Goulding v Simonds Homes Victoria Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Goulding v Simonds Homes Victoria Pty Ltd (No 2) [2021] FCCA 1499

File number(s): MLG 1941 of 2018
Judgment of: JUDGE MCNAB
Date of judgment: 2 July 2021
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – whether the applicant was an employee of the respondent – applicant found to be a contractor – tripartite arrangement – application dismissed.
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 40, 44, 90, 117, 119, 323, 545, 546, 547.

Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth).

Cases cited:

Barro Group Pty Ltd v Fraser [1985] VR 577

Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd [2020] FCAFC 122

Eastern Van Services Pty Ltd v Victorian WorkCover Authority [2020] 296 IR 391

Goulding v Simonds Homes Victoria Pty Ltd [2020] FCCA 2457

Jamsek v ZG Operations Australia Pty Ltd [2020] FCAFC 119

Number of paragraphs: 119
Date of last submission/s: 22 February 2021
Date of hearing: 22 – 24 February 2021
Place: Melbourne
Counsel for the Applicant: Dr M Wolff
Solicitor for the Applicant: Adams Maguire Sier
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr N Harrington
Solicitor for the Respondent: Minter Ellison

ORDERS

MLG 1941 of 2018
BETWEEN:

JOHN GOULDING

Applicant

AND:

SIMONDS HOMES VICTORIA PTY LTD

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE MCNAB

DATE OF ORDER:

2 JULY 2021

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application filed on 5 July 2018, and amended on 18 March 2019, be dismissed.

2.Any application by the Respondent for costs be filed within 14 days of the date of these orders and be supported by submissions limited to two (2) A4 pages.

3.Any submissions in response to any application for costs be filed within 28 days of the date of these orders and be limited to two (2) A4 pages.

4.The questions of costs be determined on the papers.

5.These reasons for Judgment, and the transcript of the Applicant’s oral evidence given during the hearing on 22 February 2021, be referred to the Attorney-General’s Department (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Judge McNab:

INTRODUCTION

  1. This matter originated by way of an application and statement of claim filed on 5 July 2018 and amended on 18 March 2019. By that amended statement of claim (“the ASOC”) the Applicant claims that the Respondent:

    (1)breached the Applicant’s employment contract; and

    (2)breached the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (“the FW Act”) by:

    (a)failing to pay the Applicant in accordance with the remuneration term under the said contract, pursuant to s323(1);

    (b)failing to provide four weeks’ written notice of termination, or pay in lieu thereof, pursuant to s117;

    (c)failing to pay the Applicant eight weeks’ redundancy pay pursuant to s119; and

    (d)failing to pay to the Applicant accrued untaken leave upon termination his employment, pursuant to s90(2) and s44.

  2. The matter came before the Court for final hearing on 22 February 2021, and was heard across three days. Judgment was reserved at the conclusion of the final hearing.

  3. For the reasons that follow, I find that at all times the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Goulding v Simonds Homes Victoria Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCCA 1499
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

McNab J of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia considered a dispute between Mr. Goulding (the Applicant) and Simonds Homes Victoria Pty Ltd (the Respondent). The Applicant claimed to have been an employee of the Respondent and sought various entitlements, including accrued annual leave, unpaid wages, a motor vehicle allowance, and amounts under a profit share clause, or alternatively, damages and compensation for breaches of the *Fair Work Act 2009* (Cth) concerning notice and redundancy pay. The Respondent denied employing the Applicant, asserting that the Applicant was initially engaged through Tomanic Pty Ltd and subsequently through Jingo Pty Ltd, both corporate entities associated with the Applicant, which provided services to the Respondent.

The central legal issue before the Court was to determine whether the Applicant was an employee of the Respondent, either by express or implied agreement, or an independent contractor supplied to the Respondent through Tomanic and Jingo. This determination was crucial for establishing the Respondent's obligations under employment law. The Applicant argued that despite the contractual arrangements involving corporate entities, he was in substance a managerial employee whose role and working conditions were dictated by the Respondent, rendering the payment and invoicing arrangements irrelevant to his employment status. The Respondent contended that it engaged the corporate entities to provide personnel, and that payments, including GST, were made to these entities for the Applicant's services, not directly to the Applicant.

McNab J found Mr. Elliot, a former Operational Manager for a related company, to be a compelling witness whose evidence was clear and appropriately qualified. The Court considered the Applicant's submission that the invoicing and GST arrangements were a matter of convenience and did not reflect the true nature of his relationship with the Respondent. However, the Court ultimately concluded that the Applicant's claims failed. The Applicant's failure to remit GST and income tax over an extended period, despite having knowledge of his obligations, was noted as significant.

Consequently, the application filed by the Applicant was dismissed. The Court indicated it would make orders for submissions regarding costs and would refer a copy of the decision, along with a transcript of the Applicant's oral evidence, to the appropriate authorities for further action concerning the tax matters.

Background

Background to the litigation

A central feature of the arrangements in this matter is that the corporate entities, as nominated by the Applicant, were the contracting party who rendered invoices to the Respondent (with GST included) and the evidence shows that neither the corporate entities, nor the Applicant, remitted GST to the Australian Tax Office. It appears that neither the corporate entities or the Applicant have paid tax on the revenue received from the Respondent, and the Applicant has not paid income tax for a significant period of time, certainly from April 2006 to August 2012. This is notwithstanding that the Applicant was using funds received from the Respondent into accounts held by the corporate entities for personal expenditure, and was receiving the benefit of payments of $300,000 per annum, plus other benefits, as at August 2012.BACKGROUND This matter’s progress before the Court is helpfully summarised in the interim decision of his Honour Judge Riethmuller delivered on 2 September 2020: see Goulding v Simonds Homes Victoria Pty Ltd [2020] FCCA 2457 (“the interlocutory decision”). These reasons should be read in conjunction with those reasons, to the extent that Judge Riethmuller’s decision informs this Judgment. Judge Reithmuller’s decision was concerned with the question of whether the originating application was statute barred in circumstances where the Applicant’s engagement with the Respondent, whether as an employee or as a contractor, was terminated on 20 August 2012 and the application was filed on 5 July 2018. As set out in the interlocutory decision at [10] – [11], and as set out below, during the course of the period in which the Applicant was engaged by the Respondent, the Applicant alleges that he was employed directly by the Respondent, and therefore the Respondent was subject to the provisions of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth), and subsequently the FW Act when it came into effect. On that basis, the Applicant claims that he is entitled to:(1)accrued annual leave upon termination of his employment (which he calculates at 49.7 days); (2)Damages consequent upon termination of his employment of around $300,000 for unpaid wages; as well as a motor vehicle allowance and amounts under a profit share clause; or alternatively (3)damages and compensation for breaches of the FW Act with respect to the minimum period of notice of termination and redundancy pay. The Respondent claims that it never employed the Applicant. Instead, the Respondent claims that the Applicant was initially employed by Tomanic Pty Ltd (“Tomanic”), a corporate entity associated with the Applicant, and that from July 2007, the Applicant was employed by Jingo Pty Ltd (“Jingo”), a different corporate entity associated with the Applicant. The Respondent claims that they instead engaged Tomanic, and later Jingo, to provide services including the provision of personnel to undertake the required work. The Respondent claims that it never paid the Applicant directly, as invoices were rendered by Tomanic and Jingo to the Respondent, and subsequently the amounts owed were paid to those entities (including GST), for the Applicant’s services.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The following people gave evidence on behalf of the Respondent:(1)Mr Mahoney, relying on his affidavits filed on 4 March 2020 and 12 May 2020;(2)Mr Christopher Burkitt, former General Manager/National Operations Manager/National Training Manager for the Respondent, relying on his affidavit filed on 4 March 2020; and(3)Mr Geoffrey Elliot, former Operational Manager of the Madisson Projects business, relying on his affidavit filed on 4 March 2020.The Applicant’s Evidence In relation to the initial commercial arrangement between the Applicant and Madisson Homes (“Madisson”) (a company recently acquired by the Respondent), the Applicant deposes in his affidavit filed on 23 January 2020 that:(1)he contacted Mr Harman in early 2006 about work opportunities, and met with Mr Harman on or about 10 March 2006. After some further correspondence in March 2006, the Applicant deposes at [10] that Mr Harman informed over the phone that the Respondent had a role available for a cost planner/estimator, and arranged for the Applicant to be introduced to Mr Elliot;(2)in late March 2006; he met with and spoke to Mr Elliot, who informed him that the Applicant could not be guaranteed a permanent role and that he could initially engage him as a contractor, but that the role could not be confirmed as permanently on-going. The Applicant also deposes at [14] – [16] to Mr Elliot asking whether he had an ABN for Tomanic and explained that the Applicant would be required to invoice Madisson. Mr Elliot asked for that ABN and the Applicant provided it to him;(3)on 5 April 2006, Ms Kelly Cutajar, Human Resources Officer of Simonds Homes, wrote to him enclosing a copy of a contract, and requesting that the Applicant return the contract signed, provide bank details and also obtain work cover insurance (which the Applicant did not do). The Applicant states that the role was a 9.00am to 5.00pm role, he was required to attend the offices on time and that he was provided with a desk and computer, as well as having access to the other resources of the office. The Applicant says that he was reimbursed for travel to meetings for which he was required to use his own vehicle, but at other times used a company pool car that was provided to him. The Applicant claims he was paid for annual leave and public holidays without loss of pay. The Applicant states at [29] of his affidavit that on 4 April 2007, a new contract was issued by Madisson to him for the work that he was doing. He says that after entering that new contract, his role expanded, and Mr Elliot suggested the state to “generate a business development role for the company whilst continuing with cost planning and estimating.” He says that in or around June 2007, his role expanded and:31. […] became a much broader role and developed into a sales, marketing, administration, business development and project management, planning and estimating role. I went from working a 9am to 5pm role providing cost planning and estimates, into a more senior role with greater responsibility and meeting clients after hours.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For these reasons, all of the Applicant’s claims fail and the application is dismissed. I will make orders for the parties to make submissions in relation to costs. I note that the failure to remit tax in this case is significant, occurred over an extended period of time and was carried out by an Applicant with knowledge of his tax obligations. I will refer a copy of this decision, together with a transcript of the oral evidence of the Applicant given at the final hearing, to the appropriate authorities to deal with the matter.CONCLUSION For these reasons, the application filed on 5 July 2018 and amended on 18 March 2019 is dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Elliot gave evidence on the third day of the final hearing via Microsoft Teams, with the consent of both parties. In my view, Mr Elliot was a compelling witness. He gave clear evidence of the matters that he had knowledge of in relation to these proceedings. He made appropriate concessions and did not attempt to give evidence on matters that he had no actual knowledge of or that he had no memory of.CONSIDERATION The primary question at issue in this matter is whether the Applicant was an employee of the Respondent by way of an express or implied employment agreement or was instead an independent contractor retained by Tomanic, and later Jingo, and was supplied as such to the Respondent in a tripartite arrangement. In submissions filed on 1 February 2021, the Applicant submits at [2] that he was employed by the Respondent through a series of written employment contracts between 5 April 2006 and 20 August 2012, as set out above. The Applicant submits at [8] – [9] that he never had a contractual relationship with Jingo, and that “Jingo was for all practical purposes in effect an alter ego for the Applicant”, as the Applicant never received any payment from Jingo, save the amounts paid by the Respondent into a joint bank account for him and his de facto partner, Ms Lupieri (who was Jingo’s Director and sole shareholder). In relation to the written contracts between the parties, the Applicant submits at [15] – [16] that: 15. The Applicant’s evidence will be that he considered it himself for all practical purposes a managerial employee, irrespective of the payment arrangements which he considered “a secretarial matter.”16. Moreover, it will be the Applicant’s evidence that his view on the written contracts was for practical purposes irrelevant. The Respondent had the power to choose whatever form of contract they wished the Applicant to enter into. They at all times had the power to alter any work arrangements at will. They evidenced that power by frequently altering the roles and positions for the Applicant, and indeed by altering any aspect of the working arrangement that they wishes to change. Therefore, if they wishes the Applicant to enter into contract A, he would do so; and if they wishes for him to enter into contract B, he would do that. The Applicant reserved his bargaining power for questions about his remuneration. By contrast he had no desire to risk losing his job in an argument over the legalistic details of his work arrangement. The Applicant submits that, in relation to billing arrangements, including invoices and GST, the fact Jingo rendered invoices for the Applicant’s services and that GST was paid on those invoices, has no bearing on the question of whether the Applicant was an employee or a contractor as “this was simply a practice agreed upon years ago for various reasons”: see Applicant’s submissions at [11] – [12]. The Applicant submits at [13] that the fact he has not filed tax returns for the relevant years is because he needs the outcome these proceedings to be finalised so that he can know with certainty whether he should file his returns as an employee or contractor.