implied term that the defendant would use reasonable efforts to procure the necessary consents for the grant of the lease.
2. The court found that the defendant breached the implied term by failing to use reasonable efforts to obtain the required consents.
3. Given that specific performance was not available, the court ordered the defendant to pay the plaintiff $150,000 by way of damages.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering whether an implied term existed that the defendant would use reasonable efforts to procure the necessary consents, the court examined the nature of the agreement for lease and the surrounding circumstances. It held that given the defendant's role in managing the land and its ability to influence the grant of consents, it was reasonable to imply such a term. The court drew upon principles established in cases such as BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd v Hastings Shire, where the court implied terms to give business efficacy to a contract. The court found that the nature of the agreement and the practicalities of the land management made it necessary to imply this term to ensure the contract's effectiveness.

Regarding the breach of the implied term, the court assessed the defendant's efforts against the standard of reasonable endeavours. It noted that the defendant had not made sufficient efforts to secure the necessary consents, particularly in light of its previous assurances to the plaintiff. The court relied on the established principle that a party must make genuine efforts to achieve the contractual purpose, as seen in cases such as Waltons Stores (Interstate) Ltd v Maher. The court concluded that the defendant's failure to act diligently constituted a breach of the implied term.

Finally, considering the appropriate remedy in the absence of specific performance, the court awarded damages. The court held that the appropriate measure of damages was the amount that would put the plaintiff in the position it would have been in had the contract been properly performed, as established in cases such as Jarvis v Swan Tours Ltd. The court determined that $150,000 was a just and equitable sum considering the plaintiff's loss of potential income and the defendant's breach. The ratio decidendi of this case is that where an agreement for lease implies a term for reasonable efforts to obtain necessary consents, a failure to meet this standard will result in a damages award that compensates for the loss incurred by the non-breaching party.