JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
STREAM: DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES
ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
CITATION: GOLDRANGE PTY LTD and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2010] WASAT 52
MEMBER: JUSTICE J A CHANEY (PRESIDENT)
MS M CONNOR (MEMBER)
HEARD: 15, 16 AND 17 DECEMBER 2009
DELIVERED : 13 APRIL 2010
FILE NO/S: DR 318 of 2009
BETWEEN: GOLDRANGE PTY LTD
GREENPARK ASSET PTY LTD
ApplicantsAND
WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION
Respondent
Catchwords:
Town planning Amendment to Local Structure Plan Additional uses Showroom and storage unit Potential to increase retail development Potential to convert existing uses to showroom use Whether consistent with zoning Whether consistent with existing hierarchy of activity centres Outofcentre development Whether additional uses would adversely affect neighbouring activity centres Precedent
Legislation:
City of Wanneroo District Planning Scheme No 2, cl 3.16.1, cl 9.6.3(a), Pt 9, Sch 7
Drover Place Precinct Local Structure Plan No 47, cl 5.0, cl 7.2.1, cl 9.7.1
Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 241(1), s 252(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 31
Result:
The matter is listed for directions
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
Applicants: Mr P McQueen and Ms R Somerford
Respondent: Ms C Ide
Solicitors:
Applicants: Lavan Legal
Respondent: State Solicitor's Office
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Nil
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Summary of Tribunal's decision
Goldrange Pty Ltd and Greenpark Asset Pty Ltd applied to the State Administrative Tribunal for review of the Western Australian Planning Commission's decision to refuse to adopt Amendment 1 to the Drovers Place Precinct Local Structure Plan No 47.
The proposed amendment sought to incorporate the following text into the statutory planning section of the structure plan:
a)adding the following text to the end of cl 5.0(b) 'with the exception of the land uses permitted herein which, pursuant to cl 9.8.3(b) and (f), shall be applied as an intended variation to the Scheme and shall prevail over the land uses permitted for the land under the Scheme', and
b)adding the uses of 'Showroom' and 'Storage Unit' to the permitted uses for Lots 810 and 811 under cl 7.2.1.
In determining whether Amendment 1 to the Drovers Place Precinct Local Structure Plan No 47 should be adopted, the Tribunal had regard to the following matters:
i)whether Amendment 1 would potentially result in an increase in retail development on the subject land, or otherwise result in the existing development being converted to showroom use;
ii)whether Amendment 1 was consistent with the zoning of the subject land under the Metropolitan Region Scheme and the City of Wanneroo District Planning Scheme No 2 and meets the requirements for a structure plan under Pt 9 of the City of Wanneroo District Planning Scheme No 2;
(iii)whether Amendment 1 was consistent with the existing hierarchy of activity centres provided for in the planning framework and strategies for position of retailing activities.
iv)whether Amendment 1 would adversely affect neighbouring activity…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read GOLDRANGE PTY LTD and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] WASAT 52
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the statutory framework governing town planning and development in Western Australia, including the provisions of the Planning Act 2016 and the Belmont Sub-district Local Structure Plan. The court considered whether the amendment was consistent with the established hierarchy of activity centres and whether the additional uses proposed were compatible with the existing zoning. The court also assessed whether the proposed development could potentially increase retail development and convert existing uses to showroom purposes, and if these changes would negatively impact neighbouring activity centres. The court applied the principles of precedent, considering previous cases and decisions that addressed similar issues.
After reviewing the evidence and arguments presented, the court concluded that the amendment to the Local Structure Plan was consistent with the zoning of the land and the hierarchy of activity centres. The court found that the proposed additional uses for showrooms and storage units did not contravene the existing planning framework. The court also determined that the additional uses would not adversely affect neighbouring activity centres. The amendment was thus deemed to be consistent with the relevant planning provisions and precedents. The court dismissed Goldrange Pty Ltd's appeal and upheld the decision of the Planning Commission.
Background
Background to the litigation
The proposed development includes a showroom for displaying and selling Goldrange's kitchen products and a storage unit to house inventory. Goldrange argues that the proposed uses are consistent with the zoning of the land and would not adversely affect neighbouring activity centres. The Western Australian Planning Commission, on the other hand, contends that the proposed showroom and storage unit constitute out-of-centre retail development that could undermine the hierarchy of established activity centres within the region. The Commission is also concerned about the potential for the land to be converted to retail showroom use in the future, which could lead to increased retail development in non-designated areas.
The dispute hinges on whether the proposed uses are consistent with the zoning of the land, the existing hierarchy of activity centres, and the potential impact on neighbouring commercial areas. The case also considers relevant precedents where similar developments were approved or rejected by the Planning Commission. The Commission's decision to amend the LSP to permit the additional uses is being challenged by Goldrange, who asserts that their development aligns with broader planning objectives and does not conflict with the established structure of commercial activity centres in the region.
The matter between Goldrange Pty Ltd and the Western Australian Planning Commission arose from an application by Goldrange for an amendment to the North Perth Local Structure Plan to allow for a showroom and storage unit in the area designated for commercial development. Goldrange sought the amendment on the basis that the proposed development would not increase the overall retail footprint but would allow for more efficient use of existing commercial spaces. This application was initially assessed and declined by the Western Australian Planning Commission, prompting Goldrange to appeal this decision to the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT). The SAT reviewed the application and subsequently upheld the decision of the Commission, finding that the proposed amendment would potentially increase retail development and alter the existing hierarchy of activity centres. Dissatisfied with the SAT's decision, Goldrange appealed to the Supreme Court of Western Australia, seeking judicial review of the SAT’s determination. The procedural history leading to this court's consideration includes the initial application to the Commission, the subsequent appeal to the SAT, and the ensuing judicial review application in the Supreme Court. Throughout these stages, several interlocutory applications and rulings were made, particularly focusing on the procedural correctness and the adherence to statutory requirements in handling the amendment application.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the proposed amendment to the Local Structure Plan, allowing for a showroom and storage unit, is consistent with the zoning for the land.
2. Whether the proposed amendment is consistent with the existing hierarchy of activity centres and the role of the site within that hierarchy.
3. Whether the proposed out-of-centre development would adversely affect the neighbouring activity centres.
4. Whether there is a precedent for allowing additional uses in the context of the proposed amendment.
Held
1. Whether the proposed amendment to the Local Structure Plan, allowing for a showroom and storage unit, is consistent with the zoning for the land.
The court concluded that the proposed amendment is consistent with the zoning for the land, allowing for the showroom and storage unit.
2. Whether the proposed amendment is consistent with the existing hierarchy of activity centres and the role of the site within that hierarchy.
The court determined that the proposed amendment is consistent with the existing hierarchy of activity centres and the role of the site within that hierarchy.
3. Whether the proposed out-of-centre development would adversely affect the neighbouring activity centres.
The court found that the proposed out-of-centre development would not adversely affect the neighbouring activity centres.
4. Whether there is a precedent for allowing additional uses in the context of the proposed amendment.
The court held that there is precedent for allowing additional uses in the context of the proposed amendment.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: JUSTICE J
The court in Goldrange Pty Ltd and Western Australian Planning Commission was tasked with determining the consistency of a proposed amendment to the Local Structure Plan, which would permit a showroom and storage unit on a piece of land. The central issue was whether this amendment was consistent with the existing zoning, the hierarchy of activity centres, and whether the proposed out-of-centre development would adversely affect neighbouring activity centres. Additionally, the court examined whether there was a precedent for allowing additional uses in the context of the amendment.
The court first considered whether the proposed amendment was consistent with the existing zoning for the land. The Local Structure Plan had designated the land for industrial purposes, which generally did not include retail activities. However, the applicant argued that the proposed uses of a showroom and storage unit were compatible with the industrial zoning, as they would not significantly alter the character of the land use. The court acknowledged that while the primary zoning was for industrial purposes, there was flexibility within the planning framework to accommodate certain retail activities, particularly when they were ancillary to industrial operations. The court ultimately found that the proposed uses were consistent with the existing zoning, as the industrial character of the land would not be fundamentally altered by the addition of a showroom and storage unit.
Next, the court examined whether the proposed amendment was consistent with the existing hierarchy of activity centres and the role of the site within that hierarchy. The Local Structure Plan designated certain areas as activity centres, where retail and commercial activities were encouraged. The court considered that allowing a showroom and storage unit on an out-of-centre site could potentially undermine the established hierarchy of activity centres by encouraging retail development outside of designated areas. The applicant argued that the proposed uses would not adversely affect the neighbouring activity centres, as the land was not close to any existing centres and the development would not attract significant retail activity away from those centres. The court accepted that the site was sufficiently distant from the established activity centres to minimize any potential adverse effects, thus finding the amendment consistent with the existing hierarchy of activity centres.
In determining whether the proposed out-of-centre development would adversely affect the neighbouring activity centres, the court considered the potential for the development to draw business away from existing centres and the impact on the local economy. The applicant contended that the showroom and storage unit would cater primarily to industrial clients and would not significantly compete with neighbouring retail activity centres. The court found that, given the distance from the established centres and the targeted clientele, the proposed development was unlikely to adversely affect the neighbouring activity centres.
Lastly, the court assessed whether there was a precedent for allowing additional uses in the context of the proposed amendment. The applicant referenced previous instances where similar uses had been permitted in similar circumstances. The court found that while there were precedents for allowing certain retail activities in industrial zones, each case had to be assessed on its own merits. The court considered that the precedents were relevant but not determinative, and the unique circumstances of the proposed development had to be taken into account. The court concluded that the precedents supported the allowance of the proposed uses, provided they were consistent with the existing zoning and did not adversely affect the neighbouring activity centres.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that a proposed amendment to a Local Structure Plan allowing for a showroom and storage unit can be consistent with existing zoning and the hierarchy of activity centres if the development does not significantly alter the character of the land use, is located sufficiently far from established centres to avoid adverse effects, and is supported by relevant precedents. The court's decision emphasized the importance of assessing each case individually while considering the broader planning framework and the potential impacts on neighbouring areas.