Gothe-Snape; Chief Executive Officer, Services Australia and

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

Gothe-Snape; Chief Executive Officer, Services Australia and [2021] AATA 2710 (4 August 2021)

Division:FREEDOM OF INFORMATION DIVISION

File Number:          2020/3899

Re:Chief Executive Officer, Services Australia

APPLICANT

AndJackson Gothe-Snape

RESPONDENT

Appeal from:         [2020] AICmr 19

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Boyle

Date:4 August 2021

Place:Perth

The decision of the Australian Information Commissioner in Jackson Gothe-Snape and Services Australia (Freedom of Information) [2020] AICmr 19 (1 June 2020) is varied to find that the Document is exempt under s 34(1)(c) of the FOI Act.

...[SGD].....................................................................

Deputy President Boyle

CATCHWORDS

FREEDOM OF INFORMATION – review of a decision of the Australian Information Commissioner – Cabinet confidentiality – whether exemption under s 34 of the FOI Act applies – request for material regarding the implementation of Taskforce Integrity –conditional exemption under s 47C of the FOI Act – document was brought into existence for the dominant purpose of briefing a Minister on a document to be submitted to Cabinet – document exempt under s 34(1)(c) – information in the document is not purely factual material – exception to the exemption under s 34(6) does not apply – reviewable decision varied

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) – ss 37, 35(4), 43, 43(1)(b), 43(1)(c)

Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth) – ss 4(1), 8A, 11, 11A(5), 11A(6), 22(1)(a)(ii), 24AB, 34, 34(1)(a), 34(1)(c), 34(3), 34(6), 47C, 47C(1), 55K, 57A(1), 93A

CASES

Commonwealth v Northern Land Council (1993) 176 CLR 604

Dreyfus and Secretary, Attorney-General’s Department [2015] AATA 962

Fisse and Secretary, Department of the Treasury (2008) 48 AAR 131; [2008] AATA 288

Jackson Gothe-Snape and Services Australia (Freedom of Information) [2020] AICmr 19

Lanyon v Commonwealth (1974) 129 CLR 650

Sankey v Whitlam (1978) 142 CLR 1

Toomer and Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry (2003) 78 ALD 645; [2003] AATA 1301

Whitlam v Australian Consolidated Press (1985) 73 FLR 414

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet, Cabinet Handbook (13th ed, August 2019)

Office of the Australian Information Commissioner, FOI Guidelines (June 2020) – paras 5.55, 5.57, 5.75

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Boyle

4 August 2021

THE APPLICATION

  1. The Applicant seeks review of a decision of the Australian Information Commissioner (IC) in Jackson Gothe-Snape and Services Australia (Freedom of Information) [2020] AICmr 19 (1 June 2020) (IC decision).[1]

    [1] T16.

  2. By the IC decision, the IC relevantly held that the material in question was not exempt under s 34 of the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth) (FOI Act), nor conditionally exempt under s 47C of the FOI Act (see [8] below).

    BACKGROUIND

  3. The facts set out under this heading are taken largely from the Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (Applicant’s SFIC) and are not contentious.

  4. On 6 January 2017 the Applicant received a request under the FOI Act from the Respondent.[2] During the course of a request consultation process undertaken by the Applicant pursuant to s 24AB of the FOI Act, the Respondent revised the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gothe-Snape; Chief Executive Officer, Services Australia and and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 2710
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned a review of a decision by the Australian Information Commissioner (the Commissioner) regarding a Freedom of Information (FOI) request made by Mr Gothe-Snape (the Applicant) for material relating to the implementation of Taskforce Integrity. The Chief Executive Officer, Services Australia (the Respondent) had initially refused access to the document in question, asserting it was exempt under section 34(1)(c) and/or section 34(3) of the *Freedom of Information Act 1982* (Cth). The Commissioner subsequently set aside the original decision, finding that the document was not exempt under sections 34(1)(c), 34(3), or 47C of the FOI Act. The Applicant sought review of the Commissioner's decision before the Tribunal.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the document was exempt under section 34 of the FOI Act, or conditionally exempt under section 47C, and if the latter, whether disclosure would be contrary to the public interest. Specifically, the Tribunal had to determine if the document was brought into existence for the dominant purpose of briefing a Minister on a document submitted to Cabinet, or if it contained information revealing Cabinet deliberations or decisions that had not been officially disclosed. The Tribunal also considered whether any purely factual material within the document was exempt.

The Tribunal found that the document was exempt under section 34(1)(c) of the FOI Act because it was brought into existence for the dominant purpose of briefing a Minister on a document that was subsequently submitted to Cabinet. The Tribunal reasoned that the exemption under section 34(1)(c) is designed to protect the confidentiality of the Cabinet process, and that a document prepared to brief a Minister on material for Cabinet submission falls within this purpose. Furthermore, the Tribunal determined that the exception in section 34(6) did not apply because the information within the document was not purely factual and its disclosure would reveal Cabinet deliberations or decisions, the existence of which had not been officially disclosed in a manner that would negate the exemption.

Consequently, the Tribunal varied the Commissioner's decision, finding that the document was exempt under section 34(1)(c) of the FOI Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 17 March 2017 the Applicant notified the Respondent of its decision (original decision) to refuse access in full to the Document on the basis that it was exempt under s 34(1)(c) and, or in the alternative, s 34(3) of the FOI Act.[4][4] T9/42–8. The Respondent made an application to the IC for review of the original decision. By the IC decision, the IC set aside the original decision and made a decision in substitution of that decision that:(a)the Document contains material that is regarded as irrelevant to the request under s 22(1)(a)(ii) of the FOI Act; and(b)the remaining material in the Document is not exempt under ss 34(1)(c), 34(3) or 47C of the FOI Act. The Applicant received notice of the IC decision on 2 June 2020 and, by application lodged with the Tribunal on 29 June 2020, seeks review of that decision.THE ISSUES The only part of the IC decision of which review is sought is that referred to in [8(b)] above. Accordingly, the issues for determination by the Tribunal are whether the Document is exempt because the relevant material in the Document is:(a)exempt under s 34 of the FOI Act; or(b)conditionally exempt under s 47C, and if so, whether (in the circumstances) giving access to the Document would, on balance, be contrary to the public interest.LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK Section 11 of the FOI Act relevantly provides:(1) Subject to this Act, every person has a legally enforceable right to obtain access in accordance with this Act to:(a)a document of an agency, other than an exempt document; or(b)an official document of a Minister, other than an exempt document. Section 34 of the FOI Act relevantly provides:(1) A document is an exempt document if:(a)both of the following are satisfied:(i)it has been submitted to the Cabinet for its consideration, or is or was proposed by a Minister to be so submitted;(ii)it was brought into existence for the dominant purpose of submission for consideration by the Cabinet; or(b)it is an official record of the Cabinet; or(c)it was brought into existence for the dominant purpose of briefing a Minister on a document to which paragraph (a) applies; or(d)it is a draft of a document to which paragraph (a), (b) or (c) applies.…(3) A document is an exempt document to the extent that it contains information the disclosure of which would reveal a Cabinet deliberation or decision, unless the existence of the deliberation or decision has been officially disclosed.…(6) Information in a document to which subsection (1), (2) or (3) applies is not exempt matter because of this section if the information consists of purely factual material, unless:(a)the disclosure of the information would reveal a Cabinet deliberation or decision; and(b)the existence of the deliberation or decision has not been officially disclosed. Section 47C(1) of the FOI Act provides:(1) A document is conditionally exempt if its disclosure under this Act would disclose matter (deliberative matter) in the nature of, or relating to, opinion, advice or recommendation obtained, prepared or recorded, or consultation or deliberation that has taken place, in the course of, or for the purposes of, the deliberative processes involved in the functions of:(a)an agency; or(b)a Minister; or(c)the Government of the Commonwealth.(Original emphasis.)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Cabinet includes a committee of the Cabinet such as the ERC.[14] The NPP was in fact subsequently submitted to and considered by the ERC and Cabinet in 2015 (McGregor affidavit para 15).[14] Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth) s 4(1). Application of s 34(3) – Disclosure of a Cabinet deliberation or decision The Document is also exempt under s 34(3) of the FOI Act because it contains information the disclosure of which would reveal a Cabinet deliberation or decision and the existence of the deliberation or decision has been officially disclosed (see [12] above). The term “deliberation” in the context of s 34(3) refers to an active debate of a matter, or weighing up of alternatives by the Cabinet, with a view to reaching (but not necessarily arriving at) a decision.[15][15] Toomer and Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry (2003) 78 ALD 645; [2003] AATA 1301. A document can also disclose a Cabinet deliberation even where the document was prepared prior to the Cabinet meeting at which the relevant matters were discussed. The relevant material in the Document includes information that was contained in the final NPP package that was submitted to, and considered by, the ERC and Cabinet and reveals the substance and nature of ERC/Cabinet deliberations in relation to the final NPP.[16] [16] McGregor affidavit paras 48–50. The qualification in s 34(3) relating to the existence of the deliberation or decision being officially disclosed does not apply in the present case. In the IC decision, the IC formed the view that the existence of Cabinet deliberation or decision in relation to the establishment or implementation of Taskforce Integrity had been officially disclosed, based on contents of the DHS Annual Report 2015–2016 and 2015–2016 Budget Paper statements.[17][17] T16/104 para 75. While the 2015–2016 Budget Paper statements make reference to the title of the NPP package, of which Taskforce Integrity formed one part, those statements do not refer specifically to Taskforce Integrity, nor do they refer to that measure being subject to deliberation or decision by the Cabinet or the Australian Government. Although the DHS Annual Report does include information about Taskforce Integrity:(a)it does not refer to that measure being subject to deliberation or decision by the Cabinet or the Australian Government; and(b)the DHS Annual Report is not a document approved by Cabinet or a Minister. As far as the Applicant is aware, the existence of Cabinet deliberations or decisions regarding the Taskforce Integrity NPP has not been disclosed in any other public material released with the authority of the Cabinet. Further, the Document was created in the course of preparing an NPP for Cabinet's consideration, and as such, is a document that relates to the Cabinet process. The inclusion of the s 34 exemption in the FOI Act recognises the importance of the protection of Cabinet confidentiality as a foundation for the proper functioning of the Cabinet process. All government proposals for a new policy that has a certain or potential financial impact must be subject to an NPP that is brought to the ERC and the Cabinet for approval. If any reference in a government publication or announcement to a matter relating to an NPP were to be construed as an official disclosure of the existence of a Cabinet deliberation or decision, this would undermine the well-established convention of Cabinet confidentiality.Exception in s 34(6) of the FOI Act