Gore v Carborough Downs Coal Management Pty Ltd & Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

INDUSTRIAL COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Gore v Carborough Downs Coal Management Pty Ltd & Ors [2022] ICQ 031

PARTIES:

DAVID THOMAS GORE

(appellant)

v
CARBOROUGH DOWNS COAL MANAGEMENT
PTY LTD
(respondent)

DAVID THOMAS GORE

(appellant)

v
CARBOROUGH DOWNS COAL MANAGEMENT
PTY LTD
(respondent)

DAVID THOMAS GORE

(appellant)

v
RUSSELL CLIVE UHR
(respondent)

DAVID THOMAS GORE

(appellant)

v
JEREMY DAVID FUTERAN
(respondent)

DAVID THOMAS GORE

(appellant)

v
JEREMY DAVID FUTERAN
(respondent)

DAVID THOMAS GORE

(appellant)

v
BERNARD VANDEVENTER
(respondent)

DAVID THOMAS GORE

(appellant)

v
KEVIN JAMES CASEY
(respondent)

DAVID THOMAS GORE

(appellant)

v
GARY ROY JONES

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

C/2022/16, C/2022/17, C/2022/18, C/2022/19, C/2022/20, C/2022/21, C/2022/22, C/2022/23

PROCEEDING:

Application

DELIVERED ON:

Orders made on 28 October 2022, reasons delivered on
1 November 2022

HEARING DATE:

28 October 2022

MEMBER:

Davis J, President

ORDER/S:

1.   The applications to strike out appeal numbers C/2022/17, C/2022/18 and C/2022/19 are dismissed.

2.   Appeals C/2022/16, C/2022/17, C/2022/18, C/2022/19, C/2022/20, C/2022/21, C/2022/22 and C/2022/23 shall be heard together.

3.   The appeals are set down for hearing on 2 December 2022.

4.   All parties have liberty to apply.

5.   Each parties’ costs are reserved.

6.   All parties have liberty to file and serve further supplementary submissions by 4:00 pm on 25 November 2022.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - RIGHT OF APPEAL - WHEN APPEAL LIES - where proceedings were commenced by complaint - where the appellant alleged offences against the Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999 (the CMSH Act) - where the CMSH Act provides for prosecution of offences in the Industrial Magistrates Court - where the summons issued pursuant to the complaint commanded defendants to appear in the Magistrates Court, not the Industrial Magistrates Court - where the magistrate dismissed the complaints on the basis of lack of jurisdiction - where appeals from summary proceedings in the Magistrates Court lie to the District Court - where appeals from summary proceedings in the Industrial Magistrates Court lie to the Industrial Court - where the appellants appealed the dismissal of the complaints - whether the appeal made to the Industrial Court of Queensland was competent

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - ENDING PROCEEDINGS EARLY - SUMMARY DISPOSAL - where the appellants appealed decisions to the Industrial Court of Queensland - where the respondents assert that the Industrial Court of Queensland has no jurisdiction to hear the appeals - where the respondents sought to strike out the appeals - whether there are arguable issues on appeal - whether the appeals should be struck out

Acts Interpretation Act 1954, s 36, s 44
Coal Mining Safety and Health Act
1999, s 6, s 33, s 34, s 255
Industrial Relations Act 2016, s 424, s 503, s 504, s 505, s 507
Judicial Review Act 1991, s 41
Justices Act
1886, s 22B, s 42, s 47, s 48, s 49, s 53, s 54, s 222
Magistrates Act
1991
Magistrates Courts Act 1921, s 14

CASES:

General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gore v Carborough Downs Coal Management Pty Ltd & Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] ICQ 31
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Gore v Carborough Downs Coal Management Pty Ltd & Ors is an appeal against the dismissal of complaints made under the Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999 (the CMSH Act) by the Industrial Magistrates Court. The Industrial Magistrates Court dismissed the complaints on the basis of lack of jurisdiction. The appellants have appealed to the Industrial Court of Queensland, which the respondents argue is not the appropriate court for this appeal. The respondents have applied to strike out the appeals, arguing that the Industrial Court of Queensland does not have jurisdiction to hear them.

The legal issues in this case are whether the Industrial Court of Queensland has the jurisdiction to hear appeals from summary proceedings in the Magistrates Court, and if not, whether the appeals should be struck out. The respondents argue that the Industrial Court of Queensland does not have jurisdiction to hear these appeals, as the CMSH Act provides that prosecutions for offences under the Act are to be conducted in the Industrial Magistrates Court. The summons issued in the Magistrates Court commanded the defendants to appear in the Magistrates Court, not the Industrial Magistrates Court. Therefore, the respondents argue that the Industrial Court of Queensland does not have jurisdiction to hear the appeals.

The Industrial Court of Queensland found that the appeals were competent and should not be struck out. The court found that while the summons did command the defendants to appear in the Magistrates Court, the jurisdiction of the court was not limited to the Magistrates Court. The court found that the Industrial Court of Queensland had jurisdiction to hear the appeals, as the Industrial Magistrates Court and the Magistrates Court are both courts of record, and the Industrial Magistrates Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of the appeals. The court found that the appeals were not incompetent and should not be struck out.

The Industrial Court of Queensland dismissed the applications to strike out the appeals and ordered that the appeals be heard together. The court set a date for the appeals to be heard and ordered that all parties have liberty to file and serve further supplementary submissions by a specified date. The court reserved each party's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applications to strike out appeal numbers C/2022/17, C/2022/18 and C/2022/19 are dismissed.

2. Appeals C/2022/16, C/2022/17, C/2022/18, C/2022/19, C/2022/20, C/2022/21, C/2022/22 and C/2022/23 shall be heard together.

3. The appeals are set down for hearing on 2 December 2022.

4. All parties have liberty to apply.

5. Each parties’ costs are reserved.

6. All parties have liberty to file and serve further supplementary submissions by 4:00 pm on 25 November 2022.

Background

Background to the litigation

Three issues arise. Firstly, three of the respondents have made application to strike out the appeals that have been filed against the orders dismissing the claims against them. Second is an issue as to whether the eight appeals should be heard together. The third and closely related issue is whether these appeals should be stayed until related proceedings presently being conducted in the District Court are finalised.Background The CMSH Act, as its name suggests, has as its objects the protection of the safety and health of persons at coal mines and the reduction of the risk of injury or illness to any person resulting from coal mining operations.[2] Those objectives are sought to be achieved in various ways, including by the imposition of safety obligations upon various persons working in or associated with coal mines.[3] [2]Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999, s 6.[3]Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999, s 33. Division 3 of Part 3 of the CMSH Act identifies the safety obligations which are imposed. Section 34 of the CMSH Act makes it an offence to fail to discharge a safety obligation. Section 255 provides that prosecution for the offences alleged against the various defendants here “is by way of summary proceedings before an industrial magistrate”.[4] [4]Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999, s 255(1); summary proceedings are proceedings under the Justices Act 1886; see Acts Interpretation Act 1954, s 44. The Industrial Magistrates Court is established by the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (the IR Act). By s 503 of the IR Act “an Industrial Magistrate Court is a court of record”. By s 504, an Industrial Magistrates Court “is constituted by a magistrate sitting alone”. By s 505 of the IR Act, every magistrate or acting magistrate appointed under the Magistrates Act 1991 is an Industrial Magistrate.[5] The jurisdiction of an Industrial Magistrate is that conferred by the IR Act or “another Act”, relevantly here the CMSH Act. By force of s 507 of the IR Act, the jurisdiction conferred by the CMSH Act is exclusive to the Industrial Magistrates Court.[6][5]See Acts Interpretation Act 1954, Schedule 1, definition of “magistrate” and s 36.[6]Section 507(2) does not list prosecutions pursuant to the Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999. Section 14 of the Magistrates Courts Act 1921 provides that Magistrates Courts are courts of record. The Justices Act 1886 provides that Magistrates Courts have, relevantly here, criminal jurisdiction conferred on them by the Justices Act or other Acts, of which the CMSH Act is one. By s 22B of the Justices Act, there are Magistrates Court districts. Section 42 of the Justices Act provides that proceedings are commenced by complaint. Section 47 provides that the description on the complaint of the offence in the words of the Act creating the offence shall be sufficient. Pursuant to s 53 of the Justices Act, a Justice of the Peace may issue a summons upon the complaint. Section 54 provides that the summons shall require the defendant “to appear at a certain time and place before the Magistrates Court … to answer the complaint and to be further dealt with according to law”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.