CITATION: Graham v Hulme; Hulme v Graham [2009] NSWSC 1264 HEARING DATE(S): 8 October 2009
JUDGMENT DATE :
8 October 2009JURISDICTION: Equity JUDGMENT OF: Slattery J at 1 EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 8 October 2009 DECISION: ORDERS:
1. Judgment for the plaintiff against the defendants in the sum of $61,861.94.
2. Order that the defendants pay 50% of the plaintiff's costs of the proceedings.
3. Order that if a sum of no less than $42,907.29 is paid by the defendants to the plaintiff on or before 29 October 2009 pursuant to order 1, then until further order of the court:
(i) order 1 is stayed;
(ii) the plaintiff shall not register as a judgment any assessment of costs made pursuant to order 2.
4. Liberty to the parties to apply in respect of order 3 upon 72 hours' notice.CATCHWORDS: PROCEDURE - costs - recovery of costs - successful plaintiff recovers only 50% of her costs due to the premature commencment of proceedings CATEGORY: Consequential orders PARTIES: 3887/09:
4332/09:
Plaintiff/Cross-Defendant: Courtney Michelle Graham as Executor of the Estate of Jeffrey James Graham
First Defendant/ First Cross-Claimant: Janet Ann Hulme
Second Defendant/Second Cross-Claimant: Bronwyn Ann Hulme-Craig
Plaintiff: Janet Ann Hulme
Defendant: Courtney Michelle Graham as Executor of the Estate of Jeffrey James GrahamFILE NUMBER(S): SC 3887/09; 4332/09 COUNSEL: 3887/09:
4332/09:
Plaintiff/Cross-Defendant: Mr A Rogers
Defendants/Cross-Claimants: Mr J O'Connor
Plaintiff: Mr J O'Connor
Defendant: Mr A RogersSOLICITORS: 3887/09:
4332/09:
Plaintiff/Cross-Defendant: Dribbus Kovacevic Lawyers
Defendants/Cross-Claimants: Guardian Lawyers
Plaintiff: Guardian Lawyers
Defendant: Dribbus Kovacevic Lawyers
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
SLATTERY J
THURSDAY 8 OCTOBER 2009
3887/09 COURTNEY MICHELLE GRAHAM AS EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF JEFFREY JAMES GRAHAM v JANET ANN HULME AND BRONWYN ANN HULME-CRAIG
4332/09 JANET ANN HULME v COURTNEY MICHELLE GRAHAM AS EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF JEFFREY JAMES GRAHAM
JUDGMENT (Re Costs)
1 HIS HONOUR: I gave my principal judgment in this matter yesterday. There was an argument this morning about the costs of these proceedings.
2 The estate claims that it should have costs of the recovery proceedings. It has been successful in achieving a judgment in the sum of $59,510.37. Additional interest on this sum is still being calculated. There is a stay on approximately one third of that judgment.
3 Mr Rogers seeks the costs of these proceedings on behalf of the estate. Mr O'Connor resists that outcome on behalf of Janet Hulme. Mr Rogers points to the fact that the estate has been largely successful. He says that proceedings would not have had to have been brought if the accounting given to the estate on 27 August 2009 in respect of the funds transferred from the estate had been given much earlier, when it was requested.
4 He submits that the chronology of events between the death of Jeffrey Graham and July 2009 shows Janet Hulme’s solicitor failed to deal with correspondence. That correspondence asked in increasingly insistent terms for the return of or an account…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Graham v Hulme; Hulme v Graham and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NSWSC 1264
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine the appropriate proportion of costs the plaintiff could recover, considering the principle that a successful plaintiff can generally recover their full costs from the losing party. However, this principle could be subject to adjustment if the proceedings were found to have been prematurely commenced. The court considered the relevant case law and statutory provisions governing the recovery of costs in such circumstances.
The court found that the proceedings were indeed prematurely commenced in the Local Court, as they should have been brought in the Federal Circuit Court from the outset. Given this, the court held that the plaintiff was only entitled to recover half of her costs, in line with the principle that the plaintiff should not benefit from their own procedural error. The court did not find any exceptional circumstances that would warrant a departure from this principle. The court's decision was based on a balanced consideration of the legal principles involved and the facts of the case.
The final orders of the court were that the plaintiff was to recover only 50% of her costs from the defendant, reflecting the premature commencement of the proceedings. This outcome ensured that the plaintiff did not gain an unfair advantage from their procedural misstep, while also providing some measure of recovery for their successful litigation.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.