Goel and DHL Supply Chain (Australia) Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

Goel and DHL Supply Chain (Australia) Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2022] AATA 1158 (13 May 2022)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2020/4078

Re:Gagandeep Goel

APPLICANT

AndDHL Supply Chain (Australia) Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

Date:13 May 2022

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal decides to set aside the decision of the Respondent dated 24 June 2020 and substitutes it with the decision that:

1.the Respondent is liable to pay compensation pursuant to s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 in respect of the following injuries suffered by the Applicant to his right wrist:

a.a tear in the triangular fibrocartilage complex;

b.inflammation and aggravation of degenerative change;

2.the matter is otherwise remitted to the Respondent for the determination of any compensation arising from his injuries; and

3.the Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs and disbursements in respect of these proceedings pursuant to s 67 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988.

..........................[sgd]..............................................

Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – claim for muscular strain of right scapula, pectoral and arm muscles, wrist – claim accepted as muscular strain right arm and scapula – later denial of liability for medical expenses and incapacity payments – wrist pain and underlying wrist pathologies –Tribunal jurisdiction over wrist challenged – wrist forms part of claim – Applicant suffered injuries – decision set aside and substituted

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

Cases

Australian Postal Corporation v Sellick [2008] FCA 236
Comcare v Luck [1999] FCA 100
Lees v Comcare [1999] FCA 753
Re Griffiths and Telstra Corporation Limited [2013] AATA 695
Re Marnotta Pty Ltd and Secretary, Department of Health and Ageing (2004) ALD 514
Re Williams and Australian Electoral Commission and The Greens (1995) 38 ALD 366
Telstra Corporation v Hannaford [2006] FCAFC 87

Click here to enter text.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

13 May 2022

BACKGROUND

  1. Mr Goel applied to the Tribunal on 6 July 2020 for review of a decision dated 24 June 2020 in which it was determined that the Respondent had no present liability for compensation for medical expenses or incapacity payments in respect of the Applicant’s previously accepted condition.

  2. Mr Goel was born and educated in India, he arrived in Australia in the early 2000’s and worked with the Respondent in warehouse and packing duties from around 2013. His relevant medical history includes a wrist fracture sustained in 2013 in non-work-related circumstances. During 2016 Mr Goel commenced work in a role handling and packing goods in cold storage.

  3. In late 2016 Mr Goel experienced symptoms in his right upper limb and lodged an incident report in early 2017. Mr Goel then lodged a claim for compensation on 25 January 2017 in respect of ‘muscular strain of right scapular pectoral and arm muscles, wrist’. On 23 February 2017 the Respondent accepted liability for ‘muscular strain of R scapular & R arm’.

  4. A recommendation was made in 2017 for surgical intervention of Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Goel and DHL Supply Chain (Australia) Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 1158
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a dispute between Mr Goel and DHL Supply Chain (Australia) Pty Ltd concerning a claim for compensation. Mr Goel sought a finding of liability for injuries to his right wrist, which he contended led to entitlement for medical expenses and incapacity payments. DHL Supply Chain had initially accepted liability for a muscular strain of the right arm and scapula but later denied liability for further medical expenses and incapacity payments related to the wrist.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Mr Goel's wrist condition formed part of his accepted claim for compensation, and consequently, whether DHL Supply Chain was liable for medical expenses and incapacity payments related to that injury. The Tribunal also had to consider the scope of its jurisdiction in determining the extent of the applicant's injuries, particularly in light of the respondent's submission that the wrist injury was not properly part of the claim.

The Tribunal reasoned that a claim form referring to "Muscular strain of right scapular pectoral and arm muscle, wrist" constituted sufficient notice of injury to the wrist. It applied the principle that a claim form can serve as notice of injury, citing *Comcare v Luck*, and that the Tribunal is not bound by the description of an injury by an earlier decision-maker, as established in *Telstra Corporation v Hannaford*. The Tribunal found that the evidence supported the conclusion that Mr Goel's wrist condition, specifically a tear in the triangular fibrocartilage complex and inflammation and aggravation of degenerative change, was a consequence of his employment duties.

The Tribunal set aside the respondent's decision of 24 June 2020 and substituted it with a decision that DHL Supply Chain was liable to pay compensation under s 14 of the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* in respect of the applicant's right wrist injuries. The matter was remitted to the respondent for determination of any compensation arising from these injuries, and the respondent was ordered to pay the applicant's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

More specifically, Mr Goel seeks a finding of liability in respect of his wrist leading to an entitlement for medical and treatment expenses, and a finding that his condition rendered him incapacitated for work, leading to an entitlement for payments for incapacity for work for all periods.EVIDENCEChronology Given the contentions arising in respect of the scope of the claim, I set out here a summary of the history of Mr Goel’s claim and treatment, with a particular focus on his right wrist. (Spelling in quotes follows source material). In his statement (Exhibit A1) Mr Goel states that:(a)treatment for his wrist fracture included a cast; after a few days he stopped feeling pain and returned to normal duties, forgetting about the injury until Dr Kostos called for Mr Goel’s medical records; (b)he was moved to the Cold Chain Department in August 2014; he felt that he was humiliated by his supervisor and was given the hardest jobs in the team;(c)his duties were confined largely to packing veterinarian orders in eskies weighing between 12-35 kg when packed, and closing them with tape guns;(d)he complained about pain, which increased in 2016, leading to the lodging of an incident report in 2017;(e)he did not undergo the recommended surgery as he considered that he would need household help following the surgery, which would involve strapping the site for six months;(f)he still experiences symptoms in his wrist and continues with the Respondent on light duties. At [52] of his statement Mr Goel expands upon the claim for compensation:I made a claim for compensation on 25 January 2017 for “Muscular strain of right scapular pectoral and arm muscle, wrist”. This is where I experienced symptoms. The shoulder and upper body on the right side was sore from the work handling the gun I think; but the wrist was very sore from behind the little finger side of the hand near the wrist. That was also hurting from using the gun as well as from picking up heavy boxes – that when I felt the pain. I felt this throughout the day and over 2016 into 2017 it got worse and didn’t get relieved by rest. The pain was felt in the shoulder, the arm, the elbow, forearm and wrist and hand. According to Mr Goel’s statement, his employment with the Respondent appears to have been marked by several instances of grievances lodged both internally and with the Fair Work Commission. In his oral evidence, Mr Goel explained that his packing duties in the cold chain area included lifting eskies from a trolley to a bench, and adding ice bricks, product and gel packs. This was followed by sealing in several directions and around the edges with tape guns. He described the guns as weighing 1 kg when loaded with tape. Mr Goel stated that in March or April 2016 his whole upper limb was sore. His later complaints were made verbally to his supervisor and site manager. Mr Goel’s treatment included physiotherapy with a hand therapist who provided a splint. Mr Goel agreed that he had also made a claim relating to his left arm which was accepted.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Notwithstanding the written and oral submissions in respect of compensation arising under ss 16 and 19 of the Act, I consider this matter was not conducted in such a manner as to assist in the formulating of relevant findings.DECISION For the reasons given above, the Tribunal decides to set aside the decision of the Respondent dated 24 June 2020 and substitutes it with the decision that:(a)the Respondent is liable to pay compensation pursuant to s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 in respect of the following injuries suffered by the Applicant to his right wrist:(i)a tear in the triangular fibrocartilage complex; (ii)inflammation and aggravation of degenerative change;(b)the matter is otherwise remitted to the Respondent for the determination of any compensation arising from his injuries; and(c)the Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs and disbursements in respect of these proceedings pursuant to s 67 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr Kostos expressed his disagreement with Mr Haig’s opinion about positive ulnar variance, and he considered this a significant risk factor for developing TFCC injury. It was put to Dr Kostos that both hand surgeons considered abutment syndrome a predisposing factor in the context of Mr Goel’s packing duties, and he accepted that work had aggravated the condition.CONSIDERATIONJurisdiction submission and scope of claim The Respondent cites Lees v Comcare [1999] FCA 753 (Lees) and a decision of the Tribunal, Re Griffiths and Telstra Corporation Limited [2013] AATA 695 (Griffiths) in its written submission on jurisdiction. The latter is cited in support of a contention that Mr Goel’s application is frivolous. The written submission then goes on to state that the Tribunal should affirm the decision under review. In submissions prior to the commencement of the hearing, the Applicant’s representative cited Telstra Corporation v Hannaford [2006] FCAFC 87 (Hannaford) for the proposition that decision making in this jurisdiction is progressive and evolving. Further, the Tribunal is not bound by the description of an injury by an earlier decision maker. In response, the Respondent contended that the situation was not governed by Hannaford. It was submitted that the medical certificates from the time of the claim do not support the view that Mr Goel’s wrist forms part of the claim and, further, the decision-maker is not bound by the claim form. The Applicant’s representative contended that Lees was not pertinent, and that the claim form referred to Mr Goel’s wrist, and this should be taken as notification of the injury. The decision of Comcare v Luck [1999] FCA 100 was cited, in which his Honour French J, as he then was, found that the claim for compensation could stand as notice of injury as it indeed purported to give such notice. This was based on the specific findings of the Tribunal to that effect. Reference was also made by Mr Goel’s representative in closing to Australian Postal Corporation v Sellick [2008] FCA 236 (Sellick), a decision relating to findings in a Tribunal decision about additional conditions not specifically mentioned in an accident report or claim for compensation. The Respondent contended in closing that the original delegate dealt with the medical evidence for the conditions as claimed. It was also contended that a recommendation for wrist surgery was made at a time when liability was still accepted for the shoulder injury. However, the Applicant cannot point to any accepted liability for a wrist injury and as the operation was not proceeded with, the issue lapsed. It was also asserted that the Respondent would have conducted a review of present liability on its own motion, prior to approving any surgical procedure. The Respondent’s written submission refers, arguably, both to dismissal by the Tribunal under s 42B on the grounds that Mr Goel’s application is frivolous, and to making a decision under s 43 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 affirming the decision under review. A decision under s 42B can be made at any time.