Graham and Australian Fisheries Management Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 862

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No V01/388

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      RODGER GRAHAM          
  Applicant
           And    AUSTRALIAN FISHERIES MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY   
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Mr J. Handley, Senior Member Mr C. Ermert, Member           

Date27 September 2002

PlaceMelbourne

Decision      The decision under review is set aside and the application remitted to the respondent for reconsideration in accordance with these reasons.
  .........Sgd. Mr J. Handley..................
  Senior Member
CATCHWORDS
FISHERIES : Respondent introduced Individual Transferable Quotas & Total Allowable Catch in to the Southern Shark Fishery - ITQ's based on best 3 years of catch between 1994 & 1997 - changed management arrangements - whether differential economic impacts on concession holders were minimised - whether permits were, in reality and in practice, transferable - whether relative economic position of concession holders affected - whether policy unjust - applicant did not fish for shark after 1990 - severe hip injury - applicant fished for cray only - nil quota allocated - whether exceptional circumstances - whether correct or preferable to set aside decision under review - application remitted to respondent with recommendations.
Fisheries Management Act 1991
Re Fischer and Australian Fisheries Management Authority
Re Drake and the Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No. 2) 1982 ALD 634
Re O'May and Anor. and AFMA 1999 AATA 720
Re Glendon Lane Pty Ltd and AFMA 1995 36 ALD 376
Re Secretary, Department of Family & Community Services and Selke 1993 18 AAR 457
Re Secretary, Department of Social Security and Tran 1991 13 AAR 346

REASONS FOR DECISION

27 September 2002           Mr J. Handley, Senior Member  Mr C. Ermert, Member  

  1. The applicant applies to review a decision made by a delegate of the Australian Fisheries Management Authority ("AFMA") made on 14 March 2001. The delegate then reviewed a decision previously made by an officer pursuant to s.32 of the Fisheries Management Act 1991 ("the Act").

  2. The primary decision (T-33) was made in the form of a letter forwarded to Mr Graham on 19 December 2000.  The first paragraph of the letter records-

    "This attachment shows the trunked weight of school shark and gummy shark allowed to be taken under the authorisation of your fishing permit subject to the conditions on that permit". 

  1. The attachment to that letter is identified as permit number 300214D with respect to the 2001 season.  The kilogram quota for school and gummy shark under the permit is recorded (with respect to both species) as "0".  Apparently that decision was made because Mr Graham was unable to demonstrate a catch history of school or gummy shark within the period 1 January 1994 and 31 December 1997.  (T-32).  The absence of a catch history was not disputed by Mr Graham.  His application for a quota was made upon the basis of "exceptional circumstances" (T-31).

  2. The circumstances giving rise to this review are virtually identical to those that existed with respect to another application heard simultaneously namely Re Fischer and Australian Fisheries Management Authority (V2001/387).…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Graham and Australian Fisheries Management Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 862
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case between Graham and the Australian Fisheries Management Authority (AFMA), the applicant, Mr Graham, contested the allocation of a nil quota for the Southern Shark Fishery by AFMA. The introduction of Individual Transferable Quotas (ITQs) and a Total Allowable Catch (TAC) in the Southern Shark Fishery, based on the best three years of catch between 1994 and 1997, led to Mr Graham's allocation of a nil quota as he did not fish for shark after 1990 due to a severe hip injury and instead focused on cray fishing. The central issues were whether the differential economic impacts on concession holders were minimised, whether permits were truly transferable, and whether the policy was unjust. Additionally, it was examined whether there were exceptional circumstances to warrant a different treatment for Mr Graham and if it was appropriate to set aside the decision under review.

The tribunal found that the circumstances leading to the allocation of a nil quota to Mr Graham were similar to those in a previous case, Fischer v AFMA. The tribunal preferred the evidence of Mr Collins, who highlighted the value of a permit, including its capital value and the income stream it could generate. The tribunal concluded that the fishery had transferable permits prior to 1 January 2001, making the imposition of ITQs based on catch history flawed. Mr Graham maintained his shark licence as an asset intended for transfer to his sons, but he did not understand that failing to use it would result in its loss. The tribunal concluded that Mr Graham's economic position had worsened due to the loss of an asset that could have provided him with income or transfer opportunities.

The tribunal decided to remit the case back to AFMA with recommendations, considering the findings and the impact of the policy on concession holders. The tribunal emphasised the importance of considering the relative economic positions of concession holders and the practical implications of permit transferability. The decision underscored the need for AFMA to address the concerns raised and to reconsider the allocation of quotas in light of the tribunal's findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Between 1994 and 1997 Mr Graham was engaged in the Tasmanian Cray Fishery where his catch returns showed fishing activity between January and August and between November and December for each year. Apparently the fishery was closed between September and October. Mr Graham said that he operated on the West Coast of Tasmania, out of King Island, using the vessel "Saint Bernadette". He said that was a vessel being 53 feet in length which had a wheel house in which he could sit to steer the vessel. He had a crew of one person. Mr Graham said he did not "explore the option" of hiring a skipper which would have permitted him to continue to be engaged in shark fishing. He said there were no persons in Portland who were qualified and it was not an option to engage a person from another district because that person would not be familiar with the waters between Portland and Apollo Bay where principally he fished for shark. It follows that his principle income in the 1990's was from cray fishing.Conclusion & Reasons For Decision As we recorded at the outset, the circumstances giving rise to the allocation of nil quota to Mr Graham are identical to those that applied to Mr Fischer. That is to say, there was a change in the management structure of the Southern Shark Fishery where by reference to catch history of the best 3 of 4 years between 1994 and 1997 AFMA decided to introduce Individual Transferable Quotas ("ITQs") against an imposed Total Allowable Catch ("TAC") for the Southern Shark Fishery. By reason of Mr Graham not being engaged in shark fishing during the above period he could not demonstrate any shark catch at all. Mr Collins who gave evidence in the Fischer application spoke at length of the value, which exists in a permit, which is not being exercised. He held this opinion because a permit creates the opportunity to fish which in turn creates a stream of income. Additionally, the permit has a capital value which is capable of being realised. In the Fischer application we decided that we preferred the evidence of Mr Collins and we found that the fishery should be regarded as having transferable permits prior to 1 January 2001. It followed that the imposition of ITQs based on catch history was a flawed decision. In the present application Mr Graham told us that he continued to hold his shark licence, despite not being able to exploit it, because it was an asset that he eventually wanted to transfer to his sons who expressed interest in becoming fishermen. Additionally, he never had any understanding that the failure to use his shark permit would cause him to lose it which necessarily has occurred by reason of the changed management structure concerning the SSF. Indeed Mr Graham said that the permit was regarded by him as an asset which he understood that he would be able to keep "forever". Clearly the relative economic position of Mr Graham is considerably worse subsequent to 1 January 2001 than it was previously because if the decision under review is allowed to stand, Mr Graham has in fact lost an asset which denies him a stream of income should he wish to exploit it or denies him the opportunity to sell it or to transfer it to his children.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established