Gorbunkova and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship)

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

Gorbunkova and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2019] AATA 853 (13 May 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/6872

Re:Svetlana Alekseyevna Gorbunkova

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member C Edwardes

Member S Barton

Date:13 May 2019

Place:Perth

The decision under review is affirmed.

................................[sgd]........................................

Member C Edwardes

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP – refusal of application for Australian citizenship by conferral – general residence requirement – application of Ministerial discretion – whether close and continuing association with Australia – whether migrated to and established home in Australia – Australian citizen children – extended family in Australia – long term relationship with Australian citizen spouse – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) – ss 21(1), 21(1A), 21(2), 21(2)(c), 22(1B), 23, 24(1), 52(1)(b)

CASES

Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Li and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2015) 150 ALD 348
Taher v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2013] AATA 917
UI Haque and Minister Immigration and Citizenship (2013) 139 ALD 376
Vasiunina v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 943
Yang v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] AATA 364

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Department of Immigration and Border Protection, Australian Citizenship Policy, at 1 June 2016 – Chapter 7A

Explanatory Memorandum, Australian Citizenship Bill 2005 (Cth) – cl 22

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member C Edwardes
Member S Barton

13 May 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an application for the review of a decision of a delegate of the Respondent


    (the Minister’s Delegate). This decision, made on 30 July 2018 (T15 179-186, R1), refused the Applicant’s application for Australian citizenship by conferral under s 24(1) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) (the Citizenship Act). The application was refused on the basis that the Applicant did not satisfy the general residence requirements under s 22 of the Citizenship Act at the time of the Minister’s Delegate’s decision.

  2. Citizenship by conferral (that is, where citizenship is granted to a person who does not have an automatic or statutory entitlement to citizenship) may be granted where an applicant satisfies certain requirements of the Citizenship Act.

    BACKGROUND

  3. The Applicant is a 32 year old citizen of Azerbaijan who arrived in Australia on


    18 March 2008, and who was granted a Partner (Permanent) (subclass 100) Visa (Permanent Partner visa) on 1 June 2013. She currently holds a Resident Return BB155 (Permanent) Visa (T16 188, R1).  

  4. The Applicant applied for conferral of Australian citizenship on


    7 February 2018 (T4 12-49, R1).  

  5. Her application indicated that she was seeking Ministerial discretion relating to the residential test, on the basis that she was the spouse of an Australian citizen.

  6. The Minister’s Delegate stated (T15 179-187, R1):

    General residence requirement (section 22 of the Act)

    To satisfy the general residence requirement an applicant must meet all of the following three requirements set out in the Act:

    1)the applicant was present in Australia for the period of 4…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gorbunkova and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 853
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) considered the application of Ms Gorbunkova for Australian citizenship by conferral. Ms Gorbunkova, a citizen of Azerbaijan, arrived in Australia in 2008 and was granted a permanent partner visa in 2013. She applied for citizenship in February 2018, seeking Ministerial discretion regarding the general residence requirement due to her marriage to an Australian citizen. The Minister's Delegate refused her application, finding she did not meet the required periods of presence in Australia, even with the discretion for absences related to a spouse.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Ms Gorbunkova satisfied the general residence requirement under section 22 of the *Citizenship Act*, specifically whether the Ministerial discretion under section 22(9)(d) could be applied to deem her absences from Australia as time spent onshore. This required the Tribunal to determine if she had a "close and continuing association with Australia" despite significant periods spent overseas. The Tribunal also considered whether any prejudice would arise from denying her application.

The Tribunal reasoned that Ms Gorbunkova failed to meet the statutory requirements for presence in Australia. In the four years preceding her application, she was absent for 1,372 days, exceeding the allowable 12-month absence under section 22(1A). Similarly, in the 12 months before applying, she was absent for 321 days, exceeding the 90-day limit under section 22(1B) for permanent residents. While acknowledging her marriage to an Australian citizen, her Australian citizen children, and her extended family in Australia, the Tribunal found these factors insufficient to establish a "close and continuing association" as required by section 22(9)(d). The Tribunal noted that her husband's overseas work commitments and his stated lack of interest in fly-in, fly-out employment in Australia indicated a lack of settled intention to reside in Australia at the time of the application.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision of the Minister's Delegate to refuse the application for Australian citizenship. It concluded that Ms Gorbunkova was not prejudiced by this decision, as she remained a permanent resident and could reapply for citizenship upon returning to Australia and demonstrating she met the requisite criteria, including a close and continuing association with the country.

Background

Background to the litigation

Citizenship by conferral (that is, where citizenship is granted to a person who does not have an automatic or statutory entitlement to citizenship) may be granted where an applicant satisfies certain requirements of the Citizenship Act. BACKGROUND The Applicant is a 32 year old citizen of Azerbaijan who arrived in Australia on 18 March 2008, and who was granted a Partner (Permanent) (subclass 100) Visa (Permanent Partner visa) on 1 June 2013. She currently holds a Resident Return BB155 (Permanent) Visa (T16 188, R1). The Applicant applied for conferral of Australian citizenship on 7 February 2018 (T4 12-49, R1). Her application indicated that she was seeking Ministerial discretion relating to the residential test, on the basis that she was the spouse of an Australian citizen. The Minister’s Delegate stated (T15 179-187, R1): General residence requirement (section 22 of the Act)To satisfy the general residence requirement an applicant must meet all of the following three requirements set out in the Act:1)the applicant was present in Australia for the period of 4 years immediately before applying for citizenship – paragraph 22(1)(a)); and2)the applicant must not have been present in Australia as an unlawful non-citizen at any time during that 4 year period – paragraph 22(1)(b); and3)the applicant was present in Australia as a permanent resident for the period of 12 months immediately before applying for citizenship -paragraph 22(1)(c).According to departmental records you were present in Australia for four years immediately before making your application.Overseas AbsencesSub-section 22(1A) of the Act allows for absences from Australia of up to 12 months within the 4 years immediately before applying for citizenship.Departmental records indicate that you were absent from Australia for a total of 1,372 days in the 4 year period immediately before applying for citizenship. As you were absent for more than 12 months you have exceeded the allowable absences provided in sub-section 22(1A) and cannot be considered to have been present in Australia for the period of 4 years immediately before making your application. Therefore, you do not meet the requirement of paragraph 22(1)(a) of the Act.…•Paragraph 22(1)(b) of the Act provides that the applicant must not be present in Australia as an unlawful non-citizen at any time during the 4 year period immediately before making an application for citizenship.…•Paragraph 22(1)(c) of the Act provides that the applicant must have been present in Australia as a permanent resident for the period of 12 months immediately before applying for citizenship.According to departmental records you became a permanent resident on 1 June 2013.Overseas AbsencesSub-section 22(1B) of the Act allows for absences from Australia of up to 90 days within the 12 months immediately before applying for citizenship providing the person remains a permanent resident throughout this time.Departmental records indicate that you were absent from Australia for a total of 321 days in the 12 month period immediately before applying for citizenship. As you were absent for more than 90 days you have exceeded the allowable absences provided in sub-section 22(1B) and cannot be considered to have been present in Australia for the period of 12 months immediately before making your application. Therefore, you do not meet the requirements of paragraph 22(1)(c) of the Act.…I have considered the information contained in your application and that [sic] contained on departmental systems and I can see no evidence that any of the partial exemptions set out in subsection 22(2) apply to you.I have considered whether any of the Ministerial discretions set out in subsections 22(4A), (5), (5A), (6), (9), (10) or (11) could be applied to assist you to meet the general residence requirements, however I have no evidence to support the application of any of these discretions in your circumstances.I have assessed your request to be considered under the Ministerial discretion – spouse, de facto partner or surviving spouse or de facto partner of Australian citizen. Subsection 22(9) of the Act outlines the requirements to be met in order for periods offshore to be considered as time spent onshore. Pursuant to subsection 22(9)(d) of the Act, the Minister is to be satisfied that the person had a close and continuing association with Australia. Based on the information provided, you indicate that you will return to Australia permanently after July 2020. In addition, departmental records indicate you have only spent 89 days in Australia in the four years prior to lodging your application compared to 1,372 outside of Australia. In the year prior to lodging your application, you had only spent 44 days in Australia. Subsequently, I am not satisfied you meet close and continuing ties, even though you may have an Australian partner and that his extended family reside in Australia. Therefore, the Ministerial discretion – spouse, de facto partner or surviving spouse or de facto partner of Australian citizen will not be applied.You have provided no evidence that you satisfy the special residence requirements in sections 22A (persons engaging in activities of benefit to Australia) and 22B (persons engaged in particular kinds of work requiring regular travel outside Australia) of the Act, or that you have completed defence service relevant to section 23 of the Act.(Original emphasis.)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The issue for determination by the Tribunal is whether the Applicant had satisfied s 22(1)(9) of the Citizenship Act as of 30 July 2018. EVIDENCE The application for review was heard on 30 April 2019 in Perth. The Applicant appeared by telephone from the Republic of Korea, and was represented by Mr Ross, a Registered Migration Agent. The Respondent was represented by Mr Burgess of Sparke Helmore Lawyers. The Tribunal received the following evidence:·Exhibit A1 – Applicant’s submissions dated 14 January 2019 with the following Addendums:oAddendum 1: Acknowledgement of receipt of an application for Australian Citizenship (conferral);oAddendum 2: Notification of refusal of an application for Australian Citizenship (conferral);oAddendum 3: Passport biodata page of the Applicant;oAddendum 4: Passport biodata page of the Applicant’s husband;oAddendum 5: Verification of registration of marriage between the Applicant and the Applicant’s husband;oAddendum 6: Passport biodata pages and birth certificates for the Applicant’s children;oAddendum 7: Decision of Taher v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2013] AATA 917;oAddendum 8: Statutory declaration of the Applicant’s husband signed on 9 January 2019, and certificate of employment for the Applicant’s husband;oAddendum 9: Statement by the Applicant, undated;oAddendum 10: Statement by various family members in support of the Applicant; andoAddendum 11: Decision of Vasiunina v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 943.·Exhibit A2 – Hearing Certificate dated 1 February 2019;·Exhibit R1 – T documents (T1-T19, 1-223); ·Exhibit R2 – Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SoFIC) dated 28 February 2018; and·Exhibit R3 – Hearing Certificate dated 8 February 2019. The Tribunal has reviewed all of the material before it. The Tribunal is satisfied that all relevant evidence was before it, and that both parties were provided an opportunity to address the evidence either orally or in writing. Relevant aspects of the evidence and material before the Tribunal will be referred to and analysed below. The Applicant contends (A1 3):…Under policy, enabling a family unit to remain together can be considered of benefit to Australia particularly if there is evidence of an imminent intention for the family unit to domicile themselves in Australia.Seven examples of personal ties that may be considered substantial are situations where the applicant:• has a history of long term residence in Australia prior to the last 5 years, particularly, if the applicant has spent their formative years in Australia or has spent a significant amount of time in Australia since first being granted a permanent visa. Under policy, the greater the proportion of their life in Australia since first being granted a permanent visa, the more weight this should be given• has been living outside Australia with an Australian citizen partner or, in the case of a minor child, Australian citizen parent, who has previously lived in Australia. Such situations should be given considerable weight as their Australian citizen partner or parent has an automatic right of entry to Australia• has been living in Australia for more than 12 months in the last 5 years, including as a temporary resident• has one or more Australian citizen minor children living in Australia (including at boarding school) where no legal impediment to access exists• has been living overseas with their family unit, including Australian citizen minor children, and the applicant provides evidence of imminent plans to return to Australia with their family to live (this tie should be given considerable weight)• has personal assets in Australia, for example family home or single investment property – although ownership of a family home or investment property in Australia may help substantiate a personal tie, whether there was a benefit to Australia will depend on whether it is occupied, for example, by a close family member or actively being rented• has close family members (that is, of a type for which family reunion might be available under the Family Stream of the Migration Program) who have substantial residence in Australia and are Australian permanent residents or Australian citizens.(Original emphasis.)

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal determines that there is no prejudice to the Applicant in denying this application. She is a permanent resident, and whilst renewal can be at times tedious and frustrating, it is not a reason to approve the citizenship application. The Applicant can apply at any time for citizenship on her return to Australia, after meeting the requisite criteria and demonstrating her close and continuing association to Australia. Her evidence to the Tribunal indicates a clear intention to return to Australia once her husband’s work commitments overseas are completed.DECISION For the reasons above, the Tribunal affirms the decision of the Minister’s Delegate.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In evidence, the Applicant’s husband stated:·He had previously owned three properties in Perth, and had subsequently sold them due to financial and property tenant considerations.·He had arrived in Australia with his family when he was 15 year old, in 1997.·He possesses qualifications in electrical engineering. Having completed his qualifications in 2006 he travelled to Azerbaijan to visit his father, who was working overseas at the time.·Whilst in Azerbaijan he was offered employment, and through a friend met his future wife, the Applicant. He worked overseas because of employment opportunities and better pay.·He returned to Australia with the Applicant in 2009, and took employment for approximately 18 months on a fly-in, fly-out basis. The Applicant stayed at his parents’ house during this time. Once this contract was completed, he left Australia for approximately 10 years to work overseas as pay and employment opportunities were far better.·He decided not to seek employment in Australia because he had no interest in fly-in, fly-out employment, or in living in mobile camps.·His return to Australia is driven primarily by a desire to provide a solid education for his children. He has good connections in Perth within his industry to secure a head office position.·He stated that the renewal of the Applicant’s visa was beginning to be an administrative nightmare, as the result of the time it takes to go through the process.CONSIDERATION In determining whether the Applicant satisfies s 22(1)(9)(d) of the Citizenship Act at the time that the Minister made his decision, the Tribunal must take into account a number of considerations. These are outlined below.Does the Applicant satisfy the requirements of s 22(1)(9) of the Citizenship Act? The Applicant made an application for citizenship by conferral on 7 February 2018 (T8 99, R1). In the four years prior to that date, she spent only 89 days in Australia (T4 28-40, R1 6). She was absent for 1,372 days (T15 181, R1). She therefore failed to satisfy ss 22(1)(a) and (1A) of the Citizenship Act. The Applicant also fails the s 22(1)(c) test of the Citizenship Act as she was only in Australia for 44 days in the 12 month period prior to when the Applicant made her application. The Tribunal accepts that the Applicant satisfies s 22(1)(b) of the Citizenship Act. The Tribunal has been asked to consider the Applicant’s application under s 22(9)(d) of the Citizenship Act. She contends the elements in her favour are: ·her marriage and long term relationship to an Australian citizen; ·her relationship with her Australian extended family; ·having two children who are Australian citizens, one of whom attends boarding school in Australia; and ·her regular returns to Australia. The Tribunal accepts the Respondent’s submission that s 22(9)(a)-(c) of the Citizenship Act has been satisfied (R2). The Tribunal accepts that s 22(9)(d) has two steps to enliven the use of that provision, and notes the Respondent’s contention that s 22(9)(d) of the Citizenship Act has not been satisfied.