Gorgy v Dean [2000] NSWDC 1
Talat Gorgy v Ian Dean
12 January 2001
The pharmacist appealed against a decision to remove his name from the Register.* The appellant had been sentenced to twelve months in prison after conviction for the offences under the Commonwealth Crimes Act. The Court considered whether, having been convicted for the offences and served a term in prison, the public would be protected by allowing the appellant to continue to practise. The evidence before the appeal court was only marginally different to the evidence which had been before the Board.
Held:
The profession and the public would be harmed if the appellant was allowed at this point of time to continue to practise pharmacy.
It was only 18 months since his release from prison which was not a long period of time in which to build up a store of good character and professionalism sufficient to overcome his admitted serious breaches of the law and his professional obligations.
The protection of the public and the requirements of the profession made it necessary that he not be allowed to practice for a period of time which, taking into account his sentence already served, should be twelve months.
The order removing his name from the register was quashed.
The appellant was severely reprimanded and suspended from practise for 12 months.
He was ordered not to have a pecuniary interest in a pharmacy or be an approved pharmacist under the National Health Act without the approval of the Pharmacy Board. For a period of 5 years he was not to be involved in the preparation, authorisation or certification of any claim for pharmaceutical benefits without prior approval of the Pharmacy Board. During this period he was to notify the Registrar of the Pharmacy Board every three months of his employment details.
He was ordered to undertake continuing education as directed by the Pharmacy Board and had a number of conditions placed upon his practice.
*(Editorial note: for the Board’s determination see Dean v Gorgy [2000] NSWPB 1).
JUDGE WILLIAMS:
This is an appeal under S.22 of the Pharmacy Act against a decision of the Pharmacy Board on 12 April, 2000 to remove the appellant’s name from the Register of Pharmacists on NSW. Subsection (2) of S.22 provides that any appeal is to be made in accordance with the rules of Court and will be in the nature of a new hearing at which new evidence may be given. In that sense this Court stands in the place of the Board and is required to deal with the appellant in accordance with the complaint made and the provisions of the Pharmacy Act governing what may happen to a person once a complaint is proved.
In this appeal it is not contested that the appellant has been convicted in New South Wales of offences under S.29B of the Commonwealth Crimes Act, 1914 or that he has been guilty of professional misconduct within the meaning of S.19A(a) and (g) of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Gorgy v Dean and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] NSWDC 1
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that while the Board had acted within its powers in making the decision to remove the appellant's name from the Register, the penalties imposed were excessive. The court was satisfied that the appellant's actions warranted disciplinary action but considered the penalties imposed to be disproportionate to the misconduct. Consequently, the court determined that the order removing the appellant's name from the Register should be quashed, and alternative sanctions should be imposed.
In light of the findings, the court ordered that the appellant's registration as a pharmacist be suspended for a period of twelve months, with the requirement to undertake continuing professional education during the suspension. Additionally, the court imposed several conditions on the appellant's practising pharmacy, including restrictions on ownership and pecuniary interests in pharmacy businesses, as well as limitations on applications for approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits and the completion of claims for payment. The appellant was also required to notify the Pharmacy Board of New South Wales of his employment status every three months for a period of five years. Lastly, the court ordered the appellant to pay the respondent's costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
The orders that I make therefore are as follows:
1. The order made by the Pharmacy Board of NSW removing the appellant’s name from the Register of pharmacists is quashed.
2. The appellant is severely reprimanded.
3. The appellant’s registration is suspended for a period of twelve months from today pursuant to S.20(1)(b) of the Pharmacy Act.
4. During the period of suspension the appellant is to undertake such continuing Professional Education as may be directed by the Pharmacy Board, not exceeding thirty hours.
5. The appellant is to have the following conditions placed on his registration as a pharmacist in regard to his practising pharmacy:
5. (a) the appellant shall not seek to or become the owner of a pharmacy business nor to have a pecuniary interest direct or indirect in any such business without first notifying the Pharmacy Board of NSW and receiving its approval.
5. (b) the appellant shall not make an application pursuant to S.90 of the National Health Act, 1953 (Cth) for approval for the purpose of supplying pharmaceutical benefits without first notifying and receiving the approval of the Pharmacy Board of NSW.
5. (c) the appellant in any capacity whatsoever shall not, for a period of five years, without prior notification to and the approval of the Pharmacy Board of NSW, complete, authorise or certify any form of claim upon the Commonwealth of Australia for payment in respect of the supply of pharmaceutical benefits by an approved person pursuant to S.90 of the National Health Act, 1953 (Cth) from the premises where the pharmacist is employed.
5. (d) the appellant shall, for a period of five years, notify the Registrar of the Pharmacy Board of NSW every three months, where he is practising as a pharmacist, in what capacity and by whom he is employed.
6. The appellant to pay the respondent’s costs.