Goondiwindi Regional Council v Tait

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Goondiwindi Regional Council v Tait [2020] QCA 119

PARTIES:

GOONDIWINDI REGIONAL COUNCIL
ABN 79 969 846 487
(appellant)
v
PAULA DEANNE TAIT
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 13250 of 2019
DC No 1665 of 2018

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:


District Court at Brisbane – [2019] QDC 208 (Jarro DCJ)

DELIVERED ON:

5 June 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

17 April 2020

JUDGES:

Morrison and McMurdo JJA and Burns J

ORDER:

Appeal dismissed with costs.

CATCHWORDS:

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – STANDARD OF CARE, SCOPE OF DUTY AND SUBSEQUENT BREACH – where the respondent was riding her motorcycle through a floodway and struck a large pothole – where the respondent sued the appellant for damages as a result of the injuries she sustained – where the appellant had responsibility for maintaining that section of road as part of its contractual arrangement with the State of Queensland, under a Road Maintenance Performance Contract (RMPC) – whether taking steps to warn motorists was part of or the commencement of the appellant’s performance of its maintenance obligations

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – STANDARD OF CARE, SCOPE OF DUTY AND SUBSEQUENT BREACH – CIVIL LIABILITY LEGISLATION – GENERALLY – where there was considerable rainfall which brought widespread flooding, including to the floodway – where the appellant’s maintenance crew identified that there was a danger to traffic because of the rough surface of the floodway and the likelihood of potholes – whether the appellant had actual knowledge of the particular risk – whether the particular risk was the particular pothole that the respondent hit

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – DAMAGE AND CAUSATION – CAUSATION – where members of the appellant’s patching crew erected freestanding signs on both approaches to the floodway – where the signs were not secured – where the signage had fallen over at the time of the respondent’s accident – whether the respondent would have been able to avoid the pothole had the temporary signage been up

Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld), s 35, s 37

Botany Bay City Council v Latham (2013) 197 LGERA 211; [2013] NSWCA 363, distinguished
Brodie v Singleton Shire Council (2001) 206 CLR 512; [2001] HCA 29, applied
Collins v Clarence Valley Council (2015) 91 NSWLR 128; [2015] NSWCA 263, distinguished
North Sydney Council v Roman (2007) 69 NSWLR 240; [2007] NSWCA 27, distinguished

COUNSEL:

K N Wilson QC for the appellant
S C Holt QC, with R J Lynch, for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

King & Company Solicitors for the appellant
Shine Lawyers for the respondent

  1. MORRISON JA:  On Sunday 25 September 2016 Ms Tait was riding her motorcycle with a group of fellow bike riders, in a southerly direction on the Leichhardt Highway, through the Mittengang Creek Floodway.  The floodway was located at Billa Billa, on the Leichhardt Highway, about 47 kilometres north of Goondiwindi.  She struck a large pothole and sustained injuries when she fell.

  2. Ms Tait sued the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Goondiwindi Regional Council v Tait and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QCA 119
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Goondiwindi Regional Council v Tait, the respondent, Ms Tait, sued the appellant, Goondiwindi Regional Council, for damages resulting from injuries she sustained while riding her motorcycle through a floodway and striking a large pothole. The Council had responsibility for maintaining the section of road as part of its contractual arrangement with the State of Queensland, under a Road Maintenance Performance Contract (RMPC). The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Council took adequate steps to warn motorists of the dangers present, whether the Council had actual knowledge of the particular risk posed by the pothole, and whether the respondent would have been able to avoid the pothole if the temporary signage had been up.

The court found that the Council's maintenance crew identified the danger to traffic due to the rough surface of the floodway and the likelihood of potholes, but did not have actual knowledge of the particular risk posed by the specific pothole that Ms Tait hit. The court further found that the temporary signage erected by the Council's patching crew to warn motorists about changed traffic conditions, including a rough surface, was not secured and had fallen over at the time of the respondent's accident. However, the court held that even if the temporary signage had been up, it was unlikely that the respondent would have been able to avoid the pothole given the circumstances of the accident.

The court concluded that the appeal brought by the Council should be dismissed, as the Council had failed to adequately warn motorists of the dangers present and had breached its duty of care. The court ordered that the appeal be dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Lloyd attended the floodway twice on 24 September. On the second time the water had receded, and he described it as a “trickle”. He said he could see from the ripples on the water, and feel from the truck’s wheels, that there were a couple of football sized potholes.[10] His evidence was that the purpose of the temporary signage was to warn motorists about changed traffic conditions, including a rough surface, which includes potholes. He agreed that potholes were dangerous to road users, and with traffic, especially large vehicular traffic, the potholes were only going to get worse.[11][10]AB 1172 lines 15-35.[11]AB 1175 lines 18-30.Facts concerning Ms Tait’s riding On the date of the accident Ms Tait was riding with a group of others. Apart from a brief shower at the start of their ride, the weather was sunny and fine. The group had ridden along the Gore Highway to Dalby via Millmerran, then to Moonie, and were returning via the Leichhardt Highway to Goondiwindi. During the journey Ms Tait did not see water across the highways but observed “lots of floodway signs”. There had been a lot of temporary signs describing “rough surface” and “slow down”. Her evidence was that when she saw such signs, she slowed down. The group rode in a staggered configuration. In that formation the lead rider, Ms Trehearn, was positioned closest to the left side, towards the fog line. Ms Trehearn’s mother, Ms Death, was two to three car lengths back, closer to the right hand side of the lane. Ms Tait was a further two to three car lengths back, behind Ms Death and near the middle of the lane. Prior to the accident the group were travelling at about 80 km/hr. Ms Tait noticed the permanent “Floodway” sign prior to the actual floodway, but no other signage. As it transpired, the temporary signage had fallen over. Ms Tait noticed Ms Trehearn veer sharply to the left and at that point she saw what she described as “discolouration” on the highway. She then saw that Ms Death’s bike was off the ground and Ms Death had been thrown into the air, hitting her own windscreen. By then Ms Tait was in dry gravel in the pothole area, and realised she was in trouble. She tried to veer left to get away from Ms Death because she thought that bike was going to flip. Then Ms Tait was catapulted as a result of hitting the deepest part of the pothole. It was not in dispute that the pothole at that time was 20 centimetres deep, 30 centimetres wide and one metre long. Ms Tait explained that the group rode in a staggered formation, and as a consequence her vision was obstructed “to a certain extent”. The group had passed flooding and potential damage to the roads including potholes, and on such occasions the lead rider (Ms Trehearn) would slow down and the remaining group members would follow. According to Ms Tait, they rode to the conditions of the roadway, including slowing down when the surface was rough. Ms Trehearn’s evidence was that Ms Tait was a very sound, cautious and careful rider. She described the way the group operated in a staggered format, and as lead rider, she decreased her speed when she observed signs that indicated changed traffic conditions. She said she was travelling about a metre off the fog line, and at 100 km/hr when she first noticed discolouration on the road. As she got closer she saw there was a defect and reduced her speed to 80 km/hr. Her initial thought was that it was a repair which had not been finished with bitumen. She was able to avoid the washout by travelling closer to the fog line on the remaining intact bitumen. As she got close enough she could see the depth of the hole and realised it was a very deep hole which was going to cause a problem.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Fourthly, by riding in staggered formation, with riders offset one against the other, Ms Tait was in a position where she could see forward, and critically maintain observation of the lead rider. She was conscious of the previous rainfall and flooding, and the potential for damage to the roads. She had been part of a group which had successfully deployed the method of riding for some 400 kilometres prior to the accident. In the circumstances, that was powerful evidence that her riding as part of the staggered formation group was appropriate to care for her own safety.Conclusion For the reasons set out above the appellant’s grounds of challenge have failed. I would dismiss the appeal with costs. McMURDO JA: The facts are set out in full in the judgment of Morrison JA and I need not repeat them. For the reasons that follow, I agree that the appeal should be dismissed.The Council’s duty of care This accident occurred on a road which was declared, under s 24 of the Transport Infrastructure Act 1994 (Qld), as a State-controlled road. The ultimate control over such a road is in the chief executive under that Act.[76] By s 28, the chief executive may exercise, for a State-controlled road in the area of a local government, all of the powers that the local government may exercise for a local government road in the area.[77][76]Transport Infrastructure Act 1994 (Qld), s 23(1)(b); as to the office of chief executive, see Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld) s 33(11).[77]As to which, see Local Government Act 2009 (Qld), s 60. By s 29, the chief executive may enter into contracts with other persons, including local governments, for the carrying out of road works on a State-controlled road. Such a contract may provide for which powers of the local government are to be exercised by the chief executive, and which of the powers are to be exercised by the local government for the State-controlled road: s 29(4). A local government may exercise, for a State-controlled road, all of the powers that it may exercise for a local government road in its area.[78] However, if there is a contract of the kind mentioned in s 29(4), the exercise of the powers must be according to the contract.[79][78]Transport Infrastructure Act 1994 (Qld), s 45(1).[79]Transport Infrastructure Act 1994 (Qld), s 45(2). Pursuant to s 29(4), such a contract was made with the Council, described as a Road Maintenance Performance Contract (“the Contract”). It recited that the maintenance of State-controlled roads had been carried out by local governments and the State for more than 70 years, with the local governments being reimbursed for the cost of work undertaken, “as the agent of the department”.[80][80]Clause 1.2.1 of the Contract. By cl 2.5.1 of the Contract, the Council, “as the department’s local representative” was to “act professionally in the department’s interest” and to ensure, amongst other things, that “Maintenance concerns are addressed [by the Council] and only referred to the department when necessary”, and that “the Network[81] is in a safe condition for Road users.”[81]Defined as those roads included in the Contract: cl 1.4.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.