Goldsmith & Anor v Resolution Life Australasia Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Goldsmith & Anor v Resolution Life Australasia Limited [2024] QCA 48

PARTIES:

ANDREW DAVID GOLDSMITH
JANNE ELIZABETH TIPPETT
(appellants/respondents)
v
RESOLUTION LIFE AUSTRALASIA LIMITED
ACN 079 300 379
(respondent/applicant)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 3379 of 2023
Appeal No 3320 of 2024
SC No 7538 of 2022
SC No 3268 of 2018

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Miscellaneous Application – Civil

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane – [2023] QSC 15 (Crowley J); [2024] QSC 17 (Wilson J)

DELIVERED ON:

3 April 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

27 March 2024

JUDGE:

Morrison JA

ORDERS:

1.   Appeal CA 3379 of 2023 be heard together with appeal CA 3320 of 2024.

2.    That the Registrar determine a timetable to finalise the steps necessary to give effect to order number 1.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – JOINDER OF CAUSES OF ACTION AND OF PARTIES – PARTIES – GENERALLY – where the applicant applies for two appeals to be heard together or heard sequentially by the same court – where the court will have to traverse areas of evidence and factual findings that are common to both appeals – where there is a risk that the court’s findings will be inconsistent about the same facts – whether the two appeals should be heard together

COUNSEL:

The appellants/respondents appeared on their own behalf
D E F Chesterman KC for the respondent/applicant

SOLICITORS:

The appellants/respondents appeared on their own behalf
Norton Rose Fulbright Australia for the respondent/applicant

  1. MORRISON JA:  The respondent to these two appeals applies to have them heard together or heard sequentially by the same court.  The appellants resist that course on the basis that it is unnecessary and will be unduly burdensome upon them.

  2. Some short history of this otherwise prolonged litigation is necessary.

  3. The appellants commenced litigation in the District Court in 2016.  They sought compensatory damages for loss of profits due to business disruption in respect of their newsagency business in a shopping centre.  The trial was heard in May 2020 and both the claim and counterclaim were dismissed.[1] In the trial the appellants contended that relevant limitation period under s 10 of the Limitation of Actions Act 1974 (Qld) was 12 years.

  4. In the course of the reasons, the trial judge held it was 12 years.

  5. An appeal from that decision was heard by the Court of Appeal.[2]  This court held that the trial judge’s conclusion on the limitation point was in error.  An application for special leave to appeal to the High Court was dismissed.

  6. The first Supreme Court proceedings were commenced in March 2018.  The underpinning of that claim involved the same general factual basis as had been alleged in the District Court proceedings.  However, the legal basis of the claim was different.

  7. Although the claim was brought in March 2018, the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Goldsmith & Anor v Resolution Life Australasia Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QCA 48
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Goldsmith & Anor v Resolution Life Australasia Limited, the applicants sought an order to have two separate appeals heard together or sequentially by the same court. The first appeal, CA 3320 of 2024, was against the decision of Wilson J, and the second appeal, CA 3379 of 2023, was against the decision of Crowley J. Both appeals involved similar factual backgrounds and procedural histories, raising concerns about potential inconsistencies if the appeals were not heard together. The primary issue for the court was whether the appeals should be heard together to avoid inconsistent findings and to ensure a coherent judicial process.

The court, upon reviewing the applications, found that the appeals were deeply intertwined due to their shared factual basis and the need to address the same limitation point. The court determined that unless the same court heard both appeals, there was a significant risk of inconsistent findings on the same facts. Additionally, the court noted that the appeal from Crowley J had been stayed since September 2023, further highlighting the need for a unified approach to both appeals. The court dismissed the contention that the appeals should be heard separately, as it would unnecessarily burden the appellants and respondents and could lead to an indirect attack on the orders of Crowley J.

Ultimately, Wilson J dismissed the application for the appeals to be heard separately and ordered that both appeals be heard together by the same court. The court's reasoning was grounded in the need for judicial efficiency and consistency, as well as the practical implications of a stay on one of the appeals. The court made specific orders to ensure that the appeals were scheduled for a joint hearing and directed the Registrar to set a timetable for the necessary procedural steps to achieve this.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal CA 3379 of 2023 be heard together with appeal CA 3320 of 2024.

2. That the Registrar determine a timetable to finalise the steps necessary to give effect to order number 1.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ultimately Wilson J determined that there was no misleading conduct that had the consequence of preventing the appellants being heard on the relevant matters. Her Honour dismissed the application.Consideration The above review is sufficient to demonstrate that the two appeals will almost inevitably involve this court considering the same background facts and procedural history, and competing contentions on the limitation point taken at various times. Further, it is almost inevitable that this court will be required to examine what was said and the positions taken with respect to the limitation point (among others) before Daubney J, Wilson J (on both occasions) and Crowley J. In my view, it does not matter that the basis of the appeal is said to be different in each case. The legal point might be different, but inevitably this court will have to traverse areas of evidence and factual findings that are common to both appeals. That raises several material considerations. First, unless the one court hears both appeals, there is a risk of inconsistent findings about the same facts. That risk is all the greater if the appellants take an inconsistent position in one appeal when compared to the other. Secondly, there is a risk, in my view, that if the same court does not hear both appeals, but only that against the decision of Wilson J in CA 3320/24, that the findings sought could amount to an indirect attack on the orders of Crowley J because it would impact upon the factual substratum for those orders. Thirdly, the appeal from the decision of Crowley J has been stayed by consent since September 2023, awaiting the decision on the application brought most recently before Wilson J. That application has been resolved, and there is no good reason why the appeal from Crowley J should not now be dealt with. Of course the decision of Wilson J has been appealed, but that, in my view, makes it all the more imperative that the two appeals be heard together, by the same court. The appellants’ contention is that they should not be put to the trouble and expense of having to address both appeals. Mr Goldsmith suggests that the appeal CA 3320 of 2024 be allowed to proceed first, on the basis that if the appellants are successful in that appeal, then the other appeal is likely to be rendered moot. That contention has only superficial attraction. The effect suggested will only occur if the result is one way in the appeal. If the appellants do not succeed, that leaves the appeal against the decision of Crowley J still on foot and unresolved. The appellants have already filed an outline of submissions in CA 3320 of 2024. Because of the stay, nothing has happened in the other appeal. There is sense in the approach proposed by the respondent, namely that the appellants produce the outline in CA 3379 of 2023, then leaving the respondents to do a combined outline answering both appeals. For the reasons I have expressed above, the appeals should be heard together. I make the following orders: 1.Appeal CA 3379 of 2023 be heard together with appeal CA 3320 of 2024.2.That the Registrar determine a timetable to finalise the steps necessary to give effect to order number 1.