Gold Ribbon (Accountants) Pty Ltd v Stoddart

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Gold Ribbon (Accountants) Pty Ltd v Stoddart [2003] QSC 332

PARTIES:

GOLD RIBBON (ACCOUNTANTS) PTY LTD
ACN 081 156 078 (IN LIQUIDATION)
(plaintiff)
v.
EWAN ALISTAIR JAMES STODDART
(defendant)

FILE NO:

S3821 of 2002

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court, Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

6 October 2003

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

15-19 September 2003

JUDGE:

Chesterman J

ORDER:

  1. Judgment for the plaintiff against the defendant in the sum of $885,000 together with interest at 13.5415 per cent from 18 October 2002
  1. The plaintiff’s costs of and incidental to the action are to be assessed on the standard basis up to 27 August 2003 and thereafter on the indemnity basis and are to be paid by the defendant

CATCHWORDS:

GUARANTEE AND INDEMNITY – THE CONTRACT OF GUARANTEE – CONSTRUCTION AND EFFECT – COMMENCEMENT OF LIABILITY – VARIANCE BETWEEN GUARANTEE AND PRINCIPAL LIABILITY - where defendant is sued upon loan guarantee but resists -  whether representations asserted would release the defendant from liability under guarantees – representations as to the term of the loan - whether alleged representations release the defendant from obligations as a guarantor

Property Law Act 1974, s45 (2)

Bank of Adelaide v. Lorden (1970) 127 CLR 185
Masters v Cameron (1954) 91 CLR 353

COUNSEL:

Ms K.E. Downes for the plaintiff
Mr R.G. Bain QC for the defendant

SOLICITORS:

Blake Dawson Waldron for the plaintiff
Johnsons Lawyers for the defendant

  1. The plaintiff briefly carried on business as a money lender.  Its customers were accountants in private practice.  It borrowed $25,000,000 from the State Bank of New South Wales (which became Colonial State Bank, which was taken over by the Commonwealth Bank of Australia) which it on-lent at a rate of interest about five per cent higher than it paid the bank.  The loans were unsecured.  In those cases where the loan was made to accountants who had incorporated a company to carry on the practice, a guarantee would be taken from the shareholders who practised as accountants.  The amount which could be borrowed was fixed by reference to the value of “receivables”, that is debtors of the practice to whom bills had been rendered.  The loan was not to exceed 80 per cent of the value of the debtors.  The borrowers were required to have and provide proof of a current policy of professional indemnity insurance.

  1. As a term of its loan from the bank, the plaintiff was required to effect a policy of insurance indemnifying it against any loss on its loan portfolio.  A policy was effected with HIH Casualty and General Insurance Limited (“HIH”) in


    February 1999.  By cl 3 of that policy the insurer was given the right of subrogation to take over and conduct, in the plaintiff’s name, claims relating to a borrower’s default.

  1. The plaintiff called its business “Accountants’ Funding Programme” and loans made by the plaintiff were recorded in a document in three parts.  Section A was entitled “Registration for the Programme” and set out…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gold Ribbon (Accountants) Pty Ltd v Stoddart and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] QSC 332
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Gold Ribbon (Accountants) Pty Ltd sued Stoddart on a guarantee. The dispute was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The plaintiff, Gold Ribbon (Accountants) Pty Ltd, claimed that Stoddart, as a guarantor, was liable for the repayment of a loan made to AS & Co, of which he was a director and shareholder. The loan had been issued by Gold Ribbon under its Accountants’ Funding Programme, a scheme whereby loans were provided to accountants, secured by their debtors. The loan was made in July 1999, with a term of 90 days, extendable by mutual agreement. The loan exceeded the value of AS & Co's debtors, necessitating a repayment of part of the principal. Stoddart resisted the claim, asserting that he was released from his obligations under the guarantee due to alleged misrepresentations by Gold Ribbon concerning the term of the loan.

The court needed to determine whether Stoddart's liability under the guarantee was affected by the alleged misrepresentations. The key issue was whether these representations, if true, would have discharged Stoddart from his obligations as a guarantor. The court examined whether the alleged misrepresentations regarding the term of the loan amounted to a significant variance from the terms of the guarantee, potentially releasing Stoddart from his liability. The court also considered whether the guarantee's terms were clear enough to be enforceable despite any alleged misrepresentations.

The court found that the guarantee was clear and unambiguous, stating that Stoddart would be liable for the repayment of the loan if AS & Co failed to do so. The alleged misrepresentations did not alter the terms of the guarantee, which was a separate contract between Stoddart and Gold Ribbon. The court held that there was no variance between the guarantee and the principal liability that would release Stoddart from his obligations. The misrepresentations did not affect the enforceability of the guarantee, as they did not pertain to the core terms of the guarantee itself.

The court ordered judgment for Gold Ribbon against Stoddart in the sum of $885,000 plus interest at 13.5415 per cent from 18 October 2002. Additionally, the court ordered that Gold Ribbon's costs of and incidental to the action be assessed on the standard basis up to 27 August 2003 and thereafter on the indemnity basis, to be paid by Stoddart.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Judgment for the plaintiff against the defendant in the sum of $885,000 together with interest at 13.5415 per cent from 18 October 2002

1. The plaintiff’s costs of and incidental to the action are to be assessed on the standard basis up to 27 August 2003 and thereafter on the indemnity basis and are to be paid by the defendant

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Judgment for the plaintiff against the defendant in the sum of $885,000 together with interest at 13.5415 per cent from 18 October 2002 The plaintiff’s costs of and incidental to the action are to be assessed on the standard basis up to 27 August 2003 and thereafter on the indemnity basis and are to be paid by the defendant The plaintiff briefly carried on business as a money lender. Its customers were accountants in private practice. It borrowed $25,000,000 from the State Bank of New South Wales (which became Colonial State Bank, which was taken over by the Commonwealth Bank of Australia) which it on-lent at a rate of interest about five per cent higher than it paid the bank. The loans were unsecured. In those cases where the loan was made to accountants who had incorporated a company to carry on the practice, a guarantee would be taken from the shareholders who practised as accountants. The amount which could be borrowed was fixed by reference to the value of “receivables”, that is debtors of the practice to whom bills had been rendered. The loan was not to exceed 80 per cent of the value of the debtors. The borrowers were required to have and provide proof of a current policy of professional indemnity insurance. As a term of its loan from the bank, the plaintiff was required to effect a policy of insurance indemnifying it against any loss on its loan portfolio. A policy was effected with HIH Casualty and General Insurance Limited (“HIH”) in February 1999. By cl 3 of that policy the insurer was given the right of subrogation to take over and conduct, in the plaintiff’s name, claims relating to a borrower’s default. The plaintiff called its business “Accountants’ Funding Programme” and loans made by the plaintiff were recorded in a document in three parts. Section A was entitled “Registration for the Programme” and set out the borrower’s name, address, contact details and insurer. Section B contained the details of the value of the borrower’s debtors, and Section C contained the terms and conditions of the loan. Relevantly, those terms were: The contract documents did not themselves provide for a date for repayment but this lacuna was filled when the agreement to lend and to borrow was made. At that time the plaintiff notified the borrower by letter of further terms, in particular: The programme was thus one by which the loan was made for 90 days but could be extended an indefinite number of times on each occasion by a further term of 90 days. Prior to the expiration of each extended period the borrower was required to inform the plaintiff of the value of its debtors. If the value fell so that the amount of the loan exceeded 80 per cent of that value part of the principal would have to be repaid so that the amount lent did not exceed the calculated maximum. Conversely the amount borrowed could increase. The guarantee required of shareholders of corporate borrowers was in a standard form. It recited: The defendant is an accountant by profession and a member of the Chartered Institute of Management Accountants. He has a degree in Business from Deakin University and commenced practice in about 1984. He was a director and shareholder of Aikman Stoddart and Co Pty Ltd (“AS & Co”) at all relevant times. He controlled the company which conducted its practice as accountants at Surfers Paradise.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established