ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
GRACIE v THE OWNERS UNITS PLAN 3411 & ORS (Unit Titles) [2016] ACAT 3
UT 15/29
Catchwords: UNIT TITLES – annual general meeting – merits review – conflict of interest – whether an administrator should be appointed – whether there should be an administrative split between stage 1 and stage 2 of the development
Legislation cited: Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (ACT) ss 22, 46, 50, 129, 136, 138, 140, 141, sch 1, sch 4
Unit Titles Act 1970 (ACT) s 92
Construction Occupations (Licensing) Act 2004 (ACT) ss 38, 46, 118
Corporations Act 2001(Cth) s 191, 232
Cases cited:Filaria Pty Ltd v Proprietors of Unit Plan 932 [2000] ACTSC 8
Lubransky v Owners Corporation No 1 PS519798G (Owners Corporations) [2014] VCAT 1301
McKinnon v Adams [2003] VSC 116
Owners Corporation 1 Plan No. PS440878V & Ors v Dual Homes Victoria Pty Ltd (Owners Corporation) [2011] VCAT 211
Peters’ American Delicacy Co Ltd v Heath (1939) 61 CLR 457
Re Steele and the Conveyancing (Strata Titles) Act 1961 [1968] 2 NSWR 796
List of
Texts/Papers cited: ARITA Code of Professional Practice (3rd edition)
Concise Australian Law Dictionary (4th edition, 2011)
Austin, R P and I M Ramsay Ford, Austin and Ramsay’s Principles of Corporations Law (16th edition, 2015)
Murray, Michael and Jason Harris, Keay’s Insolvency: Personal and Corporate Law and Practice (2011)
Tribunal: Senior Member R Orr, QC
Date of Orders: 19 January 2016
Date of Reasons for Decision: 19 January 2016
ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL UT 15/29
| MARGARET GRACIE Applicant | THE OWNERS UNITS PLAN 3411 |
| STATEHAY PTY LTD | BENJAMIN HALL |
| PAUL WILSON | ANN SULLIVAN Party Joined 4 |
| EMMA GREENWOOD | PETER STRASCHKO |
| THET H. NAING | BI ZHILONG Party Joined 8 |
| KATY GHASSEMI Party Joined 9 | LIAM MURPHY |
| CHRISTINE YOUNG | CAITLIN O’CONNOR Party Joined 12 |
| SARA WEDGWOOD Party Joined 13 | SYLVIA SAMPSON |
| RUPSA NEOGY KUMAR | KEVIN CHOW |
| CHUNG-LINH CHAU |
TRIBUNAL: Senior Member R Orr, QC
DATE: 19 January 2016
ORDER
The Tribunal orders:
Under section 129(1)(g) of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (ACT) (the UTM Act), that motion 3 at the annual general meeting of the owners corporation for Units Plan 3411 (UP 3411) on 20 May 2015 be given effect so that ‘the level of insurance be increased upon renewal to the figure as suggested by the insurer’.
Under section 129(1)(a) of the UTM Act, that Statehay Pty Ltd (Statehay), and its representatives, including Ms J Domazet:
(a)abstain from voting at any meeting of the owners corporation or executive committee for UP 3411 on any matter concerning the alleged building defects relating to stage 1 of UP 3411 (known as Lakeside); and
(b)not take part in and be quarantined from any involvement in the owners corporation or executive committee deliberations concerning the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Gracie v The Owners Units Plan 3411 and Ors (Unit Titles) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] ACAT 3
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether certain resolutions passed at the annual general meeting of UP 3411 on 20 May 2015 were valid and should be given effect. Additionally, the court was required to determine whether an administrator should be appointed for the owners corporation for UP 3411.
The court found that several resolutions passed at the annual general meeting were invalid due to conflicts of interest, procedural irregularities, or because they contravened the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (ACT). The court held that Ms Gracie was entitled to have certain resolutions amended or repealed and that Statehay and its representatives should abstain from voting or involvement in certain matters. The court also found that the appointment of an administrator was not necessary.
The court made orders that certain resolutions passed at the annual general meeting be given effect, that Statehay and its representatives should abstain from voting and involvement in certain matters, that certain members be elected to the executive committee, that City Strata Management Pty Ltd be appointed as strata manager for UP 3411, and that the appointment of an administrator be dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Under section 129(1)(g) of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (ACT) (the UTM Act), that motion 3 at the annual general meeting of the owners corporation for Units Plan 3411 (UP 3411) on 20 May 2015 be given effect so that ‘the level of insurance be increased upon renewal to the figure as suggested by the insurer’.
2. Under section 129(1)(a) of the UTM Act, that Statehay Pty Ltd (Statehay), and its representatives, including Ms J Domazet:
(a) abstain from voting at any meeting of the owners corporation or executive committee for UP 3411 on any matter concerning the alleged building defects relating to stage 1 of UP 3411 (known as Lakeside); and
(b) not take part in and be quarantined from any involvement in the owners corporation or executive committee deliberations concerning the identification or rectification of the alleged building defects relating to stage 1;
except to the extent that Statehay as an owner of units in stage 2 of UP 3411 (known as Central Park) is sought to be required to contribute to any fund to be raised by the owners corporation in relation to the identification or rectification of alleged building defects in stage 1.
3. Under section 129(1)(g) of the UTM Act, that the resolutions for the election of members of the executive committee for UP 3411 at the annual general meeting of the owners corporation on 20 May 2015 be given effect so that Ms E Greenwood, Ms M Gracie and Ms R Neogy-Kumar are also elected to the executive committee.
4. Under section 129(1)(a) of the UTM Act, that Statehay and its representatives including Ms J Domazet are not to prevent the election of up to seven members of the executive committee at any general meeting of UP 3411.
5. Under section 129(1)(f) and (g) of the UTM Act, that:
(a) in relation to motion 8 at the annual general meeting of the owners corporation for UP 3411 on 20 May 2015, City Strata Management Pty Ltd be appointed as strata manager of UP 3411 for 2015 and 2016, in accordance with the same terms and conditions as were set out in the original short term contract, or as otherwise agreed; and
(b) in relation to motion 11 concerning quotes for a strata manager, this resolution is repealed.
6. Under section 129(1)(a), (f) and (2) of the UTM Act, that in relation to motion 12 at the annual general meeting of the owners corporation for UP 3411 on 20 May 2015 concerning the review of contracts:
(a) this motion is amended to provide that Ms J Domazet, on behalf of the executive committee, may review maintenance and service contracts to the extent that they relate to services provided to stage 2 of UP 3411 (known as Central Park), which contracts could be put to a vote at a general meeting; and
(b) Statehay and its representatives, including Ms J Domazet, abstain from voting on any motion at a general meeting that relates to reviewing, negotiating, entering into or implementing maintenance and service contracts to the extent that they relate to services provided to stage 1 of UP 4311.
7. Under section 129(1)(e)(ii) of the UTM Act, that motion 13 at the annual general meeting of the owners corporation of UP 3411 on 20 May 2015 (which was that the executive committee is directed to approve an application by Statehay for the use of common property, being for the construction of a storage room within the rubbish area) is void for irregularity.
8. The application for the appointment of an administrator is dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi