Goldstein and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Goldstein and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2016] AATA 57 (5 February 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number

2015/2608

Re

Robert Goldstein

APPLICANT

And

Civil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President I R Molloy

Date 5 February 2016
Place Brisbane

The decision under review is set aside and substituted with a decision to issue the applicant with a class 2 medical certificate subject to the following conditions:

The holder is to fly at all times as or with a safety pilot and must ensure compliance with the following requirements for any flight:

Aircraft Requirements

The aircraft being flown must be configured with side by side seating in the cockpit;

The aircraft being flown must have a full set of dual flying controls.

Requirements of holder

The holder must wear a shoulder restraint harness at all times when occupying a control seat;

The holder must ensure the safety pilot has been shown a copy of the conditions endorsed on the holder’s medical certificate including these requirements.

Requirements for the safety pilot

The safety pilot must occupy a control seat, except for short absences (absences only in the cruise with the autopilot engaged);

The safety pilot must be endorsed and current on the aircraft type being flown;

The safety pilot must be appropriately rated for the in-flight conditions;

The safety pilot must have a medical certificate not restricted to multi-crew flight operations;

The safety pilot must be aware of the type of incapacity the pilot may suffer in flight;

The safety pilot must be prepared to take over the aircraft controls during critical phases of flight;

The safety pilot must be competent and capable of concluding the flight safely from the control seat.

The Applicant is also required to provide CASA’s Aviation Medical Branch with a regular (every 3 months) ICD download excluding any significant burden of ventricular tachycardia, ventricular fibrillation or ICD discharge in order to monitor him for any deterioration requiring a review of his suitability to hold a conditional certificate.

............................[Sgd]...........................................

Deputy President I R Molloy

CATCHWORDS

CIVIL AVIATION - refusal to grant class 2 medical certificate – whether applicant suffers from safety-relevant medical conditions - whether likely that medical conditions will interfere with safe exercise of privileges or performance of duties – whether conditions can be imposed to ameliorate the risk to air navigation safety – safety-relevant medical conditions made out – conditions applied – refusal decision set aside and  class 2 medical certificate issued with conditions

LEGISLATION

Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (Cth) r 61.410, 67.180, 67,010, 67.155, 11.056

Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 20AB, 3, 9A,

CASES

White and Civil Aviation Safety Authority (2008) 105 ALD 33

Window v Civil Aviation Safety Authority [1999] AATA 527

Hall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2004] AATA 21

Mulholland and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2007] AATA 1952

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President I R Molloy

5 February 2016

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Robert Goldstein holds a private pilot licence. He has applied to the Tribunal to review a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Goldstein and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 57
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Robert Goldstein sought to overturn a decision of the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) that refused him a class 2 medical certificate on the basis that he suffered from safety-relevant medical conditions. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was tasked with reviewing the decision under the Civil Aviation Act 1988 and Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998. The primary legal issue before the AAT was whether Mr Goldstein's medical conditions indeed posed a risk to air navigation safety and, if so, whether conditions could be imposed that would allow him to obtain the certificate. The AAT found that the medical conditions, including arrhythmia, defibrillator insertion, idiopathic cardiomyopathy, and others, did indeed constitute safety-relevant medical conditions. However, the AAT also determined that specific conditions could be applied to mitigate these risks. These conditions included requirements for Mr Goldstein to fly with a safety pilot, certain aircraft configurations, and regular medical monitoring through ICD downloads.

The AAT concluded that the refusal decision was incorrect, and it set aside the decision of CASA. Instead, the AAT issued a class 2 medical certificate to Mr Goldstein, subject to the previously outlined conditions. This decision was based on the findings that while Mr Goldstein's medical conditions were significant, they could be managed effectively with the stipulated conditions to ensure the safety of air navigation. The AAT's decision underscores the importance of balancing individual rights with public safety in the context of aviation regulations.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision under review is set aside and substituted with a decision to issue the applicant with a class 2 medical certificate subject to the following conditions:

The holder is to fly at all times as or with a safety pilot and must ensure compliance with the following requirements for any flight:

Aircraft Requirements

The aircraft being flown must be configured with side by side seating in the cockpit;

The aircraft being flown must have a full set of dual flying controls.

Requirements of holder

The holder must wear a shoulder restraint harness at all times when occupying a control seat;

The holder must ensure the safety pilot has been shown a copy of the conditions endorsed on the holder’s medical certificate including these requirements.

Requirements for the safety pilot

The safety pilot must occupy a control seat, except for short absences (absences only in the cruise with the autopilot engaged);

The safety pilot must be endorsed and current on the aircraft type being flown;

The safety pilot must be appropriately rated for the in-flight conditions;

The safety pilot must have a medical certificate not restricted to multi-crew flight operations;

The safety pilot must be aware of the type of incapacity the pilot may suffer in flight;

The safety pilot must be prepared to take over the aircraft controls during critical phases of flight;

The safety pilot must be competent and capable of concluding the flight safely from the control seat.

The Applicant is also required to provide CASA’s Aviation Medical Branch with a regular (every 3 months) ICD download excluding any significant burden of ventricular tachycardia, ventricular fibrillation or ICD discharge in order to monitor him for any deterioration requiring a review of his suitability to hold a conditional certificate.

Background

Background to the litigation

Robert Goldstein holds a private pilot licence. He has applied to the Tribunal to review a decision of a delegate of the Civil Aviation Authority (“CASA”) dated 6 May 2015 affirming an earlier CASA decision refusing him a medical certificate.[1][1] T1, P1-2.BACKGROUND On 11 April 2014 Mr Goldstein applied to CASA for a class 2 medical certificate. On 4 May 2014 CASA responded that based on his medical history of arrhythmia and defibrillator insertion he failed to meet the required medical standard. This decision was confirmed on review in a letter from CASA dated 1 July 2014 again relying on Mr Goldstein’s medical history of arrhythmia and defibrillator insertion.[2] [2] T3, P4-6 On 18 July 2014, Mr Goldstein made an application for reconsideration of the decision of 1 July 2014. By letter dated 6 May 2015 CASA affirmed the decision, again refusing to issue a class 2 medical certificate.[3] [3] T3, P7-9 The decision of 6 May 2015 (“the reviewable decision”) included a determination that Mr Goldstein had an established medical history of idiopathic cardiomyopathy, complete heart block, atrial fibrillation, recurrent ventricular tachycardia, type 2 diabetes mellitus, hypertension and hyperlipidaemia. The decision referred to Mr Golstein’s prescribed medication and to a permanent pacemaker and an implantable cardiac defibrillator. The reviewable decision concluded that based on the above medical conditions, and the prescribed measures implemented to treat them, Mr Goldstein did not meet the required medical standard for a class 2 medical certificate, and there were no conditions that would adequately ameliorate the risks to air navigation safety. By application dated 25 May 2015 Mr Goldstein applied to the Tribunal for review of the decision of 6 May 2015. REGULATORY PROVISIONS Regulation 61.410(1) of the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (Cth) (“CASR”) provides that the holder of a private pilot licence is not authorised to exercise the privileges of that licence if the person does not hold a current class 1 or class 2 medical certificate, or a medical exemption for the exercise of the privileges of the licence. Subsection 20AB(1) of the Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth) provides relevantly that a person must not perform any duty that is essential to the operation of an Australian aircraft during flight times if the person does not hold a current civil aviation authorisation that authorises the performance of that duty. By s 3(1) of the Civil Aviation Act the term “civil aviation authorisation” is defined to include a certificate issued under the Regulations. The issuing of medical certificates is governed by Part 67 of the CASR. Regulation 67.180 prevents CASA from issuing a medical certificate unless the applicant meets the “relevant medical standard”, or to the extent to which the applicant does not meet that standard, is not “likely to endanger the safety of air navigation”. Regulation 67.010 provides that the relevant medical standard for a class 2 medical certificate is medical standard 2. Medical standard 2 is defined as the standard set out in Table 67.155.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I accept having due regard to s 9A(1) of the Civil Aviation Act that the above would be the correct and preferable decision.Conclusion The decision under review is set aside and substituted with a decision to issue the applicant with a class 2 medical certificate subject to the conditions referred to in paragraphs 43 and 44 above.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) had determined that Mr Goldstein did not meet the required medical standard for a class 2 medical certificate based on his medical history, including arrhythmia, defibrillator insertion, idiopathic cardiomyopathy, complete heart block, atrial fibrillation, recurrent ventricular tachycardia, type 2 diabetes mellitus, hypertension and hyperlipidaemia. This determination was upheld on review and Mr Goldstein applied to the Tribunal for review of that decision. The Tribunal accepted that Mr Goldstein’s medical history did indeed constitute safety-relevant medical conditions that made him unsuitable to hold an unrestricted class 2 medical certificate. The Tribunal found that these conditions were likely to interfere with the safe exercise of his privileges or performance of duties as a pilot. However, the Tribunal considered that appropriate conditions could be imposed to mitigate these risks and allow Mr Goldstein to hold a conditional class 2 medical certificate. The Tribunal set aside the decision of CASA and issued a class 2 medical certificate to Mr Goldstein subject to a number of specific conditions aimed at ensuring air navigation safety. These included requirements for Mr Goldstein to fly with a safety pilot at all times, to wear a shoulder restraint harness, and for the aircraft to be configured with dual flying controls and side by side seating. The Tribunal also imposed requirements on the safety pilot to ensure they were suitably qualified and aware of the risks. The Tribunal concluded that these conditions would adequately ameliorate the risks to air navigation safety and allow Mr Goldstein to safely exercise his privileges as a private pilot. The Tribunal found that the imposition of such conditions was consistent with the relevant regulatory provisions under the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations. The binding principle established by the decision is that where a pilot has safety-relevant medical conditions, a class 2 medical certificate may still be issued subject to appropriate conditions that mitigate the risks to air navigation safety.