Goddard v Legal Aid Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Goddard v Legal Aid Queensland [2021] QIRC 154

PARTIES:

Goddard, Shelby
(Appellant)

v

Legal Aid Queensland
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

TD/2019/88

PROCEEDING:

Application for reinstatement

DELIVERED ON:

11 May 2021

HEARING DATE:

16, 17, 18, 20 November 2020

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

Pidgeon IC

Yeppoon

ORDER:

The application is dismissed

CATCHWORDS:

INDUSTRIAL LAW - APPLICATION FOR REINSTATEMENT - UNFAIR DISMISSAL - where the applicant is on a performance improvement plan - whether the applicant has performed her duties  carelessly, incompetently or inefficiently - whether the applicant has contravened without a reasonable excuse a standard of conduct applying to the employee under an approved code of conduct - whether termination was harsh unjust or unreasonable

LEGISLATION:

CASES

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld), s 316, s 317, s 320

Public Service 2008 (Qld), s 187

Code of Conduct for the Queensland Public Service

Coleman v State of Queensland (Department of Education) [2020] QIRC 032.

Dr Lucy Zhao v The University of Technology Sydney [2020] FWC 416.

Gold Coast District Health Service v Walker (2001) 168 QGIG 258

Laegal v Scenic Rim Regional Council [2018] QIRC 136

APPEARANCES:

Ms S Goddard as self-represented Applicant.

Ms J Marr of Counsel instructed by Crown Law for the Respondent.

Decision

  1. Ms Shelby Goddard (the Applicant) was employed as a Litigation Support Officer (LSO) by the Respondent, Legal Aid Queensland (LAQ).  During the time Ms Goddard worked for Legal Aid Queensland, she was situated in the Rockhampton Office.

  2. Ms Goddard commenced employment on 15 April 2015 on a temporary basis.  From 9 February 2016, Ms Goddard was permanently employed.

  3. Ms Goddard's role was to provide support to the two family lawyers.  Ms Goddard, along with other administrative staff, assisted with administrative tasks at the front counter, answering phones, attending to clients who came into the officer from time to time.

  4. During Ms Goddard's employment, the Principal Lawyer of the Rockhampton Office had overall supervision of her work performance. The day to day allocation of tasks and Ms Goddard's work was undertaken by the two family lawyers.  

  5. On 12 September 2019, Ms Goddard was informed that following a show cause process, a decision had been made to terminate her employment.

  6. On 3 October 2019, Ms Goddard filed an application for reinstatement.  The application was accompanied by an affidavit and the termination letter was included at exhibit A to the affidavit.

  7. Essentially, Ms Goddard argues that the performance management process that was implemented was unjust and had 'set her up to fail'.

  8. Ms Goddard does not seek reinstatement to her previous position.  Ms Goddard's application states that she seeks re-employment in another position that the employer has available and that the Commission considers suitable, and reimbursement of lost earnings.

  9. The onus is on the applicant to demonstrate that the termination (for disciplinary reasons) was harsh, unjust or unreasonable.[1]

    [1] Gold Coast District Health Service v Walker (2001) 168 QGIG 258, [259].

  10. The Respondent accepts that the onus falls on it to prove the findings…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Goddard v Legal Aid Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QIRC 154
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Goddard v Legal Aid Queensland concerned an application for reinstatement by Ms Goddard, a former employee of Legal Aid Queensland, who was dismissed from her position as a Litigation Support Officer. The dispute centred on whether the termination of Ms Goddard's employment was justified and whether she should be reinstated. The matter was heard and determined by the Industrial Relations Commission of Queensland. The legal issues that the court was required to decide included whether Ms Goddard was informed of the reason for her dismissal, whether the dismissal related to her conduct, capacity, and performance, and if the dismissal was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable. The court had to consider the evidence presented by the Department, which included testimonies from Ms Marita Kitchiner, Ms Louise Hedges, and Ms Stephanie Nicolas, as well as the relevant provisions of the Industrial Relations Act 1996 (Qld).

The court found that Ms Goddard was indeed informed of the reason for her dismissal, as evidenced by the termination letter signed by the Chief Executive Officer. The court also determined that the dismissal was related to Ms Goddard's conduct, capacity, and performance, as substantiated by the allegations of inadequate communication and task management. The court examined the performance improvement plan that was put in place to address Ms Goddard's deficiencies, which she had participated in setting and had signed off on. The court concluded that the dismissal process followed proper procedures and that the reasons provided were valid. The court found that the termination was not harsh, unjust, or unreasonable given the circumstances.

Based on the evidence and the legal considerations, the court dismissed the application for reinstatement. The court found that the dismissal was justified and in accordance with the law. The decision was based on the thorough documentation of Ms Goddard's performance issues, the formal process that was followed, and the substantive reasons provided for the termination. The court's findings and reasoning provided a clear basis for its decision, ultimately upholding the decision to terminate Ms Goddard's employment.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application is dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Department called the following witnesses:· Ms Marita Kitchiner· Ms Louise Hedges· Ms Stephanie NicolasReasons for decisionSection 320: Matters to be considered in deciding an application for reinstatementWas Ms Goddard informed of reason for dismissal? There is no dispute between the parties that Ms Goddard was informed of the reason for her dismissal. I note that the termination letter under the hand of Anthony Reilly, Chief Executive Officer provides the reason for termination.[11] Therefore, s 320(a) of the IR Act has been satisfied.[11] Exhibit 2, Affidavit of Anthony Reilly, AR-10: Penalty Letter dated 12 September 2019. The dismissal does not relate to the operational requirements of the employer and therefore s 320(b)(i) is not relevant.Did the dismissal relate to Ms Goddard's conduct, capacity and performance? With regard to s 320(b)(ii) of the IR Act, the termination letter clearly states that the termination relates to Ms Goddard's conduct, capacity and performance. Following the implementation of a formal performance management process, a show cause disciplinary process was commenced which led to the substantiation of the following allegations:Allegation 1 – that between 15 February 2019 and 3 June 2019, you failed to meet the expected performance standard required of you in your role as a Litigation Support Officer (LSO) with respect to appropriate communication with administrative staff; andAllegation 2 – that between 15 February 2019 and 3 June 2019, you failed to meet the expected performance standards required of you in your role as a LSO with respect to task management and appropriate communication with family lawyers (your immediate supervisors). The Respondent submits that:·from August 2018, Ms Goddard was warned of her unsatisfactory performance through a series of informal performance management meetings;·on 31 January 2019, the applicant was given written notice that she was not meeting the performance standards of her role and would commence on a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP);·the PIP process itself involved an initial performance improvement meeting on 13 February 2019 and then a series of eight performance improvement meetings between 6 March 2019 and 3 June 2019;·the PIP clearly articulated the areas requiring improvement, the required standard of an LSO in respect of each area, the action to be taken in respect of each area, and the expected outcomes;·Ms Goddard was involved in setting the terms of the PIP, and the final version as agreed was signed by Ms Goddard on 15 February 2019; and·the show cause disciplinary process commenced by letter of 12 June 2019, delivered on 17 June 2019, which notified the applicant of the two allegations against her and invited her to respond. That response was received on 1 July 2019.[12][12] Respondent's outline of argument filed 11 November 2020, [2]. Ms Nicholas prepared a script to support her performance discussion with Ms Goddard and introducing the informal process. The script clearly outlines issues with Ms Goddard's technical skills and professional interactions and presentation. The script addresses public contact & interpersonal skills at length.[13][13] Exhibit 11: email of 17 August 2018 containing final draft 'Performance discussion with Shelby Goddard'.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.