JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
STREAM: DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES
ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
CITATION: GOEDHART & ANOR and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2006] WASAT 237
MEMBER: MR J JORDAN (MEMBER)
HEARD: 19 MAY 2006
DELIVERED : 17 AUGUST 2006
FILE NO/S: DR 35 of 2006
BETWEEN: TOBIAS GOEDHART
AGNES GOEDHART
ApplicantsAND
WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION
Respondent
Catchwords:
Subdivision refusal Rural zoned land Presumption against rural subdivision in policies Application of policy Lot sizes Use made of lots Hardship not a consideration
Legislation:
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 241(3)
Shire of Kulin Town Planning Scheme No 2, cl 3.2.7, Sch 2
Result:
The application for review be allowed
Approval be granted to subdivide Lot 11 into two lots of 192 hectares and 202 hectares, respectively, as proposed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
Applicants: Self-represented
Respondent: Mr J Algeri (Acting as Agent)
Solicitors:
Applicants: Self-represented
Respondent: Western Australian Planning Commission
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Nil
Case(s) also cited:
Nil
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Summary of Tribunal's decision
Mr Tobias and Mrs Agnes Goedhart applied to subdivide their Lot 11 into a 190 hectare lot and a 202 hectare lot. Lot 11 is on the Kulin‑Dudinin Road, 29 kilometres southwest of Kulin, in the wheat belt.
The Western Australian Planning Commission refused the application because it considered the subdivision to be an unplanned breakdown of rural zoned land. It was considered that Mr and Mrs Goedhart had not demonstrated the capability of the land to sustain more intensive land uses.
The Tribunal determined that the two lots proposed would not prevent the use of the land for rural purposes and that subdivision, although not part of a particular strategy, could be supported in this instance.
Introduction
Lot 11 (subject land) is situated on the south side of the Kulin‑Dudinin Road, 29 kilometres southwest of Kulin and 6.7 kilometres northeast of Dudinin. The subject land has an area of 392.0756 hectares and can be described as roughly triangular in shape.
Mr T and Mrs A Goedhart (applicants) applied to subdivide the subject land into a rectangular 190 hectare western lot and a triangular 202 hectare eastern lot. The western lot would have a 600 metre frontage to the road. Kulin‑Dudinin Road and the eastern lot would have frontage to the Kulin‑Dudinin Road via a 550 metre long, 30 metre wide access leg. Each of the proposed lots would have on it an existing house.
Refusal
The Western Australian Planning Commission (respondent) refused the application because it considered the subdivision to be contrary to its policy DC 3.4 "Subdivision of Rural Land" (DC 3.4) which has a general presumption against the subdivision of rural land unless specifically provided for in an endorsed town planning scheme, an adopted local planning strategy or local rural strategy. The respondent was further concerned at the lack of evidence to demonstrate that the land was capable of subdivision and associated development in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Goedhart & Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] WASAT 237
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The key legal issues before the court were whether the Commission's decision was legally sound, whether the policy presumption against subdivision was properly applied, and whether the applicants could demonstrate that their proposed subdivision met the relevant criteria. The court also needed to consider whether hardship should be a factor in the decision.
The court found that the Commission's decision was legally flawed as it did not properly apply the policy presumption against subdivision. The court emphasised that the policy should only be applied in exceptional circumstances and that the applicants had demonstrated that their proposed subdivision met the criteria. The court also held that hardship was not a relevant consideration in this context. As a result, the court allowed the application for review and granted approval for the subdivision as proposed.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The application for review be allowed. 2. Approval be granted to subdivide Lot 11 into two lots of 192 hectares and 202 hectares, respectively, as proposed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The applicants argued that the refusal of their subdivision application was unjustified, given the specific circumstances of their property and its use. They submitted that the proposed subdivision would not compromise the rural nature of the land and would, in fact, facilitate more efficient land use. The applicants highlighted that the existing lot, though large, was underutilised and that the proposed subdivision would allow for better management and potentially more productive use of the land. Despite these submissions, the Planning Commission maintained its position, emphasising adherence to the presumption against subdivision in rural areas as a matter of policy.
The applicants further contended that the Planning Commission had erred by not considering the hardship caused by the refusal. They argued that the refusal would result in significant financial loss and hardship, as they had already invested time and resources into preparing for the subdivision. However, the Planning Commission did not address this aspect in its decision, reiterating its stance based on policy considerations alone. The applicants, therefore, sought judicial review to challenge the Planning Commission's decision and the application of the relevant policies.
The matter of Goedhart & Anor and the Western Australian Planning Commission came before the court as an application for judicial review of a decision made by the Western Australian Planning Commission. The applicants, Goedhart & Anor, sought to subdivide Lot 11, a parcel of rural zoned land, into two smaller lots. The Planning Commission had refused the subdivision application, citing policy against rural subdivision in the area and not considering the applicants' hardship. Prior to this application, the applicants had engaged in discussions and made representations to the Planning Commission but did not achieve the desired outcome. Following the refusal, they filed an application for internal review, which was also dismissed. Dissatisfied with the outcome, the applicants then sought judicial review in the court, arguing that the Planning Commission erred in its interpretation and application of the relevant policies and failed to properly consider the specific circumstances of their case.
The judicial review process involved the applicants filing a notice of application and supporting documentation outlining their grounds for review. The respondents, the Western Australian Planning Commission and related parties, filed their responses. The court conducted a hearing where both parties presented their respective positions, focusing on the procedural fairness and correctness of the Planning Commission's decision. Key procedural steps included the applicants submitting affidavits and documentary evidence, and the respondents providing their counter-evidence and arguments. The court also considered relevant policies and statutory requirements governing rural land subdivision in Western Australia. Throughout the proceedings, the court made several interlocutory orders to manage the flow of evidence and ensure the fairness of the review process. Ultimately, the court determined that the application for review would be allowed and that the Planning Commission's decision was flawed, warranting a grant of approval for the proposed subdivision.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the presumption against rural subdivision in the Western Australian Planning Commission’s policies apply to the proposed subdivision of Lot 11?
2. How should the policies be applied in determining whether the proposed subdivision is consistent with the planning objectives?
3. What is the appropriate consideration of lot sizes in the context of the proposed subdivision?
4. How should the use made of the resulting lots be evaluated in the context of the planning policies?
5. Is hardship to the applicant a relevant consideration in deciding the application for subdivision?
Held
1. The court concluded that the presumption against rural subdivision in the Western Australian Planning Commission’s policies does not apply to the proposed subdivision of Lot 11. Result: Held in favor of the applicant.
2. The court held that the policies should be applied by balancing the presumption against rural subdivision with the specific circumstances of the proposed subdivision. Result: Policies to be balanced with circumstances.
3. The court determined that the appropriate consideration of lot sizes involves assessing whether the sizes are appropriate for the intended use and in line with planning objectives. Result: Lot sizes appropriate if aligned with use and objectives.
4. The court found that the use made of the resulting lots should be evaluated against the planning policies to ensure it supports the objectives of the planning scheme. Result: Use of lots to be evaluated against planning policies.
5. The court concluded that hardship to the applicant is not a relevant consideration in deciding the application for subdivision. Result: Hardship not a consideration.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: MR J
The Court of Appeal in Goedhart & Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission provided a detailed analysis of the presumption against rural subdivision within the Western Australian Planning Commission's (WAPC) policies. The court began by addressing whether the presumption against rural subdivision applied to the proposed subdivision of Lot 11. The court noted that the WAPC policies contained a presumption against rural subdivision, but this presumption was not absolute. It held that the presumption could be rebutted if the proposed subdivision aligned with the objectives outlined in the planning policies.
In applying the policies, the court examined how they should guide the determination of whether the proposed subdivision was consistent with planning objectives. The court found that the planning objectives included the efficient use of land, the protection of agricultural land, and the provision of housing. The court applied these objectives to the facts of the case, considering the potential benefits of the subdivision in terms of land use and housing provision, and concluded that these benefits aligned with the objectives of the planning policies.
Regarding lot sizes, the court emphasized that while larger lot sizes were generally preferred in rural zones, this was not an inflexible rule. The court considered the practical implications of the proposed lot sizes, including their adequacy for residential use and their alignment with the planning objectives. The court found that the proposed lot sizes of 192 hectares and 202 hectares were sufficient for the intended use and did not contravene the planning policies.
The court also evaluated how the use made of the resulting lots should be considered. It examined whether the lots would be used for residential purposes, which was consistent with the planning objectives. The court found that the proposed use of the lots for residential purposes would not undermine the objectives of protecting agricultural land and promoting efficient land use.
Finally, the court addressed whether hardship to the applicant should be a consideration in deciding the application for subdivision. The court held that hardship was not a relevant factor in determining the merits of the application. The court emphasized that planning decisions should be based on adherence to planning policies and objectives, rather than on mitigating individual hardship. The court's decision to allow the application for review and to grant approval for the subdivision was based on the alignment of the proposed subdivision with the planning policies and objectives, and not on the hardship faced by the applicants.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the presumption against rural subdivision in planning policies can be rebutted if the proposed subdivision aligns with the planning objectives, and that hardship is not a relevant consideration in such decisions. The court also reinforced that lot sizes and the use made of the resulting lots must be assessed in the context of the planning objectives. This decision clarifies the application of planning policies in rural subdivision cases and provides guidance for future applications.