GORCILOV v POLICE
[2001] SASC 45Magistrates Appeals: Criminal (ex tempore)
DOYLE CJ: This is an appeal against sentence.
The appellant pleaded guilty in the Magistrates Court to four counts of obtaining a valuable security, a cheque, by false pretences. The value of the cheques, added together, was $1,199,918.85. The cheques were obtained from the National Australia Bank. (I will refer to the Bank as “NAB”.)
The NAB suffered a loss after realising certain security of $741,306.
The Magistrate sentenced the appellant to imprisonment for two years eight months, after reducing the sentence by four months on account of the guilty plea.
The appellant was also dealt with by the Magistrate on a charge of breaching a good behaviour bond. He pleaded guilty to the charge of breaching the bond. The offences that I have just referred to constituted that breach.
A breach of the bond meant that the appellant was liable to serve a previously suspended sentence of 12 months imprisonment. The offence for which he received the suspended sentences was obtaining money by false pretences.
The Magistrate revoked the suspension order, bringing into effect the twelve months imprisonment. That meant that the appellant faced a head sentence of three years eight months. The Magistrate fixed a non-parole period of two years three months.
The argument on appeal is based on the following:
(1)the impact of imprisonment on the appellant’s family;
(2)a claim of disparity between the appellant’s sentence and that of his co-offender;
(3)a submission that the Magistrate did not make an adequate reduction for his plea of guilty;
(4)a submission that the term of the suspended sentence should also have been reduced because of the impact of the imprisonment on the appellant’s family;
(5)the submission that the Magistrate should have allowed for an earlier period of three to four weeks spent in custody and a period spent on home detention bail.
These are the matters in the outline of argument that was filed, not all of which were pursued, or at least pursued in detail by Mr Stokes. I deal first with the facts.
The appellant was a prime mover and a fraud. The fraud involved inducing the NAB to finance the purchase of a nursing home by a string of false representations and devices.
It suffices to say the scheme was carefully and skilfully thought out. This was no impulsive act. The scheme was carried out over a period of time. I regard this as a serious fraud.
Each of the four counts attracted a maximum sentence of four years imprisonment, leading to a total of 16 years. However, the offence was in substance a single enterprise, and that is a matter properly to be taken into account.
Although NAB lost $741,306 that loss would have attracted a tax deduction, reducing its tax by about $250,000. I agree with the Magistrate that this aspect is relevant but of little significance. The criminality lies in the fraud and its direct consequence for NAB.
I can find no…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Gorcilov v Police No. Scciv-01-1790 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] SASC 45
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the Magistrate was incorrect in not considering the impact of imprisonment on the appellant's family, as the court can and should consider the offender's circumstances at the time of sentencing. The court rejected the argument of disparity between the sentences of the appellant and his co-offender, as the co-offender was not the principal offender and had pleaded guilty earlier, offered to give evidence against the appellant, and had no previous offences. The court found that the reduction for the plea of guilty was appropriate, and that the Magistrate was not asked to exercise the power under s 58(4)(a) of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act to reduce the term of the suspended sentence.
The court imposed a single sentence of imprisonment for two years, which is eight months less than that imposed by the Magistrate. The court reduced the sentence by six months on account of the impact on the family and by a further six months on account of the plea of guilty. The court fixed a non-parole period of twenty months and revoked the order suspending the sentence of twelve months' imprisonment. The court ordered that the appeal be allowed, the sentence and orders of the Magistrate be set aside, and the appellant serve the twelve months' imprisonment with effect from the date upon which he is taken into custody.
Background
Background to the litigation
The appellant was a primary instigator in a carefully planned and executed fraud scheme. He induced the NAB to finance the purchase of a nursing home through a series of false representations and devices. The fraud was executed over time, demonstrating careful planning. The NAB's loss, although significant, would have been partially offset by a tax deduction, but the criminality of the fraud remained undiminished. Each of the four counts carried a maximum penalty of four years imprisonment, totalling 16 years, though the offence was essentially a single enterprise.
The appellant is married with three children aged four years, three years, and 11 months, and his wife is due to give birth to twins shortly. The Magistrate initially dismissed the impact of imprisonment on the appellant’s family, but the appeal court found this to be an error. The court recognised that the impact on the family should be considered, especially given the appellant’s breach of the good behaviour bond, indicating a lack of deterrence from the suspended sentence. The court found no unwarranted disparity between the appellant’s sentence and that of his co-offender, who had a lesser role and pleaded guilty earlier. The court also considered the reduction for the guilty plea to be low but not erroneous, and the appellant’s earlier periods of custody and home detention bail were deemed irrelevant to the resentencing.
The case of Gorcilov v Police originated as an appeal against sentence in the South Australian Magistrates Court. The appellant, having pleaded guilty to four counts of obtaining a valuable security by false pretences, was sentenced to imprisonment for a term of two years and eight months, reduced by four months for his guilty plea. This sentence was further compounded by the revocation of a previously suspended sentence of twelve months for breaching a good behaviour bond, resulting in a cumulative sentence of three years and eight months imprisonment, with a non-parole period of two years and three months. The appellant appealed against the severity of his sentence, arguing various grounds including the impact on his family, disparity with his co-offender’s sentence, inadequate reduction for his plea of guilty, and the failure to reduce the term of the suspended sentence. The appeal was heard by the Supreme Court of South Australia, which found merit in the appellant’s contention that the Magistrate had erred in not considering the impact of imprisonment on his family. The Supreme Court subsequently re-sentenced the appellant, reducing the term of imprisonment to two years, and set a non-parole period of twenty months.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the Magistrate err in failing to consider the impact of imprisonment on the appellant’s family?
2. Is there an unwarranted disparity between the sentences imposed on the appellant and his co-offender?
3. Did the Magistrate adequately reduce the sentence for the appellant’s plea of guilty?
4. Should the term of the suspended sentence have also been reduced due to the impact of imprisonment on the appellant’s family?
5. Should the Magistrate have allowed for the period of three to four weeks spent in custody and time spent on home detention bail?
Held
1. The Magistrate erred in failing to consider the impact of imprisonment on the appellant’s family. Holding: The appeal was allowed on this ground.
2. There was no unwarranted disparity between the sentences imposed on the appellant and his co-offender. Holding: The submission was rejected.
3. The Magistrate adequately reduced the sentence for the appellant’s plea of guilty. Holding: The Magistrate’s allowance was not erroneous, though the appellate court would make its own assessment when resentencing.
4. The term of the suspended sentence should not have been reduced due to the impact of imprisonment on the appellant’s family. Holding: The Magistrate was not asked to exercise the power under s 58(4)(a) of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act to reduce the term of the suspended sentence.
5. The Magistrate should not have allowed for the period of three to four weeks spent in custody and time spent on home detention bail. Holding: These periods were attributable to other matters and could be set aside.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court held that the Magistrate erred in not considering the impact of imprisonment on the appellant's family. The court noted that the Magistrate had taken into account the appellant's circumstances at the time the offences were committed, but the court held that the Magistrate should have considered the impact of imprisonment on the appellant's family at the time of sentencing. The court held that the impact of imprisonment on the appellant's family was a relevant consideration in sentencing, even if the appellant had brought the problem on himself.
The court rejected the submission that there was an unwarranted disparity between the sentences imposed on the appellant and his co-offender. The court held that the co-offender was not the principal offender and was significantly influenced by the appellant. The court held that the co-offender was properly given a much lower sentence and that the suspension order was merciful and influenced by the plight of her young child.
The court held that the reduction for the plea of guilty was four months, which was one-ninth of the starting point. The court held that the Magistrate did not err in the allowance which he made, but the court held that it would allow a greater reduction on account of a plea of guilty than did the Magistrate. The court held that the starting point of three years was very moderate for such a serious fraud and that the sentence should be reduced by about six months on account of the impact on the family and by a further six months on account of the plea of guilty.
The court held that the Magistrate was not asked to exercise the power under s 58(4)(a) of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act and to reduce the term of the suspended sentence. The court held that the power was available to be exercised but, in the opinion of the court, the only possible 'special circumstances' was the impact of imprisonment on the appellant's family.
The court held that the Magistrate should have allowed for the period of three to four weeks spent in custody and time spent on home detention bail. The court held that these matters were attributable to other matters and accordingly could be put to one side.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court can, and should, consider the offender's circumstances at the time of sentencing, including the impact of imprisonment on the offender's family. The court should also consider the impact of imprisonment on the offender's family when resentencing the offender. The court should also consider the impact of imprisonment on the offender's family when exercising the power under s 58(4)(a) of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act and to reduce the term of the suspended sentence. The court should also consider the period of time the offender has spent in custody and on home detention bail when resentencing the offender.