Gottlob v Tiger Airways Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)

GOTTLOB v TIGER AIRWAYS PTY LTD

[2011] SASC 36

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Anderson

22 March 2011

MAGISTRATES - APPEALS AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT

MAGISTRATES - JURISDICTION AND PROCEDURE GENERALLY - PROCEDURE - ORDERS AND CONVICTIONS - SENTENCING - IMPOSITION OF FINES

Appeal from decision of a magistrate - respondent airline pleaded guilty and was convicted of a breach of curfew contrary to s 6(1) of the Adelaide Airport Curfew Act 2000 (Cth) - the magistrate imposed a $5,000 fine on respondent - appeal to Supreme Court by the Commonwealth against quantum of fine imposed - whether the magistrate erred in categorising the offence as at the "lower end of the scale" - whether the fine imposed was manifestly inadequate.

Held: Magistrate erred in categorising offending at the lower end of the scale - fine imposed by magistrate inadequate and does not reflect seriousness of the breach - appeal against quantum of fine allowed - $21,250 fine imposed.

Adelaide Airport Curfew Act 2000 (Cth) s 6, referred to.
Commonwealth Department of Transport and Regional Services v Lauda-Air 2002, unreported, New South Wales Local Court, distinguished.
Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government v Jetstar Airways Pty Ltd 2009, unreported, New South Wales Local Court, discussed.
Scroi (1989) 40 A Crim R 197; R v Ozenkowski (1982) 30 SASR 212; Everett v R (1994) 181 CLR 295; Police v Cadd (1997) 69 SASR 150; Commissioner of Taxation v Doudle [2005] SASC 442, considered.

GOTTLOB v TIGER AIRWAYS PTY LTD
[2011] SASC 36

Magistrates Appeal:  Civil

ANDERSON J.

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal by Roger Leonard Gottlob, of the Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government, from a decision of a magistrate delivered on 10 December 2010. The magistrate convicted the respondent airline of a breach of curfew contrary to s 6(1) Adelaide Airport Curfew Act 2000 (Cth) (the Curfew Act). The respondent pleaded guilty to the offence and was fined $5,000. The appeal is against the quantum of the fine imposed on the respondent. The appellant claims that the fine imposed is manifestly inadequate. The maximum penalty for the offence is $110,00 for a body corporate.

    Background

  2. An agreed summary of facts was provided to the magistrate. The respondent, Tiger Airways Pty Ltd, was the operator of an aircraft scheduled to depart Adelaide Airport on a flight to Perth at 10.15 pm on 30 August 2010.

  3. Section 6(1) of the Curfew Act prohibits aircraft from taking off from Adelaide Airport during the curfew period, being between the hours of 11.00 pm and 6.00 am. There is an exception to this prohibition where an aircraft operator is granted a dispensation permitting the operator to take off during the curfew period. See s 6(2) of the Curfew Act.

  4. Section 6 of the Curfew Act states:

    6 Prohibition on taking off or landing during curfew periods

    (1)The operator of an aircraft…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gottlob v Tiger Airways Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] SASC 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Gottlob v Tiger Airways Pty Ltd involves a conviction of Tiger Airways Pty Ltd by a magistrate for breaching the curfew at Adelaide Airport, contrary to section 6(1) of the Adelaide Airport Curfew Act 2000. Tiger Airways had pleaded guilty to the offence and was fined $5,000. The Commonwealth appealed against the quantum of the fine imposed, contending that it was manifestly inadequate. The appeal was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the magistrate erred in categorising the offence as being at the lower end of the scale and whether the $5,000 fine imposed was manifestly inadequate. The court considered the principles of sentencing and the importance of maintaining adequate sentencing standards, ensuring consistency, and correcting any manifest inadequacy, particularly in relation to general deterrence. The court also had to determine whether the fine imposed by the magistrate adequately reflected the seriousness of the breach.

In allowing the appeal, the Supreme Court found that the magistrate had erred in categorising the offence as being at the lower end of the scale. The court held that a $5,000 fine did not adequately reflect the seriousness of the breach. The court concluded that the offence warranted a fine of more than 5% of the maximum penalty, amounting to $25,000. After reducing this amount by 15% for the guilty plea, the court imposed a fine of $21,250 on the respondent. The court thus allowed the appeal against the quantum of the fine imposed by the magistrate.

The final order of the court was that the appeal against the quantum of the fine was allowed, and a fine of $21,250 was imposed on Tiger Airways Pty Ltd. The court also directed that the parties be heard as to the costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal by Roger Leonard Gottlob, of the Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government, from a decision of a magistrate delivered on 10 December 2010. The magistrate convicted the respondent airline of a breach of curfew contrary to s 6(1) Adelaide Airport Curfew Act 2000 (Cth) (the Curfew Act). The respondent pleaded guilty to the offence and was fined $5,000. The appeal is against the quantum of the fine imposed on the respondent. The appellant claims that the fine imposed is manifestly inadequate. The maximum penalty for the offence is $110,00 for a body corporate.Background An agreed summary of facts was provided to the magistrate. The respondent, Tiger Airways Pty Ltd, was the operator of an aircraft scheduled to depart Adelaide Airport on a flight to Perth at 10.15 pm on 30 August 2010. Section 6(1) of the Curfew Act prohibits aircraft from taking off from Adelaide Airport during the curfew period, being between the hours of 11.00 pm and 6.00 am. There is an exception to this prohibition where an aircraft operator is granted a dispensation permitting the operator to take off during the curfew period. See s 6(2) of the Curfew Act. Section 6 of the Curfew Act states:6 Prohibition on taking off or landing during curfew periods(1)The operator of an aircraft commits an offence if:(a) the operator engages in conduct; and(b) the conduct results in an aircraft taking off or landing at Adelaide Airport during a curfew period.Penalty: 200 penalty units.(2)Subsection (1) does not apply if the take off or landing is permitted under Part 3.Note:A defendant bears an evidential burden in relation to the matter in subsection (2) (see subsection 13.3(3) of the Criminal Code).(3)In this section:engage in conduct means:(a) do an act; or(b) omit to perform an act. In this matter the respondent sought and was granted two consecutive dispensation orders on the night in question in accordance with Part 3 of the Curfew Act. The first dispensation was requested after a hydraulic leak was discovered in the aircraft designated to undertake the subject flight. The respondent sought and obtained a replacement aircraft, resulting in delay to the departure time. The dispensation was granted extending the time for departure to 11.10 pm. The second dispensation was requested by the respondent after it became apparent there would be a delay in refuelling the replacement aircraft. The second dispensation was granted to 11.20 pm. The issue in this matter centres on the respondent’s third request for dispensation. At or about 11.12 pm it became apparent to the respondent that refuelling would not be completed by the 11.20 pm deadline. At this time all passengers had boarded the aircraft. The respondent sought a third dispensation to accommodate the additional delay but that request was denied. The captain of the aircraft was advised on a number of occasions, including by Adelaide Air Traffic Control, that no dispensation extension applied after 11.20 pm. In the summary of facts before the magistrate, the parties agreed that at or about 11.30 pm, the captain rang Air Traffic Control and asked if they would allow the aircraft to depart. The air traffic controller advised the captain that no additional dispensation had been granted beyond 11.20 pm, but confirmed that Air Traffic Control could not stop the aircraft departing. The captain advised that the relevant representative of the respondent would “sort out” the situation in the morning. The captain sought clearance to depart almost immediately and clearance to depart was granted by Air Traffic Control.

Decision

Reasons for decision

ANDERSON J
I am of the view that the magistrate did not properly consider the aspect of general deterrence in his assessment of the seriousness of the offence. It is a small price to pay, that is $5,000, for a deliberate breach of the curfew purely for reasons associated with the convenience and commercial advantage of the airline. It does not adequately bring home to the corporate offender the seriousness of the offence.Conclusion This is the first prosecution for this offence in South Australia since the legislation was enacted in 2000. General deterrence is nevertheless important. In my view the offending was more akin to the offending referred to in the Jetstar decision than that in the Lauda Air decision. In my view the offending in Lauda Air was clearly at the lower end of the scale. I do not consider this offending was of that order. I consider it more serious. It warranted a fine of more than about 5% of the maximum. It is not at the higher end of the scale of seriousness but a fine of $5,000 does not reflect the seriousness of the breach. I disagree with the magistrate that it is an offence at the lower end of the scale. In my view the appropriate fine for this offending is $25,000. I will then reduce that by 15% for the guilty plea, making the fine payable by the respondent $21,250. I therefore allow the appeal. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: ANDERSON J

Finally, Ms Fuller submitted that this is not an appropriate case for setting a sentencing standard for this type of offence.Consideration In my view the issue comes down to whether, despite all the mitigating factors, the fine imposed is so far out of a reasonable range for penalty that this court is justified in interfering. The principles relating to Crown appeals against sentence must be considered. Those principles permit allowing appeals for the purpose of maintaining adequate sentencing standards, ensuring consistency in those standards or to correct any manifest inadequacy. It is really only the last of those principles which is relevant here. See R v Osenkowski (1982) 30 SASR 212 and Everett v R (1994) 181 CLR 295. It seems to me that a $5,000 fine for breach of curfew, by a deliberate act by the respondent to ignore the Commonwealth authority is a very minimum penalty. I accept what Ms Fuller submits as to specific deterrence and I would not interfere on that account. In relation to general deterrence Ms Fuller puts it that, because of the peculiar facts of this matter, any penalty is not really going to be looked at from the point of view of a general deterrence to others. I do not agree. I think it is important to indicate that a flagrant breach, albeit with some deficiencies in the airline’s communication systems, including its operation manuals, is a serious breach. I am of the view that the magistrate did not properly consider the aspect of general deterrence in his assessment of the seriousness of the offence. It is a small price to pay, that is $5,000, for a deliberate breach of the curfew purely for reasons associated with the convenience and commercial advantage of the airline. It does not adequately bring home to the corporate offender the seriousness of the offence.Conclusion This is the first prosecution for this offence in South Australia since the legislation was enacted in 2000. General deterrence is nevertheless important. In my view the offending was more akin to the offending referred to in the Jetstar decision than that in the Lauda Air decision. In my view the offending in Lauda Air was clearly at the lower end of the scale. I do not consider this offending was of that order. I consider it more serious. It warranted a fine of more than about 5% of the maximum. It is not at the higher end of the scale of seriousness but a fine of $5,000 does not reflect the seriousness of the breach. I disagree with the magistrate that it is an offence at the lower end of the scale. In my view the appropriate fine for this offending is $25,000. I will then reduce that by 15% for the guilty plea, making the fine payable by the respondent $21,250. I therefore allow the appeal. I will hear the parties as to costs.